EPTNewbie Mini Mafia LVII - Page 9
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
| ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 06:01 Seeyalater wrote: And you know he's not mafia because... ? I don't know maybe it was two mafia nad the game is won. Thats a world but for now a mafia died and you didn't vote on said individual. You don't look good. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
MEATPUDDING Meatfry - You're being accused of the high crime of MAFIA!!! How do you plead?? Since you like cases so much I made you one <3 Speaking of cases. On August 01 2014 15:17 meatpudding wrote: Pardon if I missed it, but I didn't see anyone put forward a good case about 666. This quote just comes from such a weird mindset I can't wrap my hand around. You are basically saying I can't be blamed for not voting cause no one made a proper case. Like sorry but sometimes we can't do all the work for you. Thats just not something that has to happen always. You don't need need a case. The fact you're asking for one basically seems to me like you're excusings yourself on voting for him. Also in your defense as Jenny (RIP) pointed out you were grasping at straws in your defense. You didn't seem to care about who was mafia and more about just staying alive. You also refused to vote on the other guy to save your life. You also lurked a large majority of the game and are harping on very strange points to me. This is not a large case but you don't have a large amount of information to work from. Can you just walk me through your thought process of where you were at when you were making the decision not to vote on someone to survive and what posts you've made that you think I should read you townie from? Who should I be pushing on? If you have already said these things please do them again. We need to get organized as town and not let mafia coast so proving your towniness is paramount. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
SeeYaLater Seeyatoobschat - Will be your new name if you don't step it up today. You so far has been coasting for lack of a better word. You came out with this stance of not giving any mafia reads and working from a point of trying to find townies. Its a philosophy that I in general find scummy. Your reads posts: + Show Spoiler + On August 01 2014 12:31 Seeyalater wrote: All right off work and have full stomach so here is my current B/M/K list. Bang- Lilwade- After going through his filter earlier today to see his interactions with others, specially our confirmed mafia, Lilwade is currently sitting at the top of my top town his. I was unsure about him yesterday and I think I put him on town leaning mafia early on, and while he did say some really odd things, such as the whole "role/roll" thing with Poofter, his early push on Clockwork makes me put him highly on my town list. Jenny- Jenny has actually dropped a peg for me, still at the top of the hill, but I always mistrust when a lot of people think someone is top town, unless there's a cop who greens them. It just makes me wary. Also the posting style has changed from the beggining of the game, where a lot of her posts were her defensively stating where she was, to almost too confident posts about now, but that could just be, for the lack of better term, "ego" of being called top town by everyone. Again still town sided for me, but I'm very wary that she could just be pocketing tons of others too. Lord Tolkien- While out of the remaining people he might be one of the 2 people who have talked the least, I still get the heavy town vibe I got from him when he first spoke up. He seems to mainly be here to chew gum and kick mafia butt, and he's fresh out of lemonade. Hoping we hear more from him as well! Marry- Poofter- As I've stated before, him being a very veteran player always puts me on edge when it comes to him. I really don't like how he has basically elected himself town mayor for lack of better term. While he does have substanciated reads, he speaks in absolutes, that would make it easy to pocket others. Like Jenny, until a green check comes to him from a trustworthy source, Im going to be on edge with him. Also, while we joked about this in the RC me him and Jenny frequent, the fact that he brought up Texas, which was an old scum read Jenny had on him, was a joke to Jenny, that also made me uncomfortable. Still have him leaning town, of course, but we'll see. Teemu- Boy how the tables have turned. I basically have teemu in a neutral scale now. His posting style changed vastly from day 1 which made me read him as mafia, and how he was pushed on by Meat, have made me regard him in a completely different light. While I'm still not sold he's town, I've returned my mafia purchase on him for now as well. There's something about how people have pushed on teemu, that have made me realize I was basically the one who started the teemu meatwagon that started early in day 1, and makes me suspicious that it was pushed by all mafia team members, since they