|
On January 26 2015 04:47 DarthPunk wrote:Show nested quote +On January 26 2015 04:44 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:41 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:39 DarthPunk wrote: Yeah cause I tried to get you all to lynch my scum buddy damdred over lurker LM yesterday.
Honestly. I've already said I can't look at you objectively right now. Thoughts on Damdred? EBWOP: Though come to think of it, since Damdred is obviously not going to vote for himself, we would still have lynched LM with no one else around at EoD. I'll look at your play later. Only cause you refused to switch off an obv mislynch...
If I switched on to Damdred your first counter LM would still be lynched.
I did not switch to Breshke from LM. I was wrong. I've admitted it. I don't know that Breshke was the right lynch, but LM definitely was the wrong one.
|
On January 26 2015 04:53 DarthPunk wrote: @jjb as you know rso best do you think she could have a filter like she does as scum?
He already said he thinks I could.
|
On January 26 2015 04:53 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On January 26 2015 04:47 DarthPunk wrote:On January 26 2015 04:44 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:41 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:39 DarthPunk wrote: Yeah cause I tried to get you all to lynch my scum buddy damdred over lurker LM yesterday.
Honestly. I've already said I can't look at you objectively right now. Thoughts on Damdred? EBWOP: Though come to think of it, since Damdred is obviously not going to vote for himself, we would still have lynched LM with no one else around at EoD. I'll look at your play later. Only cause you refused to switch off an obv mislynch... If I switched on to Damdred your first counter LM would still be lynched. I did not switch to Breshke from LM. I was wrong. I've admitted it. I don't know that Breshke was the right lynch, but LM definitely was the wrong one.
Ok so in your mind. I am scum with damdred and try to lynch him instead of lurker LM because with my mystical powers of foresight, I know that : shining, breshe and jjb, who are all town in this world, are just gonna not show up for the flip?
To me it seems like your logic is starting to break down.
|
On January 26 2015 04:58 DarthPunk wrote:Show nested quote +On January 26 2015 04:53 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:47 DarthPunk wrote:On January 26 2015 04:44 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:41 rsoultin wrote:On January 26 2015 04:39 DarthPunk wrote: Yeah cause I tried to get you all to lynch my scum buddy damdred over lurker LM yesterday.
Honestly. I've already said I can't look at you objectively right now. Thoughts on Damdred? EBWOP: Though come to think of it, since Damdred is obviously not going to vote for himself, we would still have lynched LM with no one else around at EoD. I'll look at your play later. Only cause you refused to switch off an obv mislynch... If I switched on to Damdred your first counter LM would still be lynched. I did not switch to Breshke from LM. I was wrong. I've admitted it. I don't know that Breshke was the right lynch, but LM definitely was the wrong one. Ok so in your mind. I am scum with damdred and try to lynch him instead of lurker LM because with my mystical powers of foresight, I know that : shining, breshe and jjb, who are all town in this world, are just gonna not show up for the flip? To me it seems like your logic is starting to break down.
I think I've said a few times I'm not sure about you. That is not the same as saying you and Damdred are definitely a scum team. I've also said I'm not sure about Shining.
|
Meh shining wasn't on a tablet for all of last game though, which isn't a huge point but he had a comp for a lot of the quotes he did besides that meh.
Here's the thing a better player than I told me that heuristic about waking up/staying up. Instead of attacking the idea, why didn't you instead attack it wasn't an unreasonable time? DP himself said it wasn't to bad?
Can someone besides rs tell me his Scum team pair right now? Or the two likeliest people and why?
|
|
On January 26 2015 05:01 Damdred wrote: Meh shining wasn't on a tablet for all of last game though, which isn't a huge point but he had a comp for a lot of the quotes he did besides that meh.
Here's the thing a better player than I told me that heuristic about waking up/staying up. Instead of attacking the idea, why didn't you instead attack it wasn't an unreasonable time? DP himself said it wasn't to bad?
Can someone besides rs tell me his Scum team pair right now? Or the two likeliest people and why?
I'm not attacking the idea; I'm saying it doesn't fit in with a suspicion that LM is scum, which is what you were demonstrably doing at the time you said that statement.
I have no clue what Australian time is in relation to my time and frankly don't care that much. DP, who actually lives there, would obviously have a better idea of whether or not the timing was reasonable.
|
Rsoultin has 19 pages. That's a bit of a surprise. Like think she could do it as mafia and the constantly repeating questions that have been answered surprises me. But 19 pages is a shit-ton for a newbie scum.
|
Wait when did you become unsure of shining? You were really sure of him before now rs?
Even though you've attacked almost every person toad you haven't mentioned breshke almost at all why?
|
The idea that dp is town for being in thread at a bad time is independent of lm being town? That's pretty simple
|
Like I'm actually not sure about Damdred. Or kinda anyone to be honest. Like shining looks really different, but there's such little meta to compare that it's not that useful and I didn't find his filter that great. Shining doesn't look great, but his argument that DP was intentionally tying himself to LM is an interesting one. I don't really put stock in it, but it's not the sort of argument I really expect from mafia. Breshke's response to almost being lynched was super fucking odd. But Damdred/Breshke I don't think makes much sense.
|
On January 26 2015 05:04 geript wrote: Rsoultin has 19 pages. That's a bit of a surprise. Like think she could do it as mafia and the constantly repeating questions that have been answered surprises me. But 19 pages is a shit-ton for a newbie scum.
That is her best case for being town. But Idk man she has gotten progressively scummier as the game goes on. And as you say she is rehashing the same shit a lot of the time.
|
Dp/Geript how hard was the push by rs onto trf to you? How was the follow up?
|
On January 26 2015 05:04 Damdred wrote: Wait when did you become unsure of shining? You were really sure of him before now rs?
Even though you've attacked almost every person toad you haven't mentioned breshke almost at all why?
I think you're scum. I know you're trying to push at least one town as scum. I don't think you're in it for the long game, bussing breshke for cred to ride out the game.
I relooked at breshke last evening. If I'm wrong, I'm still wrong; I still don't see anything damning in his filter. Being wrong in and of itself does not make a person scum. I get what geript's saying, but I know I at least have been told many times as a newbie not to make pre-flip associations, so if that's he only reason to scumread breshke, I think it's pretty weak.
I need to relook at shining. I don't really expect to see anything different, but that doesn't mean I shouldn't look when my reads are obviously off.
You completely changed your read of me. It happens.
|
On January 26 2015 05:11 Damdred wrote: Dp/Geript how hard was the push by rs onto trf to you? How was the follow up?
Need to reread it.
|
The D1 vote is actually quite interesting now. The 3 of the wagons are town with Damdred as the last. I wish BH had done the strikethrough to show where votes had been throughout. Rsoultin has her vote on Damdred there too for much of the day.
|
I actually think the push on trf is to sure and to aggressive. And the rest of the game rs is really passive and unsure about who Scum is.
After catching tr you would think the opposite is true. Those first few posts just totally to sure to fast
|
Like Rsoul/Damdred can't be mafia mafia here I don't think. Those two are actually pretty exclusive.
|
I think my vote d1 went lm then jarjar then warwaffle what a bad day, I was on cooltlbame before. Man my votes d1 were bad.
|
On January 26 2015 05:18 geript wrote: Like Rsoul/Damdred can't be mafia mafia here I don't think. Those two are actually pretty exclusive. Agreed.
|
|
|
|