|
On January 11 2015 07:47 Lazermonkey wrote:
Vivax, just food for thought: Do you think I would've reevaluated my read on both you and Damdred if I was scum? I was kinda meh on you and now I'm quite certain you are town, and Damdred was my top scum read and I now see him as town as well. This would be, like you are saying, narrowing down my lynch options far too much.
Honestly I figured you looked townie on the last few pages. Then you brought up the filter size argument and I was like "fuck it if they all have a boner for filter size I'll just have it too".
If you are town, then I'd much rather have you figuring out in the thread who is scum. You already mentioned Palmar, a good guess, but try to reach further than that. You could do some legwork on artanis and Kelsier as they haven't really been discussed much as scum altogether. Keep in mind that D2 scum's willingness to bus super must have been very high.
|
On January 11 2015 07:50 GlowingBear wrote:
Hm wait.
There is another theory
The theory is that they thought Robik wasn't really the cop and killing him would make ritoky look good
MEGALOL
And all these theories are helping you find scum exactly how?
|
Anyway still nothing to see from him since that one-liner from Palmar.
Most likely going to kill him after ritoky,
|
If I had to take out LM from the scummers I'd put SL in there.
GB doesn't shine townie since he prefers to dwell over theories that don't lead to any conclusion on who is scum...Except LM at the beginning, and if LM is town and GB is scum then pushing these theories is all he wants.
|
You can't confirm somebody based on assumptions like those.
You cited Carol mafia but that was an entirely different situation. HF was a roleblocker, not a framer, and a much better player than the other guy, that's why all scum conceded once HF died.
YOur example is that mafia saved ritoky to keep a framer alive to frame somebody in the next night when they kill the cop anyway.
|
But just the fact that this is me saying this and not LM when he's in the thread doesn't bode well for him.
|
Cause then he would have to call his teammate scum.
|
Considering what Palmar wrote:
The way I see this game we now have ritoky as confirmed mafia, damdred as likely second one, and pending further reading maybe vivax too.
Damdred is never mafia. I'm obviously not mafia. And Palmar tries to not lynch both of you (GB and LM), so a scumteam of you three just fits perfectly.
|
Also funny how how forgets to think about the third mafia. That's cause he is it.
|
The way I see this game we now have ritoky as confirmed mafia, damdred as likely second one, and pending further reading maybe vivax too.
Is this me being derp or does Palmar not list the fifth scum cause from his point of view he doesn't have to (since he knows he's the fifth).
So, a scumslip of sorts.
|
|
|
The puzzles, the emotions, the victories.
Mafia should become a sport.
|
I think I'll go into entepreneurship and launch a mafia gaming hall.
1. Hall Live mafia
2. Hall Video-Lan-Mafia
3. Hall: Chat mafia or thread mafia or something like that.
|
This will be the hidden gem. Only the best players from my gaming halls will be allowed to play here.
|
On January 11 2015 08:25 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2015 08:21 Vivax wrote:The way I see this game we now have ritoky as confirmed mafia, damdred as likely second one, and pending further reading maybe vivax too. Is this me being derp or does Palmar not list the fifth scum cause from his point of view he doesn't have to (since he knows he's the fifth). So, a scumslip of sorts. that's called having a conclusion already and retrofitting what you see to fit the conclusion
Not really sure what you're saying there, but if Palmar mentions 4 scum in his conclusions, why doesn't he mention the fifth. Cause right now it looks to me like he forgot to do that knowing that he's the fifth.
|
On January 11 2015 08:30 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2015 07:47 Lazermonkey wrote:
Vivax, just food for thought: Do you think I would've reevaluated my read on both you and Damdred if I was scum? I was kinda meh on you and now I'm quite certain you are town, and Damdred was my top scum read and I now see him as town as well. This would be, like you are saying, narrowing down my lynch options far too much. it's a reasonable point but it's kinda annoying that you're aware of it.
It's kinda good though. If he's on the boat for lynching Palmar I'd be cool with townreading him for the moment.
|
On January 11 2015 08:39 marvellosity wrote:
i think that's pretty silly tbh. i was saying you've started with the premise that Palmar is mafia and now you're fitting his posts to match with that premise. Palmar mentioning 1,2,4,6 mafia is really neither here nor there. It's not like he was even listing the mafia team. and I don't think i've ever seen any kinda comparable slip to that.
I am not going to go all out today because it requires effort and I'd rather have energy when it actually matters. The way I see this game we now have ritoky as confirmed mafia, damdred as likely second one, and pending further reading maybe vivax too.
Plus his reads on me and Damdred are wrong.
|
If you spot any oddities it's probably cause i'm slightly wasted, but only slightly, and I feel the stuff I write still makes sense.
|
On January 11 2015 08:46 DarthPunk wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2015 08:46 Vivax wrote:
If you spot any oddities it's probably cause i'm slightly wasted, but only slightly, and I feel the stuff I write still makes sense. Do you think marv looks scummy?
I think it's weird that a few pages ago he agreed with me on Palmar having done scummy stuff, and Palmar called him mafia on multiple occasions for reasons that half the thread didn't understand (I at least understood part of it), but it's not like marv went after him for that.
Now that I post this other stuff on Palmar not mentioning the 5th scum I just can't make marv see what I mean there and he's inclined to argue in favour of Palmar.
It does make me wonder what his motives are since I'd expect him to be more prone to lynching Palmar, but I need further conversation.
|
On January 11 2015 08:47 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2015 08:46 Vivax wrote:
If you spot any oddities it's probably cause i'm slightly wasted, but only slightly, and I feel the stuff I write still makes sense. gin & tonic?
And stolen pills.
Being sober is just too boring and I have no weed supply atm.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
