It shouldn't. I'm not saying it couldn't, but it shouldn't.

I mean you always have to work around or with people that just don't even try. The hard part is realizing who's mafia and who's just an asshole.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 01:07 GMT

#353

On February 09 2014 10:04 marvellosity wrote:
Thing is, Palmar, I like your "who sees themselves as obv town" question because it's kooky, and I thnk in a good way.

I'm not sure I agree on what you've done for the results. In my experience town are far more likely to think they look obv-town and mafia rarely think that way, even as a joke response. I constantly say I'm obv-town as town and can almost never make myself say it as mafia, as a joke or otherwise.

I specifically asked people not to troll the response. So I am assuming geript's opinion of himself is genuine. His later outburst actually supports that, so that's consistent. I don't think it was a joke response.

So yeah, it's entirely plausible geript just has a really hard time realizing how shit his posting is because he's caught up in trying to be a badass (why do so many people here want to be badasses?).

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 01:08 GMT

#354

The eternal question of mafia.

Bad, or scum?

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 12:59 GMT

#513

On February 09 2014 07:57 Corazon wrote:
Yeah I really don't feel like defending myself. I'm just gonna wait for Yamato to reply to my message.

Btw, you guys should look into Palmar's vote of Geript. Wouldn't it make a lot of sense for scum to try and rile up Geript for no reason?

On February 09 2014 10:58 Corazon wrote:

Show nested quote +

We could always lynch Palmar for going after Geript, because attacking Geript is a pretty easy thing to do as scum.

I really need clarification on this.

I was not trying to rile geript up, I posted facts about what he had done in the game so far and voted for him.

And apparently it's easy to attack him as scum. So by extension should geript be immune to scrutiny as it's too easy to attack him? I don't really know where you're going with this but all I can read from it is that you think that going after geript is a waste of time and shouldn't be done, in fact merely accusing him seems to be scummy.

I'm amazed you allow yourself to think like this.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 13:07 GMT

#514

in addition @Corazon:

Is there any specific reason you wanted other people to look at me, instead of just doing it yourself and presenting your conclusion?

@Marv: I think you're voting Oats, could you explain to me why?

All I remember about him is that I noted his early question (the very question that started my intrigue into geript) was valid, but a bit "cheap" if you will, ie: it bears no meaning on his alignment, it's not a thoughtful or an analytical question.

I've mostly ignored him since. But I'm all ears.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 13:24 GMT

#520

On February 09 2014 22:17 marvellosity wrote:
I think Koshi is a terrible lynch today

I would agree he's relatively far down my list of people I'd like to lynch.

I'll have more time tonight.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 13:32 GMT

#523

Just to agree more with people WoS is possibly my strongest town read. The other option is Risen.

Now that's not to say much as I'm having an unusually hard time figuring out townies because not many people are making coherent cases or trains of thought, but yeah.

I would be hard-pressed to want to lynch either today, but compared to strong town reads from other games neither of them is very strong, just better than anything else I have at the moment.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 13:38 GMT

#528

On February 09 2014 22:35 marvellosity wrote:
Do you think i should be reading you as town, Palmar?

Yeah I think so by now. Probably with some reservations, mostly because of activity/lack of interaction with half the thread, but what I've posted is pretty straightforward.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 15:13 GMT

#536

Tempted to join Oats' wagon on marv just for the delicious drama.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 15:42 GMT

#543

I like you Grack

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 16:31 GMT

#565

no one is trolling I think. I don't think oats' reasons for voting you are any worse than your reasons for voting him. if anything his case is slightly better. But I'm all for being convinced.

im off for like 4 hours, or at least only on phone.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 17:03 GMT

#585

How about my wagon marv? help me instead?

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 17:30 GMT

#623

answer my question before you go cora

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 17:58 GMT

#631

I'm no a huge fan of either wagon atm. I'll admit i haven't read much of kosher

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 18:01 GMT

#633

I meant kosher and va.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 18:47 GMT

#651

riaen is town i think. he did some kind of a flip flop that looked somewhat gnuine.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 18:59 GMT

#653

I already mentioned I think wos is town

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 20:55 GMT

#682

ok I'm back. My reading of the last few pages has been a bit sketchy, but whatever.

I don't think I want to lynch Kosher. Other people I don't want to lynch include WoS, Oats, myself, Risen etc.

I worry about the Cora wagon. I pointed out some inconsistency in his play myself, but his random vote on me there before he switched is really head scratching if he's mafia. Now his is obviously not going to make much sense to anyone but myself, but given how he's been wanting to kill me and been casually calling me out all game, it seems like a strange vote as it makes it more likely he'll flip AND if he flips mafia he's basically confirming me as town.

So knowing my own alignment, his move just doesn't make any sense if he's mafia.

I'd much rather lynch somewhere into geript, marv, VE, rayn, or even holyfare.

I'm unsure about yamato...

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

February 09 2014 20:56 GMT

#683

oh and VA, I'll go back and re-read him now. But I just had a look at my initial reads, and I stated he made some good point about mutually exclusive something and that I was a fan of his. So...