I have a soft spot for people who have outrageous reads...wolves, especially someone like batsnacks, don't come out of left field with reads that are so absurdly opposite from the reads the majority of the thread has. I think most wolves just follow along with general concensus, especially if things are going ok for them (given that kush is a villager)

RIP Banks

yamato77

11589 Posts

June 18 2014 12:49 GMT

#4123

Do you believe that batsnack's reaction to KotC's "pressure" is real? He calls him a bad lynch for it, for god's sake.

yamato77

11589 Posts

June 18 2014 12:49 GMT

#4124

On June 18 2014 21:48 roundabound wrote:
I have a soft spot for people who have outrageous reads...wolves, especially someone like batsnacks, don't come out of left field with reads that are so absurdly opposite from the reads the majority of the thread has. I think most wolves just follow along with general concensus, especially if things are going ok for them (given that kush is a villager)

RIP Banks

Was he like this in cell?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 18 2014 12:50 GMT

#4125

like did batsnacks really think he could turn the tide of the KotC lynch by himself with less than an hour to deadline? it's so futile. Couple of times he's made lists with too many mafia as well, seems kinda townie. Kinda just written him off tbh.

Biggest point against him is that he's so inflexible. still don't want to kill him today though. still think he's probably town.

yamato77

11589 Posts

June 18 2014 12:54 GMT

#4126

If ketomai suddenly dies somehow and flips mafia, I want to revisit batsnacks. Deal?

roundabound

Niue881 Posts

June 18 2014 12:54 GMT

#4127

Kinda? I dont remember exactly, but I was a wolf that game and he was calling me out as a wolf even when the majority of the thread had me as villager, although I think it was mostly based off of shiaopi (who I subbed in for). Its a bit difficult to distinguish ones motives when in cell I was a wopf and know he was a villager, whereas in this game im a villager and dont know his alignment.

yamato77

11589 Posts

June 18 2014 12:58 GMT

#4128

Well you acted like you knew him better than me, I kind of expected you to have a reason for it.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 13:05 GMT

#4129

On June 18 2014 21:47 marvellosity wrote:
mehhhhhh. still doens't look like mafia on mafia.

yes

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 13:09 GMT

#4130

I don't think i want to lynch someone that's not sandroba/foolishness/gumshoe today

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 18 2014 14:12 GMT

#4131

lynch matt. Sandroba is going to get modkilled unless he just randomly shows up to vote. and if he does that he claims mafia and we lynch him

justanothertownie

16320 Posts

June 18 2014 14:25 GMT

#4132

On June 18 2014 05:18 mattisfoolish wrote:
Repost in here sorry

Also found this gem:

Show nested quote +

~Foolishness

On June 18 2014 05:22 mattisfoolish wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm just bringing it to light cause I'm pretty sure he's mafia and he's not going to show up later.

~Foolishness

On June 18 2014 09:56 roundabound wrote:
Formatting

Show nested quote +

Its been over 24 hrs since this post came out.

Need more from sandroba than this week, unsubstantiated stuff on 2 thread sentiment lynches

##Unvote
##Vote: Sandroba

~moc

You guys are sooooo helpful. It's not like I didn't already point exactly this line out ages ago. Is this seriously all you can come up with foolishness? This is hard to believe.
Other comments will follow.

strongandbig

United States4858 Posts

June 18 2014 14:34 GMT

#4133

I tried to random filter read vayne authority but there's like nothing there that gives a hint of his thought process, just some pictures and some random unjustified conclusions

I don't feel like he was like this when I played with him before? This is more what id expect from kush or like mrzentor

Unfortunately I don't know what this means for him alignment wise because I haven't played much for a while.
So filter read: failure

justanothertownie

16320 Posts

June 18 2014 14:36 GMT

#4134

On June 18 2014 10:46 batsnacks wrote:
Gumshoe commented on a couple useless posts (Palmar's numbers post, a couple IRL stuff posts) which is scummy to me. But then there was that post where he thought there was a 3rd party in this game, which, I don't believe mafia would have made that mistake. Mafia, in the universe I am imagining, would have read the OP. Gumshoe isn't someone I'm going to vote for today.

You would be surprised what mistakes gumshoe makes as mafia.

On June 18 2014 11:04 batsnacks wrote:
So mafia list is roundabound, tehpoofter, sinani, bunnies, one of marv/holyflare, one of sandroba/mattisfoolish, maybe CR

Almost twice as many mafia reads as there are mafia. Does anyone want to convince me to remove someone from my list?

What is this... where is the connection between HF/marv or sandro/foolish? Why one of them? Why can't sandro and MIF both be mafia?

On June 18 2014 11:58 27ninjabunnies wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well, marv did that lynch d1. I doubt mafia would bus that early. His play has lacked since then imo, but everyne deserves to be wrong once. I wouldn't lynch him today.

Plus with his claim of protection, cant be sure anyway

Why the hell would he fakeclaim being protected. If there is a jailer that person knows exactly that he is fakeclaiming. That's stupid. It tells us NOTHING about his alignment. He would have been protected as town or mafia.

On June 18 2014 14:18 Chromatically wrote:
gumshoe is looking like a modkill, so that's probably not going to be an issue.

##Unvote
##Vote: sandroba

You shouldn't EVER bet on a scummy lurker being modkilled. Especially not with gumshoe.

On June 18 2014 15:25 roundabound wrote:

Show nested quote +

So, this is way more than sandro has done and hos list isnt terrible. It at least shows a semblance of paying attention and knowing whats going on.

As I was tyoing that to say we shouldnt lynch MIF, I realized that thats probably even scummier than just not showing up like gumshoe is doing.

Not sure if it is scummier than sandro promising in the thread to pick up activity and then disappearing though.

The bolded is very very true.

On June 18 2014 17:04 Holyflare wrote:

Show nested quote +