Catastrophe Mafia - Page 280

On April 14 2014 21:46 sandroba wrote:
@palmar yeah Im starting to feel that way too. I dont know if we can afford to lynch jat or amiko. We definetely need to start shooting people at night too.

@austin can you still shoot people?

@jat If you kill me do you leave the game?

On April 14 2014 23:36 strongandbig wrote:
I'm just worried that we can't afford to waste a lynch on oatsmaster. Unlike VE, at least oats has presented a somewhat coherent explanation of a world in which his actions make sense... Whereas VE has had four nights and delivered zero useful checks and not been shot as the only claimed full detective.

On April 13 2014 07:50 strongandbig wrote:
1. If he's town how do scum not kill the claimed dt? I sincerely doubt VE has been protected.
2. I don't agree that he wouldn't have openly said he didn't check oatsmaster, if there's a leak he could have known that I would make his n2 check unstoppable so the only way out of checking oats was to claim "oops I forgot"
3. We did already have at least one dead town cop

Each night, you may either Alignment check a player who ended any previous day voting you, or use “Borderline Ethical” methods and alignment check any player, but add 1 point to the chaos and radiation counters.

On April 03 2014 12:31 VisceraEyes wrote:

I don't think it's important. I've made my stance clear, and I'm trying to find scum instead. Or rather, I've started by trying to find town, which will help me narrow down where I think I should look for scum. However your suggestion that it's important to discuss whether pushing the button is good or bad, again, leads me to believe that you're not so much interested in finding scum.

LSB captured!!

On April 15 2014 03:04 austinmcc wrote:
No. Gun doesn't unbreak. Town knowing that better than WIFOMing scum and saying maybe or whatever, but I cannot.

Oats gets almost lynched yesterday, saved only by action. Oats has N3 and D4 to do stuff. Oats does _______. Oats isn't town.

---

---

---

Back, wanted to chat about this.snb, you asked this, and looking back at poofter I dunno. As far as (1), the reason is ye olde "because he looks like ass and they'd rather shoot vocal townies/circle townies". Also, since everyone is powered this game, it's not the normal calculus of shooting a cop or Some Townie, but it's a cop vs Vocal Townie Who Does Something. Not great reasons, but that's what fits.

I had to re-check poofter, knew he was a cop but I thought he had more restrictions than he did. That points towards VE NOT being alignment and rolecoppy, as plain old alignment DT was balanced by either having limited targets OR adding counters, whereas VE has claimed alignment + role check, with an alternative ability to transfer a role for a day or night or whatever.

Given another lack of info night...I can come around on him. The claiming not to have seen "check oats" is still a point in his favor, imo, but nothing else really is when I look back at poofter's cop role.

The LSB stuff is...meh. He mentions him a bunch, but never really says WHY LSB is scummy. This is IT for why LSB is scummy, everything else is just coloring his name red and asking people about him, except he never says more about LSB and he never tries to get votes on him or anything:(i.e. button discussion = scum, and then asking people later to comment on his points on LSB, which is nothing but "button discussion = scum")

He DOES vote iamp and call out iamp, slightly, but he's townie townie townie on iamp, and then swaps based on Foolishness's case, when a lot of people didn't like it/didn't like foolishness. It's...minor stuff slightly in his favor, but he's not really making any points on scum or pushing them legitimately, he just kinda colors them red when he feels like it, and I think he's making a little much of that.

On April 15 2014 03:08 strongandbig wrote:

oats obviously isnt town. im worried about if hes telling the truth about being 3p

On April 15 2014 03:05 austinmcc wrote:
JAT, did you shoot last night?

On April 15 2014 03:14 austinmcc wrote:
Grrrrr. I want to try and figure out the mayoral lynch vs alignment check, but it depends on how many scum and how many 3Ps we have, neither of which we know.

I don't see that it's crazy clear-cut for mayoral lynch, in some ways getting 100% of someone's role would be nice, it delays a lynch 1 day but it lets us not mislynch if we're wrong on someone. But we probably use it to check a 3P claim? And that's not a great use of a day, even if scum is down to 1 NK after today's lynch.

On April 15 2014 03:08 austinmcc wrote:
TAGS HARD


Just to confirm, the option that WINS the vote today, has the most votes, whatever, is the option that will be in place tomorrow?

On April 15 2014 03:42 austinmcc wrote:
At some point we're bumping up against a bunch of scummy crap that we don't know a source of though.

That brings us to:

Prince of Darkness
Blazinghand unrevived
Oats being unlynchable (still think this will be on oats when he flips)
Protect on oats last night

Along with assorted small counter movements that we can't account for as of yet.