2p2 Vanilla Werewolf 13er - Page 71

On September 28 2014 23:49 justanothertownie wrote:

Of course he could. But right now he is pushing the right people in my opinion.

On September 28 2014 23:52 Palmar wrote:
Btw why was GB killed?

It's dumb speculation but I'm still interested.

On September 28 2014 23:52 Palmar wrote:
Btw why was GB killed?

It's dumb speculation but I'm still interested.

On September 25 2014 08:34 Fecalfeast wrote:
The fact that nobody was using the voting thread made me think they were joke votes. That's why I didn't use the thread anyway.

Lol I actually like your case holyflare

On September 28 2014 23:51 SkyDragon wrote:


If you had read that comment properly, you'd have noticed that those people are only suspects were Killing actually Mafia.

On September 28 2014 23:53 Palmar wrote:


This is my number 1 post for townreading FF. Holyflare's case is very obviously sort of a troll case, and it seems quite risky for mafia to randomly announced they like that case. It's much safer to just ignore it.

I'm also a bit confused by him. A lot of his attitude from day 1 feels pretty townie, but it doesn't feel very much like he is scumhunting since his reads posts on day 1. I guess I can't blame him with batsnacks and killing trolling the thread.

He goes into the tentative town column too, like Obi.

On September 28 2014 23:52 justanothertownie wrote:

So, do you think he is mafia or why are you asking?

On September 28 2014 23:57 justanothertownie wrote:

Meeeh. I think that's a weak read. I mean I agree with you that he isn't very scummy because to me his play looks pretty similar to last game but anyone could say that really. The case wasn't that bad for the start of the game.

On September 28 2014 23:58 Holyflare wrote:
The only reason to kill gb is for seer searching. Dunno if he claimed vt at the start of the day. The kill is pretty irrelevant anyway.

Really don't like Palmar's recent posts at all. Super silly town reads that aren't even certain and has nothing to do with the main wagons or anything to do with what happened at deadline or any actual analysis of anything

On September 28 2014 23:58 Palmar wrote:

I'm interested in your opinion, and I'd actually more like to know more specifics.

Basically, HF has a daunting 14 page filter. He's super annoying to deal with as mafia, and is actually very good at mafia. I still do not trust how he joined the Hopeless wagon yesterday, because I feel he should've made up his mind much earlier. It seems strange that after I posted the initial case on Hopeless, he kept doing other stuff for a long time, then joined much later with basically no new evidence (that is if I recall the events correctly).

I feel townflare is confident enough to make a call on my case right there and either disagree or agree. But then again, he has made a few good observations, and he's capable of that as mafia, but as town as well.

This is why I wanted him checked. Problem is the worst player in town seems to have gotten the cop role, so all we're getting out of that is a self-claim + 1 green, which is just as bad as if he had claimed on day 1.

Anyway, I'm almost definitely going to leave HF until last while reading the potential targets, and I'm super afraid I will actually not lynch him ever if he's mafia, because it's just too much work.

On September 28 2014 23:59 Palmar wrote:

Of course. But the lol is important, as in he is not overselling his buy-in on the case. The fact that he wrote "lol" shows that he recognizes it's a bit of a troll case, and he is still willing to support it.

On September 29 2014 00:01 batsnacks wrote:
Palmar is repeating himself.

On September 29 2014 00:02 justanothertownie wrote:

That's true but I still think that is not enough to townread him.

On September 29 2014 00:01 justanothertownie wrote:

I really am the wrong person to ask here. I have an abysmal track record for catching scum HF. He is responsible for 2 of my recent failures.

On September 29 2014 00:04 Palmar wrote:

Sure, you don't have to townread him, but it's still better than anything else I have. Like if I read you, hf, haru, sky, superbia, storr and you all look super town, I'll be all for lynching FF, but at the moment he feels more in the town column, mostly based on this.