had found what they thought off as their easiest target. GB- I have absolutely no clue at all how to view this guy. One second he sounds town, one second he sounds mafia. Makes a lot posts that seem to make him seem like he's role hunting, but could it be that its others(including me) reading too much into his posts? Plus I did not like his reaction to Banks' vigi shoot "plan" one bit, almost seemed desperate. He doesn't seem to leave anyone behind in his posts though, usually bringing up everyone, so that's a plus right now I guess. Again still town leading, though to a lesser degree than Teemu. Kill(boy is it lonely) Meatpudding- I'm going to stick to my guns on MP, mainly because I still don't like his push on Teemu last night. I feel like, he would almost have to be donkey mafia to continue to try to save his mafia partner even though Clockwork had basically dug his own grave and thrown himself in it, but at the same time, how could he not see the logic between the clockwork push? He was also one like Clockwork, who seemed to dissapear out of nowhere in the last few hours, unlike everyone else who always let everyone know when they will be heading off. So that's where I am right now. Let me just tell you right now, if you think I'm mafia, that's fine, I'm unconfirmed so of course in anyone else's shoes I'd be looking at myself too, but knowing that I'm town, lets try to look at everyone else as well, and know for a fact that I'm hoping that, even though I'm not great with words, I will not be an easy lynch because I will fight tooth and nail not to let a mislynch on myself happen. Was okay but you said that Jenny was falling down a peg or two for you can you further explain why? I know it may not seem relevant but I have something to say about this point. You then also make this statement today: On August 02 2014 04:27 Seeyalater wrote: Woah, while somewhat expected, I'm sad Jenny died. D: I'm getting ready for work and Fridays are usually busy so I might not have time to make a concise post for a bit, my first impression is that now I'm heavily doubting MP is the last mafia, since some of Jenny's last posts were about her concerns about how hard the bandwagon was for him. Makes it sound like "oh wow jenny was the most obvious town of course she died!" which to me doesn't seem the case from your reads as you had lilwayne top. You also made the post talking about how the night kill basically totally cleared your top mafia in Meatpudding. Who do you think would make that night kill? I understand its WIFOM but I'd like to know where your head is at currently. What about the night kill basically makes it something MeatPrincess wouldn't do? | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 07:21 Teemursu wrote: o/ Unless I fall asleep in the bus, though. I'll be posting some, but the Magic Pro.tour has my priority #1 atm. You can trust me though because I'm not mafia. I'll add this too your case  | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
I'll bump you up the list. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Lord Tolkien Mr. Lord of the Rings - You have voted on a mafia but busing happens My main beef with you is your day one play and your uppityness about some harmless blue confusion going on in the night. You were taking the stance that blue roles shouldn't be talked about and I feel like that kind of feeling about the roles just makes it easier for someone to hunt as mafia for a role that might get mentioned. I make it a goal as any role or alignment to claim roles and alignments to mask anything the mafia might be willing/wanting to do and put doubt in their minds. Your day one started off with this post which I originally found very townie. On July 30 2014 04:32 Lord Tolkien wrote: Wait wat. I said I was considering if I should /in, not that I was /in. i actually have a pretty busy week O_O Oh well, i guess I'll try and make time for this. :x This read as pretty sincere so I was hesitant to call you mafia for something generally a lot of mafia do and thats make excuses your "oh man I didn't realize I was in" could easily be something a mafia says to exclude their low activity even if its partially true mafia tend to bring up the excuse more than town would. The main scummy thing for me has been like I said your paranoia with the blue roles. Your vote coming in on RNG guy was a good time in that it made it 4-4 I believe and moving off the side wagon was good but it could have been a ploy to not be on the guy getting lynched as meat got to 4 votes first. I think I'm mainly just missing hte leadership that I saw in the first game I played with you where I subbed in. If I see more of that then I can feel easier but until I see that full steam ahead attitude I feel you could be mafia. