|
On February 06 2014 01:46 suki wrote:
@Jay and Oats
I also saw cakeman as 'unconfident townie' in the early part of the game. I noticed that he wasn't really giving strong reads but I decided to give it some time and see how he continued to play.
The fact that so much has happened but he's still going after lurkers and easy lynches is really .. hmm.. disappointing, if he's town. But as scum it's a safe play.
@Balla: You played with cakeman in one of your newbies and he was scum there. What's your impression of him compared to this game?
He was town... I don't really remember that much so looking back on it
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=433102&user=cakemanofdoom
Looks pretty similar. Less waffling then here but nothing stands out to me as that different.
|
Koshi, what do you think of cakeman?
|
On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made was just pushing Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping.
I tried blatantly sheeping and got shot down Jay. I thought Oats was scum. Am I supposed to spam "OATS SCUM KILL IT" and leave it at that? I'm also not simply tunneling Oats to infinity.
You haven't actually commented on the case. Can I get your thoughts on how you feel about Oats claiming everything early on re:Koshi was just pressure?
|
On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made EDIT a scum read to just push EDIT Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping.
|
On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made was just pushing Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping.
I was thinking the same. But then he started a fresh conversation on Cakeman and that looked very good. I was just going to ask him about his other reads but it was 1700PM and had to go home.
|
On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made was just pushing Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping.
He was actually asked to make a case earlier and he had promised one:
On February 05 2014 15:21 Hopeless1der wrote:Show nested quote +On February 05 2014 15:18 suki wrote:On February 05 2014 15:04 Hopeless1der wrote:
As for being a perfect sheep, yes I'm sorry I wasn't around to make the case myself. Do you want me to go quote Oats' filter 5 times and explain why he's still scum for the stuff you say he's refuted?
On second thought, I think this would be quite helpful. You don't have to quote his filter 5 times but if you can explain why you think his defense did not appropriately address my case that would be good. kk first thing when I wake up.
@cakeman, you were reluctant to vote jay earlier (when you were saying koshi is scum). What changed?
I'd call him scum if he didn't make one after that.
|
On February 06 2014 01:50 suki wrote:
Koshi, what do you think of cakeman?
tbh, I thought he was a blue when reading him earlier.
|
On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made was just pushing Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping.
Absolutely. Hopeless being gone for 24hrs is important to me. In his other games he is literally here for hours on end posting oneliner responses, questions, etc. here he was here, posting responses, then he just bailed out.
|
LoneMeow would you be so kind as to drop a vote so we have a better idea of where you stand?
|
On February 06 2014 01:52 Hopeless1der wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made was just pushing Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping. I tried blatantly sheeping and got shot down Jay. I thought Oats was scum. Am I supposed to spam "OATS SCUM KILL IT" and leave it at that? I'm also not simply tunneling Oats to infinity. You haven't actually commented on the case. Can I get your thoughts on how you feel about Oats claiming everything early on re:Koshi was just pressure?
I have gone back and forth on Oats. Right now I think him pressuring Koshi for content is a reasonable explanation. Koshi hadn't posted much beyond his early policy. After that he didn't really say much. His post when he got frustrated with Oats. Showed that Oat's pressure was working and getting to him.
And thru that post Oats deemed him more likely town. The pressure had a purpose and that was to reveal Koshi's alignment and it seemed to have worked for Oats.
|
Let's get some votes plz gogo everyone... only 5 hours to lynch~
|
On February 06 2014 01:52 LoneMeow wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 01:48 jaybrundage wrote:
Does anyone else think that Hopeless being gone for twenty four hours. Coming back and getting on the popular sentiment of oats being scum and the two cases on him. While also OMGUS'ing Oats is a bit suspicious?
It seems like he made was just pushing Oats back cause he needed to come back in the thread with something. After calling Oats scummy. He made up his own case so he wouldn't be blatantly sheeping. He was actually asked to make a case earlier and he had promised one: Show nested quote +On February 05 2014 15:21 Hopeless1der wrote:On February 05 2014 15:18 suki wrote:On February 05 2014 15:04 Hopeless1der wrote:
As for being a perfect sheep, yes I'm sorry I wasn't around to make the case myself. Do you want me to go quote Oats' filter 5 times and explain why he's still scum for the stuff you say he's refuted?
On second thought, I think this would be quite helpful. You don't have to quote his filter 5 times but if you can explain why you think his defense did not appropriately address my case that would be good. kk first thing when I wake up.
@cakeman, you were reluctant to vote jay earlier (when you were saying koshi is scum). What changed? I'd call him scum if he didn't make one after that.
Lonemeow do you not think him being asked to make one, isn't suspicious in it self? Also if your promise to make a case you better make it as either alignment or your just not playing the game at that point.
|
On February 06 2014 02:20 Balla24 wrote:
Let's get some votes plz gogo everyone... only 5 hours to lynch~
Woah is it that close. What do you think about the lynch being on hopeless atm?
|
Just to be clear.
##Unvote
##Vote Hopeless1der
|
lol I was just thinking going to LM.
|
Well, did I change my vote? His cases weren't amazing. Everything that I wrote last night still stands. I like lynching hopeless or Lonemeow. Wouldn't really be surprised if cake/oats flipped scum still. Oats less and less though.
|
I think I'm okay with a cakeman or a LoneMeow lynch at the moment.
LM hasn't done anything. He was leaning scummy on Hopeless, but now says Hopeless looks better. He doesn't seem concerned enough to really push Koshi for being scum either, and those are the only two people that he's labelled as scummy. :\
|
LM his cases were on the 3 people that were most likely going to get lynched at that time and Alakaslam. Which is not even worth calling a case.
His response to the case from jayB was: Why not Hopeless who is equally scummy?
That doesn't make sense at all.
|
blehhhh I really dunno, I kinda like that hopeless is taking some initiative though, I think we should wait and see.
Yeah ok read through cakes filter again, could be either way but for now, I think hes scum
##unvote
##Vote cake
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
