|
United States1302 Posts
On February 21 2014 04:59 IAmRobik wrote:Show nested quote +On February 21 2014 04:55 JarJarDrinks wrote:On February 21 2014 04:35 IAmRobik wrote:
you guys brought it up first...he tries to say that he read SS wrong in that game, which is why he's giving him a free pass this game. And then he says he's going to go reread that game to see why he read him wrong. Then he comes back with the conclusion that he's willing to give him a break based off of the similarities between that game and this game, when that's an absolute fallacy and the game SS is playing here is 100% different from the one he played there just from the first couple of pages alone! I addressed this: On February 15 2014 03:38 JarJarDrinks wrote:
I was just saying that I read him scum early on in that game for reasons similiar to how I read him early this game. I am in no way saying that I think he's playing exactly like he played that game. All I said was I wanted to back off him a bit and give him a chance before jumping on him. Do you have a bot that pings you every time "JJD" is written in the thread? No
|
On February 21 2014 03:30 IAmRobik wrote:
OK...I'm officially bored. Who are we lynching today? SideSprang, JJD or mordanis ..... or are we actually going to lynch mattchew who hasn't spoken in like 10000 years
Hate to be a broken record but he did promise to talk and yet here we are, for all we know hes just trying to avoid a modkill. Hes proven that hes here and yet he refuses to respond, thats not the matt I know. Everyone defends him as lynch bait, but honestly what does that even mean? Jar jar, shiao, quantam, mordanis, side, thrawn, Half the fuking players in this game were/are lynch bait, that doesn't make any of them more or less likely to be town. Honestly between them all its just a matter of pick your poison, a flip on sidesprang or jar is a solid 50 50, no more no less, because players like them always play suspiciously. But Matt is diffrent, Matt is capable of caring, of coming up with solid cases. Above all he gets angry and fights when he knows hes right. I dont know what past experience you have with him, but this is not my idea of town matt.
If your still soundly resolved not to lynch him, my preference goes to Bum, he back pedalled on side sprang (his only read) but didn't offer any scum alternatives (mustve been to busy hiding behind his replacement status).
If your not willing to lynch either of these guys, then out of your selection I find sprang the scummiest since he isn't bothering to help town at all. If Mattchew/Bum absolutely wont happen then I'll compromise on him. If you wanna kill someone outside of those three, you'll probably have to do it without me, I'm not yet desperate enough to vote for a straight coin flip.
|
United States1302 Posts
OK,
##Unvote
##Vote Mattchew
|
gumshoe, you were rb'd last night, yah?
that's one of the only reasons I don't want to lynch you.
as for bum...I explaining why i think he's town a couple pages back
if push comes to shove, i'll vote mattchew. I don't like the speed at which he got pressured this game especially with the votes d2. We'll see though. I'm down for whatever at this point as long as it's not vivax420, roundabound, me, gumshoe, bum, or grack (i think that's my town circle at the moment)
|
VOTE COUNT:
Mattchew (4): JarJarDrinks, Grackaroni, gumshoe, roundabound, Grackaroni, JarJarDrinks
gumshoe (1): roundabound, sidesprang
bumatlarge (1): Mordanis
sidesprang (1): JarJarDrinks, bumatlarge
JarJarDrinks (0): Grackaroni
With 10 players alive it takes 6 votes to lynch. Only votes in the Voting Thread will be counted!
|
w/e let's do this shit voting mattchew.
|
|
|
i actually don't hate the people voting mattchew but if he flips town, I might have to reconsider some of my reads.
|
On February 21 2014 06:14 IAmRobik wrote:
gumshoe, you were rb'd last night, yah?
that's one of the only reasons I don't want to lynch you.
as for bum...I explaining why i think he's town a couple pages back
if push comes to shove, i'll vote mattchew. I don't like the speed at which he got pressured this game especially with the votes d2. We'll see though. I'm down for whatever at this point as long as it's not vivax420, roundabound, me, gumshoe, bum, or grack (i think that's my town circle at the moment)
I was rbed yes, but aside from that why do you want to lynch me? I think my arguments out before I post them, I dont get in insult wars with other townies, I go through filters thoroughly before I take a stance on someone and you can see all that in my history. I opt for quality over quantity and I've produced more with five posts than most people have with twenty. Which is pretty much how I've played as town in games past.