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Teemu Captain Teemu - Not doing much rescuing this game! I feel like Teemu your play on day one up until the night phase was very scummy. You seemed to ask questions and then not bother following up which is a classic mafia tell. You did in the night phase try to call me scummy as well (a silly position I think) I didn't follow why you thought I was the mafia but the case seemed townie and you included the picture of wolves which temporarily blinded me to the fact that you might be one yourself. I really want to hear more from you about where your heads at today and the same spirit I saw in the night. You didn't manage to vote on a mafia and you used this post: On July 31 2014 23:05 Teemursu wrote: Does this mean I'm basically confirmed? Right after it happened to basically try to psuedo confirm yourself. I don't like it at all. That kind of thing is silly mafia push on mafia all the time and its not even like RNG ever pushed on you that hard he pushed on me too and I didn't confirm myself from it. I hate that your filter was so long as mafia last game. You seemed to really be able to break the mafia doesn't talk a lot stereotype. I just can't get over that of you. I really want to see you doing more than just sheeping me today. I want to see you finding the mafia tell me which of my cases is the best which one we should hop on and if I miss something. If you don't end up doing any hard analysis you could easily be the mafia staying on Meatproduce to save a buddy. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 07:44 Teemursu wrote: That's fine, I'm not going to be lynched because I'm not mafia, and you know it, Banks. 80) You assume town always gets it right. If I find you scummy I'll kill you make it known you're town. I don't want to doubt it. I have a spot on my married list and ::wink:: you could be it. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 07:52 Lord Tolkien wrote: wat I made it a 4-3 on DC comics, since I was ON meat at the time. Went from 4-3 on meat to 4-3 on DC. wat are you high, we just talked about this last night lol Also I heartily disagree about blue roles and the treatment thereof. From my experience, best not to talk about them at all unless you're hard claiming it. Difference in opinion I suppose. Hmm I need to double check cause I thought it was 5-3 at the time Meat to DC (votes on Meat being Seeya, DC, Teemu, GB and yourself) Votes already on the wagon of justice Were Myself Lilwayne and theWife. You then made it 4-4 as I recall.... I'll look it up later and verify cause it does make a different in my head at least. If you made it 4-3 then GB's vote is completely unnecessary and your vote is more meaningful. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 08:07 GlowingBear wrote: I don't like the way you're bringing those cases, poof. You can find anything scum from anyone in the game. By doing that you're doing nothing at all, probably just confusing town and by pushing everyone you'll be pushing no one. I have a reason. And I'll explain it once I'm done. Going to try to knock out the others before lunch. Got you and lilwayne left I think. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Interesting. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
GlowingBear GlowingRed - You are playing in such a different fashion from other games I've seen you in and makes me think you might be mafia. I missed Tolkien's description of how the votes went down So your vote is now basically just a flavor vote because MeatPolice wouldn't have voted on himself so he was likely to switch to the RNG guy at some point anyways. So hoping on late wasn't actually to hammer which was what I was giving you some town points for (and taking them from Tolkien) I now am thinking the reads you have been giving may not be from just a silly point of view but might be from a mafia point of view. I said it at the start of the day that your case with the Jenny/Seeya Connection was very weird/odd. It didn't seem to hold water. It also was already making connections between people that frankly shouldn't have been made at the time. I also think you got way overly defensive when I said I was vigi and going to shoot you in the night. + Show Spoiler + On August 01 2014 08:23 GlowingBear wrote: ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Do you all read me as mafia??? Really??? Wtf I give up The kind of attitude was silly from an offhand comment. You also are quick to want the day to just be on MeatPie and not really moving on from there. I think that your game play has been to throw scum on people and also the reasons you had from not being here in day 1 while probably all true felt like you wanted to have a good reason to be afk. I think you might be mafia with RNG and I'm going to see what kind of interaction you guys had. GB Can you explain why you reacted like you did to me threatening to shoot you? Can you also explain to me what your top 3 suspects are as mafia and why? | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Lil'Wayne Lil'Quiet - You've been doing things that show you know the game but haven't made me feel you ooze town I feel like day one you tried to buddy up to