|
Canada11355 Posts
geript, you claimed and then shortly thereafter unclaimed the role that shoots people when they visit.
You then tried to make a point about palmar
On September 18 2014 02:24 geript wrote:
Also for the record, Palmer being okay with me is like really odd:
1. I lied and apparently Rayn lied. That's like 2 strikes
2. I claimed.
3. I'm me. He usually reads me very well and hasn't quite bothered making a serious read.
4. Wouldn't be the first time...LXI...Palmer vs BC vs Super Scummer Geript.
Seems kinda odd for him not to want to lynch me with fire.
In what scenario does this point make you town and palmar mafia? If you are a town with a plethora of reasons to be called mafia you are an easy target for a mislynch and if palmar is mafia he is missing a really good chance to lead another mislynch wagon.
If you're both mafia, this is just a really dumb post so I don't think that.
Palmar doesn't necessarily have to think you are mafia, even with all the current questions about you, it's his read. You have all the heat from recent posts and obviously want to redirect it as mafia or town but why did you pick palmar? Just because he 'usually reads you' and didn't this time? I don't like it.
|
On September 18 2014 04:03 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 04:02 justanothertownie wrote:On September 18 2014 03:58 VisceraEyes wrote:
Re: batsnacks
Early on I thought he was a little suspicious based on the things he chose to do when he was here - he looked like he was participating in the trolly intro portion of D1 and then just kinda disappeared when stuff started getting real. When he came back he looked a little better, but he didn't really add a whole lot in the way of actual content.
I'm looking at lynching Batsnacks tomorrow barring a stellar day from him. Feel free to push him but right now I wouldn't lynch him over the someone like geript. That's fair, and I'm not like TOWNREADING geript, just want him to have a fair chance to catch up if he's town. I'll certainly hear arguments for geriptScum tomorrow.
Yeah, I think that's reasonable. But geript should really just read the thread then instead of filterdiving multiple people.
|
On September 18 2014 04:09 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 04:03 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 18 2014 04:02 justanothertownie wrote:On September 18 2014 03:58 VisceraEyes wrote:
Re: batsnacks
Early on I thought he was a little suspicious based on the things he chose to do when he was here - he looked like he was participating in the trolly intro portion of D1 and then just kinda disappeared when stuff started getting real. When he came back he looked a little better, but he didn't really add a whole lot in the way of actual content.
I'm looking at lynching Batsnacks tomorrow barring a stellar day from him. Feel free to push him but right now I wouldn't lynch him over the someone like geript. That's fair, and I'm not like TOWNREADING geript, just want him to have a fair chance to catch up if he's town. I'll certainly hear arguments for geriptScum tomorrow. Yeah, I think that's reasonable. But geript should really just read the thread then instead of filterdiving multiple people.
People read in different ways. And frankly with as much piss and vinegar as is in this thread, I wouldn't begrudge anyone taking shortcuts.
But yeah, context is key. I trust geript to countercheck anything suspicious he finds with the thread to make sure nothing is taken out of context, but not so much that I won't make sure.
|
Geript,
At what point in reading the game aka catching up did you decide that you were going to claim PGO? Please point me to the post or the page when it clicked that that's the towniest thing you can do at that moment.
Also, did you read any of Rayn's posts before posting?
|
On September 18 2014 04:11 IAmRobik wrote:
Geript,
At what point in reading the game aka catching up did you decide that you were going to claim PGO? Please point me to the post or the page when it clicked that that's the towniest thing you can do at that moment.
Also, did you read any of Rayn's posts before posting?
Like, I want you to break down exactly how you went about reading the game/catching up. Like what you did first. What you did next. Then what you did. All the way up to the point where you claimed PGO.
|
Canada11355 Posts
I would be okay with learning that, too.
Why don't you think I am me, Robik?
|
On September 18 2014 04:14 Fecalfeast wrote:
I would be okay with learning that, too.