I have stuck my neck out and presented unpopular cases not because I'm yolo red, but because I genuinely want to lynch scum. I have also played entirely transparent and have given town plenty to work with, both on those I consider scummy and myself, which is saying something considering that I didnt even know I was playing this game for two days.
You've done just the same and then some, as a result I and several others have placed our faith in you. You dont have to listen to everything I say, but after I I've delivered to you Mattchews red razor mouse of doom, do have a little bit of that faith in me, given my existing contributions and upcoming accolades(matt slayer!) I dont deserve to have the whims of the trilaner be all that separates me from the noose.
|
On February 21 2014 06:41 IAmRobik wrote:
i actually don't hate the people voting mattchew but if he flips town, I might have to reconsider some of my reads.
bear in mind that as the lynch on him gets closer, scum will probally have to jump on him, if theyre smart they may have already done so, so even if/when he flips red, you may still have to reavaluate reads / :
|
as we wait longer and longer, there will be more modkills. let's wAIT! modkills help us
|
*if they happen sooner rather than later
|
gumshoe...your absence bothered me as well as the fact that I still think mattchew is town...regardless of his activity. I'll reiterate that I can be wrong here...but that's just my intuition. I'm totally down with Vivax420's plan of waiting until everyone gets modkilled. If we end up losing, I won't feel bad. If we get mafia modkilled, that would be awesome and we can read him and figure stuff out and move onto another suspect. If it ends up with 1 town modkilled, well at least we have more info and we don't have to waste a lynch on him and again, can move onto another suspect.
|
Actually. That should be the plan from now on. One person becomes obvious town as I've done this game. Then I force everyone to stop participating so that they all get modkilled and town wins.
|
On February 21 2014 06:56 IAmRobik wrote:
Actually. That should be the plan from now on. One person becomes obvious town as I've done this game. Then I force everyone to stop participating so that they all get modkilled and town wins.
omg i think you just solved iml
|
On February 21 2014 06:59 VIVAX420 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 21 2014 06:56 IAmRobik wrote:
Actually. That should be the plan from now on. One person becomes obvious town as I've done this game. Then I force everyone to stop participating so that they all get modkilled and town wins. omg i think you just solved iml
easy game easy rares
|
ok I nominate myserlf to be that townie survivor. Everyoen else STFU and if you talk you will get lynched.
|
Yeah in all seriousness I'm not doing that, I signed up to play mafia. I want to asses facts and make reads. I wanna be witness to the cases of others, be they better or worse than my own. I wanna soak it all in and that come to a conclusion based off everything I've learned so far. Above all, I want to convince my fellow townies that my case is right(or sway them on behalf of the one I believe in) and then receive the blissful gratification of having my mark come back red . I did not sign up to break a setup that is endlessly less interesting than the games that setup can produce, if only we are willing and able to be brave and smart and resilient. If we willingly solve the game like this, then were no better then those who get modkilled of thier own volition and ruin the game for everyone else.
In regards to specific modkills, the only one whose going to die potentially is sprang, and him and matt have too little interaction to make a read off that about them. Bum and matt will not get modkilled, they will pop in when they absolutley have to, make promises, and then pop off, never to fulfill them. The only way scum dies is if a) they are awful, or b) we lynch them. So can we stop being cowards and play the game? If anyone has another case i'll gladly hear it out, otherwise lets lynch the scum thats on the table.
|
VOTE COUNT:
Mattchew (4): JarJarDrinks, Grackaroni, gumshoe, roundabound, Grackaroni, JarJarDrinks
gumshoe (2): roundabound, sidesprang, IAmRobik
bumatlarge (1): Mordanis
sidesprang (1): JarJarDrinks, bumatlarge
JarJarDrinks (0): Grackaroni
With 10 players alive it takes 6 votes to lynch. Only votes in the Voting Thread will be counted!
|
So by my count, everyone has voted except for Matt and Vivax. Vivax, why have you not voted, it seems like you've had plenty of scumreads.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