me... while I like friends I like friends that want to be my friend for a good reason. I feel like your read on me was a bit premature maybe you just had a good beat and went with it. I've been there before but it felt kinda like a mafia buddying up to me. Also your vote on RNG guy came early with me but I didn't feel like you were pushing for him to really go away. Like you were sitting your vote there almost to keep the blood off your hands if MeatPretzel got lynched. I think that you were in the right and your reads seem okay but I'd Like to see you out here pushing more on them really trying to steer town in the direction they're suppose to go. I think that if you continue to stay sorta in the shadows you get more and more mafia. I think mafia could easily lynch onto me and keep me alive knowing that you can just feed off me and sheep my reads and by agreeing and being my "yes man" stab me in the back. This is over generalizing and I don't think you've been doing this all game but I want it to be known. Can you tell me who I should filter dive first? Who would you think is the scummiest townie? And why do you read them as such? | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
PEOPLE THAT ARE AROUND REVIEW MY CASES!!! WHICH ONE DO YOU LIKE? WHY? WHAT CASE NEEDS THE MOST WORK??? I don't actually think everyone is mafia but I really want to see where people stand prove that anyone could be mafia!! We win today. For our fallen townie Batman Jenny we WILL GET THEM! | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 09:39 meatpudding wrote: Oh good morning. Anyone around? I'll take this question from poofl. You're thinking in reverse. It's about who didn't vote. Also, reading Teemu's filter make me think it was likely mafia. He posts sead end questions. It would have been more helpful to town to analyse what had gone on up to the events, instead of fake claiming medic and being aggressive without trying to back it up. I'd be pushing on lilwade, GB and cya today. Start pushing! | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 09:01 GlowingBear wrote: Poof I'm traveling but I'll explain it soon. I'm actually all for meatpudding. I don't have a solid case instead of him. But I'll try to write what is off about those two I'll bring up Explain it for me! | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Bring it On Again Seeya Lets see the fire! | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 09:48 lilwade wrote: My top 3 scum list right now is Meat , Seeya , and GB. Id like to see some reads on GB more in depth he is the one person this game I am having trouble getting a decent read on Bit busy today, but I feel like we are getting some good info... What is going on with meat, I feel like he disregards almost every post and just throws random things out there. what do you think? Hes a big MeatPile. I can't get my barrings on him.... What of my cases do you like the least/best? | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On August 02 2014 10:30 GlowingBear wrote: Poof, Seeyalater has got a lot of fluff on his posts which is a mafia trait. So, it makes me consider him as possible mafia. There's nothing remarkable coming from him. Lilwade has been lurking a lot and when he comes to the topic he contributes for nothing. It makes him possible mafia for it. Meatpudding has a long list of wrong traits. Lurking almost 36 hours on day one and bringing a terrible list, goes back to lurking? check On that list, gives free town pass to 666 with no reasoning whatsoever? check Refuses to vote the other wagon to save himself considering Teemu more scum than we considered 666? check Votes WITH flipped scum in a possible townie, possibly leading to a mislynch? check When asked to talk about Teemu, brings full case. When asked to talk about 666, quotes other people's opinion. When specifically asked to bring opinion regarding 666, refuses to do so (look at how many attempts I tried. Mafia is uncomfortable of talking about other mafia, that's why I always try to make people to talk about each other, specially when I believe both are mafia). check I thought I was the one who hammered 666. Vote count was confusing, as you know. I thought I would die because I would be confirmed town for that. You said you had a plan and talked about vigi, an impossible role in this game. I believed you were trying to draw suspicions on me so I wouldn't be killed at night. That was me faking being silly. Other than that, my posts were genuine thoughts. If you think they are silly, there's nothing I can do I still think you're silly. And If I was vigi I would have shot you tbh  I still am unsure. Basically where I'm at this game is that I think its probably ez game ez rares with Seeya or MeatPlum but if its not town is ain a SHIT spot because neither of them is dying at night. We only need one more lynch and tbh if felt like night killing Jenny led to a lot of suspicion on you. I'd be like "bad idea" as mafia. IT just is weird. idk. | ||
| ||
