|
By the "lurker thing", I meant how Koshi said he wasn't gonna push anyone for 24 hours. From what I understood of that, Koshi was saying that he'd lurk for a day and then give out his reads on the people who posted in the meantime.
On February 04 2014 22:27 Koshi wrote:
I have no interest in calling out people already. In 24 hours you will know more.
I would like Jonny to explain his arguments against me though. I am actually upset about the fact my early posting is "shitposting" tbh.
On February 04 2014 23:59 Koshi wrote:
Tomorrow. Today, people can post freely. Without worry. Nobody is watching.
|
Meh. Maybe, I guess.
Actually, I don't really care right now. I'm fine with lynching Hopeless either way.
##Vote Hopeless1der
Going to sleep. I'm also fine with lynching LM and Koshi.
|
Woke up late. Reading and thinking.
First impressions so far: Hopeless has quite a few more posts and it seems more substantial now. Still doesn't seem like LM has done much.
|
My fence-sitting: can't help it. I'm uncertain about my reads.
My vote on Hopeless: I wanted to get a vote down before I slept. I do find Koshi scummy, but Hopeless was pretty scummy just for being gone for the first half of the day and barely having anything when he came back. The reasons are pretty similar tbh, I just voted hopeless since I figured I could change it now-ish if he seems townier.
Now I gotta read more carefully and decide who I want to lynch today...
|
Hopeless's case on me seems pretty well thought out... Feels like he's trying to find scum, not just trying to kill off a random townie
Don't know what to think of his case on oats. I feel like I can understand most of oats's thought process. But oats has done some kinda weird things.
Overall the effort makes me unwilling to lynch him.
LM: I thought his questions were pretty good ones to ask. And he has pretty reasonable-seeming opinions on lynch targets now.
Koshi: He had a policy that he didn't follow up on, he had a big case on Jonny that he didn't stand by. So what's left?
-Casually calling Hopeless the best lynch, following thread sentiment. Then backing off after hopeless posted.
-Voting LM.
On February 06 2014 02:30 Koshi wrote:
LM his cases were on the 3 people that were most likely going to get lynched at that time and Alakaslam. Which is not even worth calling a case.
His response to the case from jayB was: Why not Hopeless who is equally scummy?
That doesn't make sense at all.
I don't see the problem with posting his thoughts on people he's watching/thinks might be lynched, it lets us know where he's at.
Also, the question makes sense from the perspective of town trying to figure stuff out. It's reasonable to wonder why jay picked one lurky player over another. It's not like LM could have defended his own lurkiness there, anyways.
I think Koshi's just trying to make up reasons to sound original as he votes a fairly easy target.
So overall, I see nothing from Koshi except a poorly-reasoned vote on LM, a lot of short posts that I didn't get anything out of, and a policy/case that he retracted.
##Unvote
##Vote Koshi
|
I have not played a scumgame.
From what I can tell, the main point against me is that I'm on the fence about a bunch of my reads. There's nothing I can really say to that besides the fact that I just wasn't absolutely sure.
It's a fairly valid point though, so attacking me is probably more towny than not.
And I was walking to a class that starts in 7 minutes. I can't be on 7-57 minutes from now, I'll be able to follow/ post from phone after that. 20 minutes or so after that I'll be on my comp again
|
I still don't want to lynch LM or Hopeless right now. LM looks like he's trying really hard to figure the game out right now.
Hopeless seems to be making sense.
Need to decide whether I want to lynch jay or Koshi right now. Jay's been looking worse and worse since his decent beginning. But I still don't see how Koshi's town.
|
Hmm. Rereading jay's filter, I don't think the problems are that bad. He does have some opinions in there, and he's pretty reasonable while discussing right now.
Meanwhile Koshi still seems scum. He has little effort in his cases/pokes as far as I can tell - his stuff on hopeless seemed to be a sheep of oats, his stuff on Jonny was retracted because it was made without reading carefully enough, and I don't like his reasons on LM. Plus he doesn't seem to be here figuring stuff out.
I like my vote where it is.
|
Though I'm not sure why jay reposted his case on LM. I didn't like it that much in the first place, and LM's only been seeming more town since then.
|
I do that, Balla... I get a bad impression, then I look into the person more and solidify my opinion while making a case on them. Like that phrase about LM I forgot to delete and you found scummy. I had a bad feeling, was going to try and make a case, and then I decided LM didn't look particularly bad for a lurker.
|
what do I do. I have a stronger townread on LM than on jay. I'd prefer lynching Koshi over jay. But it doesn't look like Koshi's getting lynched, and jay claimed doc.
Easy solution for me: lynch Koshi.
|
Why's there a switch to jay now? lm's claim was so bad imo
|
Wait wtf LM was actually doc? I thought it was way too unlikely that the other lynch target besides the first doc claim would be real doc O.O
|
When jay claimed I didn't believe him. But then he was an un-CC'd doc claim, and I wasn't sure if it would retarded to vote him.
I still had a stronger townread on LoneMeow at the time, though. So I had no clue who to vote for. So I stuck with Koshi, who I thought was scum independently of this whole doc thing.
Then when LM claimed I just went wtf, because I thought it was way too improbable for him to actually be doc. I was considering voting LM for that... but time ran out while I was thinking.
Basically, my brain malfunctioned because I had no clue what to do :/
|
Oh sweet so I was the only one on scum at that vote?
|
Everyone else's vote was useless or on town. meh.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
