Just got invited so in the end I won't be around tonight to see what happens. Still think mordek is scum obviously, but that means there's another one and that...
Had Cixah not been Innocent Child I could have accused him after he went on Wave, sudden twist to get him killed and ensure the final mislynch or something, but as I said at some point early Cixah's motivations can't be attacked, whether or not he's right. But that makes the remaining choice between Wave, Ghandi and Requizen... and Ghandi is ironically almost the most townie here. ><" Just because in the end the arguments against him wouldn't be as compelling as against the other two (in terms of quality of play).
Man... you see the whole "Alzadar or Cixah dies tonight" thing kills me because even if it meant scum is predictable and we can plan around that, it actually doesn't give us any new information about who they are. Which sucks. Inb4 I spend my first day of holidays reading through the two biggest filters of the whole game trying to solve that puzzle. ><
Req is basically a hail mary for me, I mentioned it twice already and that's part of why Asmodeus turning out town is super bad for my reads. >< As for you I posted one specifically for what makes me point you as scum on the previous page (it's spoilered).
So I'm not going to say "lynch x for sure", because I'm really not sure anymore. I was pretty confident of the Asmo lynch, and nobody really argued for anything else. Jeff was suspicious for a long time but has shaped up. Wave has been too much of a leader, if he's scum he's a god of deception. Alaric has been a top Town read forever. Requizen is focusing too hard on Wave, but has seemed pretty Town lately. Cixah is all over the place but at least you can trust his motives.
Good luck Town. Tomorrow is lynch scum or lose. We can still win, I think.
Whoops I skimmed that spoiler and forgot to come back to it Alaric sorry. You're going to be really disappointed when what you thought was scum play was just noob town. I explained why I voted Tolkien from the beginning. He was bing disruptive I felt. I had a feeling on soniv and Ghandi N1. I was going to poison Ghandi but said YOLO let's get soniv since Ghandi is easy d2 lynch. My vote in soniv to start was to make sure others thought he was worth killing. I should have let the poison go and hoped dandel wrote that part in. I don't have a good argument for anyone else. I thought you all were town at some point this game.
Right now I'm probably going to side with Wave on this one, but I think Req has a good shot at convincing me otherwise. Waiting for both sides before I make a decision here.
On October 20 2014 09:10 mordek wrote: This an Alz mislynch bait is my first impression.
That's exactly what I meant when I said I wouldn't be able to rely on my reads as much once I revealed them >< Also the reveal of Alz unable to protect himself that fucked with me and scum's possibilities.
Actually, whether or not Req is scum he'd have to answer this at some point: since there are now 2 scum and we don't have room for error, tunneling so hard on Wave won't make you win, even if he's scum (well, unless you are scum and he isn't, in which case you only need one mislynch). There'd be someone else to find.
If you're still bent on Wave being scum, then who do you think is the other one? Alternatively, assuming Wave died tonight (and flipped VT) instead of Cixah, who would be your new scum reads?
EPT![[image loading]](http://www.meatbook.de/uploads/tx_ddfrezepte/illu-rezept-lasagne_01.jpg)