Why don't you think I am me, Robik?
Cause the way you talk about meta reads and the way you're not interacting nervously at all and giving your thoughts and joking around and all these things are not indicative of a new player. And when you ask questions, you ask them in such a weird awkward way as if you know the answer and you just want it to be clarified for you as if you're acting dumb (i.e. wouldn't that make koshi scummier if he was pushing on kush who was town)
|
On September 18 2014 04:04 Fecalfeast wrote:geript, you claimed and then shortly thereafter unclaimed the role that shoots people when they visit. You then tried to make a point about palmar Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 02:24 geript wrote:
Also for the record, Palmer being okay with me is like really odd:
1. I lied and apparently Rayn lied. That's like 2 strikes
2. I claimed.
3. I'm me. He usually reads me very well and hasn't quite bothered making a serious read.
4. Wouldn't be the first time...LXI...Palmer vs BC vs Super Scummer Geript.
Seems kinda odd for him not to want to lynch me with fire. In what scenario does this point make you town and palmar mafia? If you are a town with a plethora of reasons to be called mafia you are an easy target for a mislynch and if palmar is mafia he is missing a really good chance to lead another mislynch wagon. If you're both mafia, this is just a really dumb post so I don't think that. Palmar doesn't necessarily have to think you are mafia, even with all the current questions about you, it's his read. You have all the heat from recent posts and obviously want to redirect it as mafia or town but why did you pick palmar? Just because he 'usually reads you' and didn't this time? I don't like it.
Why did I pick Palmer? Because him acting the way he is is out of character for the town Palmer I know. Like the no reaction is really fucking out of place if he's town.
|
I expect someone faking being new to ask "wouldn't it make koshi scummier that he's pushing on town!kush"
I expect someone who is actually new to state "koshi is scummier for pushing town!kush"
I think that both of those things are wrong. I think most vets would agree that koshi is townier for the way he pushed hard on Kush. Mafia tend to sit back and let lynches happen (for the most part), especialyl when they're mislynches. They don't want their hands dirty of anything bad. Which was why I accused VE earlier. He seemed like he was willing to push on Palmar, but didn't want to be suspected if Palmar flipped town. Like "hey guys, look, i even said that he might flip town"
|
On September 18 2014 03:41 Fecalfeast wrote:I just woke up, i fell asleep before GSL even started. Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 01:33 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 17 2014 23:06 IAmRobik wrote:
Pg 120, I still don't believe this is Fecal's first game. I agree with this. This means I'm playing well? I don't think I am.
This means you're using terminology correctly that I wouldn't expect a first-time player to use correctly - you're thinking about things in a way a townie who has looked for scum before looks at things. At least in my opinion. You could say playing well, I just call it playing. "Well" remains to be seen, because you haven't tried to convince anyone of anything and we don't know if any of your reads are good.
|
On September 18 2014 04:20 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 03:41 Fecalfeast wrote:I just woke up, i fell asleep before GSL even started. On September 18 2014 01:33 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 17 2014 23:06 IAmRobik wrote:
Pg 120, I still don't believe this is Fecal's first game. I agree with this. This means I'm playing well? I don't think I am. This means you're using terminology correctly that I wouldn't expect a first-time player to use correctly - you're thinking about things in a way a townie who has looked for scum before looks at things. At least in my opinion. You could say playing well, I just call it playing. "Well" remains to be seen, because you haven't tried to convince anyone of anything and we don't know if any of your reads are good.
Like frankly if this IS your first time playing then I feel like you're getting outside help and you may be mafia.
