|
On September 10 2014 04:54 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On September 10 2014 04:50 IAmRobik wrote:On September 10 2014 04:47 Damdred wrote:
Ok, Rob.
Talk to me about geript, what do you think about him sticking his vote on syl and not moving it after he claimed and nobody has cc'd it? What else makes you not trust him? That's weird that you automatically presume that that's what makes me not trust him. I don't trust his reads. None of them are well formed nor based on the occurrences of this game. He seems to be saying a lot of stuff but it's all meh He keeps throwing dirt on me and I know I'm town. Besides haru, he's spent a lot of time calling townies scum. Nah, I think you've played this setup before. I'm less looking at you and more at setup newbs right now. Potentially Yam because of how distanced he's been I could see him not wisely using KP. But I'm looking more seriously at like Sloosh, Harurh, Damdred, Sylencia, etc. I still don't buy Sylencia's claim whatsoever.
I wonder if scum get information on the role of the person they tried to kill or if they get the name of the role that died. That's a bit unclear
mod, can you please specifiy
|
What does me playing this setup have to do with anything?
|
I probably should of broken that up better, the first was a question that I was curious about from your perspective, because it bothered me to an extent.
With his reads, most of them are meta reads I think. Do you think hes twisting the meta reads to fit the narrative of those people being scummy? Also the people hes putting those types of reads on do they have stuff in the game that would fit the scum better you think?
|
Geri, why do you nto buy syl claim? Is it only cause he said he did not look at who the inquisitor was?
|
On September 10 2014 05:00 Damdred wrote:
I probably should of broken that up better, the first was a question that I was curious about from your perspective, because it bothered me to an extent.
With his reads, most of them are meta reads I think. Do you think hes twisting the meta reads to fit the narrative of those people being scummy? Also the people hes putting those types of reads on do they have stuff in the game that would fit the scum better you think?
I don't think he's twisting anything. He might actually believe what he's saying.
1) doesn't make them right
2) i don't know that they're even really applicable. They're so fucking broad/lack generalization, that it sounds like he's just throwing around words here and there and calling it meta reads
|
On September 10 2014 04:58 IAmRobik wrote:
What does me playing this setup have to do with anything?
Because you'd know that you get a free soup shot. Soup Martyr + some number is a freebie shot at more than one kill and better information on souping later on.
|
On September 10 2014 05:01 Damdred wrote:
Geri, why do you nto buy syl claim? Is it only cause he said he did not look at who the inquisitor was?
Because if he's Acolyte, why would he ever consider claiming? What purpose does it serve? None. It doesn't help town at all it only disadvantages town because we're forced to lynch him.
Second, how he pre-claimed is fucking awful. Not awful as in it's so goddamn awful he must be town, but awful as in, "I'm getting my fake claim ready and want to prepare people for it.
Third, the whole point of being acolyte is that you know to not lynch the Inquisitor and you get someone with an honest opinion that you can reflect your thoughts and leads off of. What acolyte who is town thinks, "Man I shouldn't look at who the inquisitor is so that I don't reveal him" instead of, "Great that's 1 less person I can mostly ignore seriously looking into and get to view his opinions as honest."
Fourth, look at how Palmer stated roles went out. How in the fuck does he not see who is inquisitor? Like I try to do that a bunch as mafia and I'l always catch at least 1 name. There's only one name there. It just isn't realistic.
|
Why would he fake claim though. Yam and I are going to be hard defending him all day from you/rayn
|
On September 10 2014 05:27 geript wrote:
Fourth, look at how Palmer stated roles went out. How in the fuck does he not see who is inquisitor? Like I try to do that a bunch as mafia and I'l always catch at least 1 name. There's only one name there. It just isn't realistic.
Holy shit. I didn't even notice this. There's basically 0% chance to miss it.
|
Geript -- we're going to have a LOT of good information tomorrow
D4 will be the day of reckoning...i reckon
|
Your mother sucks cock in hell
|
I'm reading or interpreting that part differently
|
So Sylencia is town because noone cc's him.
Now we kill Sloosh.
|
unless someone basically claims mafia, i don't plan on unvoting syl.
|
WHAT THE FUCK YOU GUYS ARE SERIOUSLY CONSIDERING LYNCHING AN UN-CC'D ROLE IN A SETUP WHERE MAFIA BASICALLY CANNOT FAKECLAIM?
fuck this game, do what the fuck you want.
|
On September 10 2014 05:52 raynpelikoneet wrote:
WHAT THE FUCK YOU GUYS ARE SERIOUSLY CONSIDERING LYNCHING AN UN-CC'D ROLE IN A SETUP WHERE MAFIA BASICALLY CANNOT FAKECLAIM?
fuck this game, do what the fuck you want.
Chill -- no one is even voting him. wtf are you going on about
|
On September 10 2014 04:57 IAmRobik wrote:Show nested quote +On September 10 2014 04:54 geript wrote:On September 10 2014 04:50 IAmRobik wrote:On September 10 2014 04:47 Damdred wrote:
Ok, Rob.
Talk to me about geript, what do you think about him sticking his vote on syl and not moving it after he claimed and nobody has cc'd it? What else makes you not trust him? That's weird that you automatically presume that that's what makes me not trust him. I don't trust his reads. None of them are well formed nor based on the occurrences of this game. He seems to be saying a lot of stuff but it's all meh He keeps throwing dirt on me and I know I'm town. Besides haru, he's spent a lot of time calling townies scum. Nah, I think you've played this setup before. I'm less looking at you and more at setup newbs right now. Potentially Yam because of how distanced he's been I could see him not wisely using KP. But I'm looking more seriously at like Sloosh, Harurh, Damdred, Sylencia, etc. I still don't buy Sylencia's claim whatsoever. I wonder if scum get information on the role of the person they tried to kill or if they get the name of the role that died. That's a bit unclear mod, can you please specifiy
Do not ask questions in the thread. Last warning for you
Especially when I have already clarified it:
On September 08 2014 17:39 Palmar wrote:
Just to be clear, the martyr save is only made obvious as to it being a martyr save. Whoever was targeted is not revealed.
In addition the Necromancer role will learn the identity of the original target, even if that target is then saved by a martyr.
|
fuck it geript is also scum.
|
Oh. I didn't know necro was the mafia role that learned roles, so I didn't realize it was answered. I can't believe I would be warned for asking a question that the mod explicitly answered in the thread. Oh well. Weird rules will be weird. So now that I'm on my final warning. Let's get down to business. Who's scum, since I'm not.
|
why would you say geript is scum and vote sloosh in the same sentence lol
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
