|
Oh yes.
Batsnacks isn't playing his normal "I don't care". But this is solely meta. I don't see anything alignment indicative on his posts.
Slam is a question mark. I simply can't read him. Literally.
Thrawn's posts are weird. They sound forced. It's like he can't post naturally. His posts feels like he is trying to adequate himself to the thread but doesn't really know how.
|
On October 24 2014 21:54 justanothertownie wrote:
Yeah, what about the snacks? And Robik "sucks"? That is your read on the guy you are still voting for?
It was a reaction vote, I'm going to change it and probably to vote kush.
He sucks because he is bad. But I don't have the same feeling that he is mafia like guilty. He looks more like town now. Robik is really hard to read.
|
gb i am very busy but I am reading the thread. how is that scummy?
|
On October 20 2014 10:19 kushm4sta wrote:
i love how i kept promising to do stuff but never did it.
On October 21 2014 09:26 kushm4sta wrote:
LOL rayn the game wasn't impossible. you just got owned. I acted so ridiculously scummy it was hilarious.
You better do stuff today if you want to live.
|
On October 24 2014 22:08 kushm4sta wrote:
gb i am very busy but I am reading the thread. how is that scummy?
Give reads. If you come back only when cited its pretty much a mafia trait.
|
Like
On October 18 2014 02:03 kushm4sta wrote:
do you have the flu?
do you work full time?
do you go to school full time for chemical engineering and get fuck tons of homework?
do you have a girlfriend?
yes to all those questions for me. so i dont think your business can compete with mine.
And you were mafia.
So I'm lynching you gladly 
|
Why nobody plays when I can play  ((
|
I am here from time to time. Why don't you go into more detail about your HF observation for example.
|
On October 24 2014 22:34 justanothertownie wrote:
I am here from time to time. Why don't you go into more detail about your HF observation for example.
Why him, specifically?
|
On October 24 2014 21:00 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 11:54 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:43 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:37 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:35 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:32 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:29 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:24 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:59 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 10:56 GlowingBear wrote:
[quote]
20 pages of thread and yes, I have a scumread on lian. The strongest, but not strong.
So you didn't had any reads at page 20? You think that it's impossible? I think it's entirely strange that the part I highlighted in red shows that you think that nobody has done anything towny at all yet and how it sucks but instead of checking if that's actually true and maybe re-evaluating that by actually reading the whole game and MAYBE changing your mind on your scum read on lian who you don't even know if he shits town rainbows since page 19 you decide to say that you're going to make a full blown case on him. Without reading the rest of the game. That's the strangest thing i've seen in a while. I was talking about the game until the page I was at. I'm sorry I had opinions on page 20 what use is a read up to page 20 when there's 20+ more pages to read and everything could have changed? It just screams of wanting to appear to contribute and get post count up because you're afraid of having an empty filter with no contributions There's a lot of content on 20 pages HF. I can give reads that nobody gave yet and it will also help you reading me. There's more content in 40 pages that would be more than enough to COMPLETELY change any read you have up on it's head, I don't even know why you're contesting this at all. You're literally working with 50% information and saying that it's better than 100%. If you had the same reads after you read all the game I wouldn't even be bringing this up but you're being stubborn on a point which is a no brainer. Ok HF, from the case I posted, what's different? I literally just explained it to you, he's baiting people for reactions and trying to get them to converse about him and made that list post about why he's playing a bit differently from last game where he was trying hard and got shot by the vig. He's disproved half your case. Like 50% of your case is that he's not playing how he explained but when does anyone ever trust self meta ever? Why does that make him mafia in the slightest, what stops it being someone disgruntled from being scum read why is it a mafia trait to be wrong about yourself!??!?! Like I said the only relevant part was that he hasn't posted his conclusions from reactions (I haven't even really checked if he actually has) but even then I've seen plenty of townies do the same thing and I actually even town read him for other things/not giving a crap about things sooo there's that too Best way to play as town right? Acting scummy to get people talking and not actually contributing to the thread. That's the thing, HF. He isn't bringing his conclusions regarding reactions. Any alignment can do that. And if he is town, he is playing anti town because he is making us wasting our time talking about him. The thing is - we are not lynching anti town players. We are lynching scummy players. Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 12:52 IAmRobik wrote:Controversial read of the game: GB is town + Show Spoiler +Based solely on the fact that he gave himself 3-4 outs to go to sleep and he continued to converse with people even though he coulda just peaced out That's not a towntell. I did that as mafia before.