IS this your first time playing?
|
On September 18 2014 04:19 IAmRobik wrote:
I expect someone faking being new to ask "wouldn't it make koshi scummier that he's pushing on town!kush"
I expect someone who is actually new to state "koshi is scummier for pushing town!kush"
I think that both of those things are wrong. I think most vets would agree that koshi is townier for the way he pushed hard on Kush. Mafia tend to sit back and let lynches happen (for the most part), especialyl when they're mislynches. They don't want their hands dirty of anything bad. Which was why I accused VE earlier. He seemed like he was willing to push on Palmar, but didn't want to be suspected if Palmar flipped town. Like "hey guys, look, i even said that he might flip town"
I wouldn't really say I was ever "willing to push on Palmar". I VOTED on Palmar, sure, but I never did any of the "pushing". I would agree with this reasoning if not for that and try and explain myself further, but like I said then, I wasn't pushing Palmar because I didn't really think Palmar was super mafia. In fact, I intimated the polar opposite, that I had a townread on Palmar based on something in the thread. So why vote? Because my townies (GOOD, STRONG townies) said Palmar was mafia. *shrug*
|
Canada11355 Posts
I'm using terminology correctly because I'm reading the game, processing it through my brain unit, and regurgitating them through my fingers.
Robik you said that I'm not acting nervously at all then in your next post said I'm posting as if I'm acting dumb.
The way I posted the koshi 'read' was nervously as I felt pressured into saying something, anything even though I wasn't solid on any reads but people were asking.
However I do think I understand what's expected of me now.
Who did/do you think I am? Is he cool?
|
On September 18 2014 04:25 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 04:19 IAmRobik wrote:
I expect someone faking being new to ask "wouldn't it make koshi scummier that he's pushing on town!kush"
I expect someone who is actually new to state "koshi is scummier for pushing town!kush"
I think that both of those things are wrong. I think most vets would agree that koshi is townier for the way he pushed hard on Kush. Mafia tend to sit back and let lynches happen (for the most part), especialyl when they're mislynches. They don't want their hands dirty of anything bad. Which was why I accused VE earlier. He seemed like he was willing to push on Palmar, but didn't want to be suspected if Palmar flipped town. Like "hey guys, look, i even said that he might flip town" I wouldn't really say I was ever "willing to push on Palmar". I VOTED on Palmar, sure, but I never did any of the "pushing". I would agree with this reasoning if not for that and try and explain myself further, but like I said then, I wasn't pushing Palmar because I didn't really think Palmar was super mafia. In fact, I intimated the polar opposite, that I had a townread on Palmar based on something in the thread. So why vote? Because my townies (GOOD, STRONG townies) said Palmar was mafia. *shrug*
Why are you still harping on this. I'm not pushing you. I used this as a freaking example to explain to fecal what I meant and my general feelings on scum/town motivations. There's absolutely 0 reason that you need to respond to that post
|
On September 18 2014 04:25 Fecalfeast wrote:
I'm using terminology correctly because I'm reading the game, processing it through my brain unit, and regurgitating them through my fingers.
Robik you said that I'm not acting nervously at all then in your next post said I'm posting as if I'm acting dumb.
The way I posted the koshi 'read' was nervously as I felt pressured into saying something, anything even though I wasn't solid on any reads but people were asking.
However I do think I understand what's expected of me now.
Who did/do you think I am? Is he cool?
I didn't doubt you until you wrote this. wtf
|
On September 18 2014 04:26 IAmRobik wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 04:25 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 18 2014 04:19 IAmRobik wrote:
I expect someone faking being new to ask "wouldn't it make koshi scummier that he's pushing on town!kush"
I expect someone who is actually new to state "koshi is scummier for pushing town!kush"
I think that both of those things are wrong. I think most vets would agree that koshi is townier for the way he pushed hard on Kush. Mafia tend to sit back and let lynches happen (for the most part), especialyl when they're mislynches. They don't want their hands dirty of anything bad. Which was why I accused VE earlier. He seemed like he was willing to push on Palmar, but didn't want to be suspected if Palmar flipped town. Like "hey guys, look, i even said that he might flip town" I wouldn't really say I was ever "willing to push on Palmar". I VOTED on Palmar, sure, but I never did any of the "pushing". I would agree with this reasoning if not for that and try and explain myself further, but like I said then, I wasn't pushing Palmar because I didn't really think Palmar was super mafia. In fact, I intimated the polar opposite, that I had a townread on Palmar based on something in the thread. So why vote? Because my townies (GOOD, STRONG townies) said Palmar was mafia. *shrug* Why are you still harping on this. I'm not pushing you. I used this as a freaking example to explain to fecal what I meant and my general feelings on scum/town motivations. There's absolutely 0 reason that you need to respond to that post
I'm not harping - that you brought it up made me think you still thought it or whatever so I responded to it.
