Aren't you the resident syllo expert?

Based on my experience, syllo feels uncomfortable posting actively as mafia. He hasn't been very open with reads so far so I think he looks the worst of the three. Usually I'm convinced he is town a few minutes into the game and that hasn't happened yet.

With marv, I liked his defense of LSB because he seems like an easy target based on his poor filter and he indeed does often look terrible. His post to reads ratio is good enough for me that he seems town for the time being. Eventually I'm going to want to see some stronger reads/follow-up though.

Holy maybe has a cool role? Takes the same view as I do on paper. No strong read yet.

I'm supposed to be, but I can't tell either way so far. I'll see if he does something useful tomorrow besides coaching people on anger management, if he doesn't there is reason to be worried.
I get it that palmar wants to spam the thread and I'm not sure if he is mafia for it yet, but holy enabling him feels out of character from the little I've seen from him.
Marv just seems flat out useless so far.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:02 GMT

#1579

On April 04 2014 09:53 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

Tell me why it's retarded then. I've done plenty useful things, defending Robik when the thread was retardedly on his ass was pretty useful. Maybe work with me rather than just saying random shit. Because yes, you are quite likely to be town. Maybe even very likely.

I haven't caught a bunch of mafia in 24h, but then again, neither have you.

Alright I'm willing to roll with that. Paperscraps is likely non mafia because doing random shit like typing backwards is not a mafia tell and he voluntarily disclosed information about him and VE being somehow connect and still being suspicious of VE which is a town tell. Also his filter is one page, let the dude play some more freely before we wagon up on him and he becomes all defensive and now you can't tell shit about his alignment.
There are probably better people to focus who have a larger filter but I haven't started filter diving yet. Do you have any ideas on who to start with?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:04 GMT

#1580

On April 04 2014 10:01 marvellosity wrote:
I bolded the whole thing because you mention something that I brought up alone, and then called me useless.

It's just fantastic.

Alright man, let's just do some work then. Sorry if I misrepresented you but I'm just not seeing the town flame in you yet.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:06 GMT

#1583

I want to lynch holyflare btw.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:10 GMT

#1587

Besides the palmar thing, his "reads" are for the most part opposite of mine and he is supposed to be good at this game. Also he has done nothing other than spam one liners with apparently very little thought put into them. It may be somehow minor, but I remember him being quite proud of his mafia playing abilities and his comment downplaying himself with oats seems like scum behavior to me.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:12 GMT

#1590

Sigh.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:13 GMT

#1592

On April 04 2014 10:11 kitaman27 wrote:
Foolishness post was amusing, but a thousand word post with only two unexplained reads, a condemnation of spam, and a suggestion to scum hunt rather than talk about setup is really uninspiring.

I really hope we don't get another shadow game where he refuses to interact with the thread.

We will just have to wait to see what he does next. We are not going to lynch him based on that one post (which I found quite entretaining), so no point talking about him right now.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:14 GMT

#1593

On April 04 2014 10:13 marvellosity wrote:
I think Dandel is really obviously town.

Also just looking at Holy, I totally forgot he was passively calling me mafia. Would lynch 100% for that alone.

Good then. Onwards with the wagon of justice!

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:17 GMT

#1600

Wave, you look like non mafia to me. How about you join town on their righteous pursuit of HolyFlare?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:25 GMT

#1612

Bh really hasn't posted much so far, besides starting the paperscraps wagon. I think it's too early to tell either way, let the man post some more.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:27 GMT

#1617

Whoa, sorry to step on your toes princess. Any reason for this hostile comment?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:32 GMT

#1628

Wow people are really attacking my english today.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:45 GMT

#1642

On April 04 2014 10:42 WaveofShadow wrote:
Don't like robik's style. I can't trust him not to rage-use something in a way it shouldn't be used. I'm aware he's been given a pretty decent ranking and apparently has shown well lately, but I haven't seen it personally so I don't trust him not to be tunnelly-bad town.

Oats with power? lol.

Sandro probably a good addition, yeah.

Sandro, would you like to replace Rayn on my list?

Actually no, I'm afraid of your hint at being 3rd party earlier. So you don't have my consent.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 01:55 GMT

#1654

On April 04 2014 10:49 WaveofShadow wrote:

Show nested quote +

Alright that's fair I guess.
Thing is though, and I suppose I may as well make people aware of this, if I don't get enough people to volunteer, I may just have to pick people, and if towny people don't want to be put on my list, I can totally see myself simply choosing you, sandroba.

Well, if you can do that, I don't know why you would be asking for people to sign up for the list. If you are town just get your town reads and give it to them.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 20:09 GMT

#2367

Alright I think I might have been wrong about holy but at least it got him playing the game. Still got a bit of catching up to do.

PS: @holy by "proud mafia player" I meant the game not the alignment

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 20:13 GMT

#2375

On April 04 2014 22:25 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

actually in games sand & I have been town together, my day 1 reads have been superior

I require proof of this =P

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 20:14 GMT

#2376

Also I'm now on the QT with marv, I got a message saying that "the brown" put me there to figure out marv's alignment.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 20:41 GMT

#2399

Still not liking the paperscraps lynch. I'm inclined to go with tehpoofer if we can get enough support.
That exchange with him and marv where he says he doesn't trust marv, therefore won't be voting paper is already a mafia tell, making assossiative reads with imcoplete information and not even reading the content of the case. But then he goes and does a complete 180 votes paper and vanishes after marv pressures him a bit.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 04 2014 21:00 GMT

#2410

Finally caught up. My reasoning for paperscraps being town is mainly one of the first posts he made in the game, as I've said before, he was the first to reveal his QT and along with it revealed he was suspicious of VE, but didn't disclose the other 2 people in the QT he wasnt suspicious of. That points to town. The whole case on him is that he is writing backwards and change his read from town to null in 6 hours which I don't think point to mafia. People read the thread over and change their minds. Also the current defense of poofer points to town as well in this situation where he is on the chopping block.

I'll look at gumshoe next.