Why do you think lian is town?
|
On October 24 2014 21:49 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 21:27 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 21:25 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 20:58 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 10:59 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 10:56 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:47 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 10:30 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:25 Damdred wrote:On October 24 2014 10:05 GlowingBear wrote:
[quote]
Reasons behind it? Bear, I think these are great reasons that these guys aren't the beautiful town they are pretending to be. look at storrs filter man, compare it to the other games he played in.Hes a serious person in every game, but everything is coming off so fake this game his fights seem fake. His pressure feels fake, everything about him seems fake. Hes also obtuse and he filled up the thread with a fight over nothing to get town disorganized at the start. Lian hasn't posted a lot of really insightful posts this game either. Last game I scum read him for refusing to do things, so my hesitation...actually screw that. Hes wishy washy a lot of his filter is fluff, he tried to get ff into a rage and has seemed to avoid things and takes soft stances i might of mentioned that already. hf gives some unsubstantiated reads, and his list of people he wants to lynch is mostly lazy people or lurkers. Could be mafia in their but just doesn't seem like a townhf thing to do. Storr was really serious when we both played mafia together. He also posted a lot less than he is posting now. So you believe lian and storr are mafia together. Do you think mafia would bus for so long, specially considering this is still day1? HF needs to step up, I'm also not liking his gameplay. On October 24 2014 10:40 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:35 Damdred wrote:
I know what you are doing here bear bear but i'll go along until i finish this drink.
People can change their playstyle to fit their needs.
The possibility is their, its probably a low possibility i have no idea how lian plays scum. But they seem a bit ok instead of just pushing each other they seem to be at peace so not seeing much bus after initial.
Bear, tell me your scum reads or are you still catching up I'm stilll at page 19. I don't think I'll be able to finish catching up today but anyway...
I want to call everyone in the game scum. Nobody has done anything quite townie yet. Which sucks.
But until now my strongest scumread is lian. Gonna make a case on him.Damdy, would storr and lian bus themselves so early if they are both mafia? what the fuck is this, you've read half of the thread, don't know what on earth people are posting yet at all because you aren't caught up with 50% of the game and you are already making a super strong scum read + wanting to make a case on them and you're talking about people's play throughout the whole game? 20 pages of thread and yes, I have a scumread on lian. The strongest, but not strong. So you didn't had any reads at page 20? You think that it's impossible? I think it's entirely strange that the part I highlighted in red shows that you think that nobody has done anything towny at all yet and how it sucks but instead of checking if that's actually true and maybe re-evaluating that by actually reading the whole game and MAYBE changing your mind on your scum read on lian who you don't even know if he shits town rainbows since page 19 you decide to say that you're going to make a full blown case on him. Without reading the rest of the game. That's the strangest thing i've seen in a while. It is strange. BUT YOU JUST SAW ROBIK DO IT. HOLY SHIT. On October 24 2014 11:32 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:29 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:24 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:59 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 10:56 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:47 Holyflare wrote:
[quote]
[quote]
what the fuck is this, you've read half of the thread, don't know what on earth people are posting yet at all because you aren't caught up with 50% of the game and you are already making a super strong scum read + wanting to make a case on them and you're talking about people's play throughout the whole game? 20 pages of thread and yes, I have a scumread on lian. The strongest, but not strong. So you didn't had any reads at page 20? You think that it's impossible? I think it's entirely strange that the part I highlighted in red shows that you think that nobody has done anything towny at all yet and how it sucks but instead of checking if that's actually true and maybe re-evaluating that by actually reading the whole game and MAYBE changing your mind on your scum read on lian who you don't even know if he shits town rainbows since page 19 you decide to say that you're going to make a full blown case on him. Without reading the rest of the game. That's the strangest thing i've seen in a while. I was talking about the game until the page I was at. I'm sorry I had opinions on page 20 what use is a read up to page 20 when there's 20+ more pages to read and everything could have changed? It just screams of wanting to appear to contribute and get post count up because you're afraid of having an empty filter with no contributions There's a lot of content on 20 pages HF. I can give reads that nobody gave yet and it will also help you reading me. Ahem, if you didn't read the rest of the game - how the fuck do you know if nobody gave those reads yet? Like wtf... On October 24 2014 11:41 Fecalfeast wrote:On October 24 2014 11:39 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:38 Fecalfeast wrote:
GB do what I did and read the thread all the way before posting again, the fifa analogy was shit but at least HF has read the thread. Bah. I will, but not now. I'm too tired. Gonna sleep. Why did you bother making a read based on the first 20 pages if you were too tired to read the entire game? Why not spend the energy you have reading the thread so you don't end up even FARTHER behind when you wake up? It would help everyone much better than what you have been doing since you got off work Very true. JAT, I didn't know at the moment, but it could be something new. Also, it would be a fresh read without any thread influence. If you see someone coming with genuine reads that is pretty similar to yours, it would (i) emphasise the person is scummy and (ii) make plausible that the person who brought similar reads are probably town too.I understand people prefer updated stuff but I see no harm into giving opinions while catching up. No. Because there is no way to verify that you didn't just rehash something someone else wrote later on in the game. It is just generally shitty. So are you completely caught up now or what? I think HF is playing kinda oddly this game. He looks like he is misinterpreting people a lot and I don't really see him strong pushing anyone. I was expecting more of his day one. I mean, he is calling out bad logic but not really pushing anyone.
This sounds quite damning to me and if you think so you should probably push him. It also sounds like you should be able to back that up.
|
On October 24 2014 22:38 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 21:00 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 11:54 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:43 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:37 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:35 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:32 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:29 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:24 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:59 Holyflare wrote:
[quote]
I think it's entirely strange that the part I highlighted in red shows that you think that nobody has done anything towny at all yet and how it sucks but instead of checking if that's actually true and maybe re-evaluating that by actually reading the whole game and MAYBE changing your mind on your scum read on lian who you don't even know if he shits town rainbows since page 19 you decide to say that you're going to make a full blown case on him. Without reading the rest of the game. That's the strangest thing i've seen in a while. I was talking about the game until the page I was at. I'm sorry I had opinions on page 20 what use is a read up to page 20 when there's 20+ more pages to read and everything could have changed? It just screams of wanting to appear to contribute and get post count up because you're afraid of having an empty filter with no contributions There's a lot of content on 20 pages HF. I can give reads that nobody gave yet and it will also help you reading me. There's more content in 40 pages that would be more than enough to COMPLETELY change any read you have up on it's head, I don't even know why you're contesting this at all. You're literally working with 50% information and saying that it's better than 100%. If you had the same reads after you read all the game I wouldn't even be bringing this up but you're being stubborn on a point which is a no brainer. Ok HF, from the case I posted, what's different? I literally just explained it to you, he's baiting people for reactions and trying to get them to converse about him and made that list post about why he's playing a bit differently from last game where he was trying hard and got shot by the vig. He's disproved half your case. Like 50% of your case is that he's not playing how he explained but when does anyone ever trust self meta ever? Why does that make him mafia in the slightest, what stops it being someone disgruntled from being scum read why is it a mafia trait to be wrong about yourself!??!?! Like I said the only relevant part was that he hasn't posted his conclusions from reactions (I haven't even really checked if he actually has) but even then I've seen plenty of townies do the same thing and I actually even town read him for other things/not giving a crap about things sooo there's that too Best way to play as town right? Acting scummy to get people talking and not actually contributing to the thread. That's the thing, HF. He isn't bringing his conclusions regarding reactions. Any alignment can do that. And if he is town, he is playing anti town because he is making us wasting our time talking about him. The thing is - we are not lynching anti town players. We are lynching scummy players. On October 24 2014 12:52 IAmRobik wrote:Controversial read of the game: GB is town + Show Spoiler +Based solely on the fact that he gave himself 3-4 outs to go to sleep and he continued to converse with people even though he coulda just peaced out That's not a towntell. I did that as mafia before. Why do you think lian is town?