|
On September 18 2014 04:27 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 04:26 IAmRobik wrote:On September 18 2014 04:25 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 18 2014 04:19 IAmRobik wrote:
I expect someone faking being new to ask "wouldn't it make koshi scummier that he's pushing on town!kush"
I expect someone who is actually new to state "koshi is scummier for pushing town!kush"
I think that both of those things are wrong. I think most vets would agree that koshi is townier for the way he pushed hard on Kush. Mafia tend to sit back and let lynches happen (for the most part), especialyl when they're mislynches. They don't want their hands dirty of anything bad. Which was why I accused VE earlier. He seemed like he was willing to push on Palmar, but didn't want to be suspected if Palmar flipped town. Like "hey guys, look, i even said that he might flip town" I wouldn't really say I was ever "willing to push on Palmar". I VOTED on Palmar, sure, but I never did any of the "pushing". I would agree with this reasoning if not for that and try and explain myself further, but like I said then, I wasn't pushing Palmar because I didn't really think Palmar was super mafia. In fact, I intimated the polar opposite, that I had a townread on Palmar based on something in the thread. So why vote? Because my townies (GOOD, STRONG townies) said Palmar was mafia. *shrug* Why are you still harping on this. I'm not pushing you. I used this as a freaking example to explain to fecal what I meant and my general feelings on scum/town motivations. There's absolutely 0 reason that you need to respond to that post I'm not harping - that you brought it up made me think you still thought it or whatever so I responded to it.
Like, you literally go out of your way earlier to say that you think I could be mafia still (it's implied in your posts if you just go read them!) then you mention this. I'm not harping, I'm just trying to clear the air.
|
On September 18 2014 04:25 Fecalfeast wrote:
I'm using terminology correctly because I'm reading the game, processing it through my brain unit, and regurgitating them through my fingers.
Robik you said that I'm not acting nervously at all then in your next post said I'm posting as if I'm acting dumb.
The way I posted the koshi 'read' was nervously as I felt pressured into saying something, anything even though I wasn't solid on any reads but people were asking.
However I do think I understand what's expected of me now.
Who did/do you think I am? Is he cool?
Yes. You're not acting nervously, but it seems like you're playing dumb. I feel I've explained this. I thought that your rock star post, although it doesn't matter anymore, was really like cool, calm, and collected. You're doing very well to "fit in."
I don't think you're anyone in particular, just that you're not new.
It doesn't matter though. I feel kinda good about your being town.
|
But actually - look at hist posting history guys. I still doubt that Fecal isn't new.
|
Canada11355 Posts
On September 18 2014 04:27 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2014 04:25 Fecalfeast wrote:
I'm using terminology correctly because I'm reading the game, processing it through my brain unit, and regurgitating them through my fingers.
Robik you said that I'm not acting nervously at all then in your next post said I'm posting as if I'm acting dumb.
The way I posted the koshi 'read' was nervously as I felt pressured into saying something, anything even though I wasn't solid on any reads but people were asking.
However I do think I understand what's expected of me now.
Who did/do you think I am? Is he cool? I didn't doubt you until you wrote this. wtf
So you doubt that I am new, now?
I'm gonna take all this as a compliment and move on, I think. If you think I am a smurf, act accordingly but I assure you this is my only account.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
