|
On February 10 2014 10:52 Balla24 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 10 2014 10:49 Aquanim wrote:On February 10 2014 10:14 Balla24 wrote:
So Aquanim. Which of jay and suki is town? I reckon they both are town. I'm not completely positive on either of them, though. Reasoning please. Oats, same question to you.
The reasons I think Suki is town are in this post. The tl;dr version is that I feel that her case and push to get JayB lynched was genuine; it's a gut read at best.
As for JayB, he feels like a paranoid, OMGUSing townie to me. Also, that blue claim - though I'm starting to become a little doubtful of that.
My reads on these two have a lot more to do with feelings than with hard facts.
|
On February 10 2014 10:57 Oatsmaster wrote:
jay town suki scum.
They both arent scum.
Jay town because I feel like he wouldnt really have such a long explanation for being afk.
suki scum for pushing jay when she got no support the whole day.
Uhh, you mean this post?
On February 09 2014 08:57 jaybrundage wrote:
@Balla the lynch was decided when I came back in the thread. I said I was ok with a jonny lynch as I have been using process of elimination recently. I could of moved my vote with 30 mins left in the day but why? The lynch was decided my vote was useless whether I would of changed to Jonny or not. I would of consolidated on Jonny if you guys needed as I think you and Agua are both town reads for me and I was fine with a jonny lynch. But the way it was I didn't see any reason to change my vote.
That's your reason for thinking jay is town? A single pretty boring post? There was so much more than that for him that day and that's the only thing?
|
Does it matter what thing I use??
|
On February 10 2014 11:11 Oatsmaster wrote:
Does it matter what thing I use??
Yes it matters what thing you use, because that is a pretty bad reason for a town read. You really think one post makes someone town?
A single post will never ever ever convince me that someone is town. Especially not this one. It's the most generic explanation i've ever heard in my life:
1. Why does that post make him town?
2. What else is there to this read?
|
Maybe you see something I don't because that does not indicate town for me at all.
|
no, I think its a waste of my time to defend Jay with so many examples when you clearly dont think so and its night anyway.
|
are you trying to convince me that Jay is scum? Or what?
|
I think jay is town. That's not the point, you aren't defending jay, you are explaining a weak town read to me because that's not cutting it.
|
So whats the point of this exactly?
|
On February 10 2014 11:20 Oatsmaster wrote:
So whats the point of this exactly?
Bad reasoning for any reads = scummy. This is very scummy.
|
but its not bad??????
What/???
|
We literally just talked about this a page back with Hopeless.
|
On February 10 2014 11:17 Oatsmaster wrote:
no, I think its a waste of my time to defend Jay with so many examples when you clearly dont think so and its night anyway.
...
This is day 2. It's not even nighttime in your timezone. Wat?
|
It's terrible, how can you give someone a town read for one post. A read that you apparently can't even explain why that post makes him town.
Why would you say you think its a town post if you can't even explain it? If you can explain it, fricking explain it!
|
I did explain it.
Still super confused.
Ohhh right aqua.
Anyway why are none of you chumps voting for sidesprang?
|
You're making me rip my hair out.
|
On February 10 2014 10:57 Oatsmaster wrote:
Jay town because I feel like he wouldnt really have such a long explanation for being afk.
Does not = town. How does that mean he's town? Because he typed a paragraph? Seriously?
|
It means he would not explain in such length why he was afk as scum.
|
Fine. Whatever.
Can you comment on the other things he's done and why that makes him town? Or why anything scummy he has done is cancelled out by a single post explaining an afk?
|
also look at the first page of my filter for hard defence of jay
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