The post you quoted did not indicate any read on him. I am not as sure about him as I was earlier before I knew that he already played mafia elsewhere but I still don't really want to lynch him. He doesn't care about how he looks to people and that is generally not a scumtrait.
|
Ok, I'm on the phone so it will be hard to quote, but:
Around page five of HF's filter, he says the thread should let FF retreat and comeback later with more consolidated reads.
Then FF comes back around page 7 and HF ignores him, putting him on a list and not talking about him at all. Votes for batsnacks. Then, he is asked to talk about FF and all he says is that, based on meta, FF looks genuine so he is not concerned with him. Why putting him on a possible lynch lost if he is not concerned with him? Or, is FF's meta really I fixative in a way that you can not be concerned with him?
Now, he is voting for batsnacks, but completely drops the push on bats to argue with Rayn. But he is not completely OMGUSing. He does not assume, explicitly, that Rayn is mafia. He just says Rayn might be trolling.
You see, HF is not following his reads. He just call people out for bad logic but doesn't really pushes anyone. He even dislocate threads direction out of FF who is acting weird, for no apparent reason. Says he isn't concerned with ff but keeps him in a list of possible lynches
|
That's sort of what I was tryin to say too.
GJ bear
|
I think the filter page numbers you just gave are off?!
I think I like what you wrote though. There were some HF posts recently that I really disliked too and that is generally a very bad sign.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Jat, robik catch up was NOTHING like rayns in the slightest. Also robik wasn't missing 50% of the thread before making an entire case on someone.
Gb, i never called ff's filter genuine ever. He's in my lynch list for Christ's sake you say I'm misinterpreting but then you don't show where at all. Ff's post on lian was uninteresting so i ignored it, like everyone else did. It proved nothing and he maintained scummyness.
|
On October 24 2014 23:02 justanothertownie wrote:
I think the filter page numbers you just gave are off?!
I think I like what you wrote though. There were some HF posts recently that I really disliked too and that is generally a very bad sign.
I read his filter and posted. I didn't have the page numbers in mind, just the facts.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
I'm pushing batsnacks and I'm still pushing batsnacks but i think i want to lynch kush even more at this point
|
On October 24 2014 13:16 Holyflare wrote:
i mean i read all his long post and i don't particularly see the total similarities between fecal in that game and this one but his other reads seem legitimate (from someone looking analytically at the game rather than meta/feelings of individual posts) and he has a lengthy posting style in his newbie which i think would be pretty hard to keep up with if he's mafia this game so much so that i'm not too worried about him at the moment
Legitimate, genuine... Whatever you may call it
|
On October 24 2014 23:04 Holyflare wrote:
Jat, robik catch up was NOTHING like rayns in the slightest. Also robik wasn't missing 50% of the thread before making an entire case on someone.
Gb, i never called ff's filter genuine ever. He's in my lynch list for Christ's sake you say I'm misinterpreting but then you don't show where at all. Ff's post on lian was uninteresting so i ignored it, like everyone else did. It proved nothing and he maintained scummyness.
Robiks catch up was pretty similar to GLOWINGBEARS catch up that you scrutinized so heavily.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
