EPTOn January 17 2014 05:33 thrawn2112 wrote:
hi! awake.
koshi so scummy
hi! awake.
koshi so scummy
O rly. Tell me more.
[M][N] "SMB" Mini Mafia - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
O rly. Tell me more. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
^ This is my entire defense of all accusation. -------------------------------------------------- Now to go for scumhunting. I really don't want to omgus Grack here but I will. First Mig: On January 17 2014 03:48 Mig wrote: Grack isn't a bad 2nd candidate. He trolls as town and mafia (I feel like he does it more as mafia tho), so only trolling combined with the fact that while under pressure he just disappeared as soon as thrawn/oats started arguing and taking the heat off of him. This is the only thing that Mig has talked about that isn't Snow. I will look into previous games of Mig but I am pretty sure that Mig came into Intrigue with a post that committed to 4 reads and that there was actual fresh content in it. The reason he gives for Grack is scum is something that was said by 2 others before him. Then my opinion about Mr. Snowman. I was nodding my head when I read that case from Skanjab in the start, I agreed with it. BUT time has passed since then and the only scummy thing that Snow actually did this game is start the game "bad". Which he got a shitton of flak for and under all this pressure my scumread on him lessened which is pretty strange if he is scum because Snow posted a lot. On January 17 2014 03:46 Mig wrote: Sno is likely mafia. 1) I had the same thoughts as skan when reading sno's response to kush's question about why he seems so happy. Most townies just ignore it or dismiss it, instead of providing a real answer (which felt kind of like bs btw). 2) These posts he makes back to back In the initial post he very weakly accuses skan of possibly being mafia. Also, this is probably nothing but the stupid :/ face there doesn't really fit for a townie mindset in my eyes. If you think someone is doing something scummy why use the wishy washy face. The very next post he then implies that skan is town when he says that skan actually thinks he is scum. This doesn't really make sense unless he is mafia and already knows skan is town. #vote Sno Compared to LXIV game: + Show Spoiler + On January 13 2014 07:34 Mig wrote: To Marv I am only about 50 pages in so quick thoughts are this- thrawn is very very likely town - Mafia are rarely going to fake claim this early and on top of that oftentimes millers are not self aware. Mafia wont know whether millers are self aware or not so to claim you are a self aware early on in thread is a huge gamble (if it turns out they arent self aware and one flips later on this could potentially be suicide). I am actually a bit suspicious you just ignored this right after thrawn claimed but you didn't list him under your suspicious list at least so meh. koshi/rayn both very likely town - both playing the exact same as previous games I have played with them as town. doge- likely town, every pm game I play most of the people active in pms and trying to seek people out through skype are town. The fact that he is talking to you, he also pmd me right away, is something I don't think many mafia would do unless they were extremely confident in their play (assuming you are town). Your point about him still being suspicious of bh/hopeless is another thing that appear townie to me. Scummy people I haven't had a chance to talk to WoS or Yam in pms yet but both look bad to me. WoS's posts that I have read so far are wordy with very little content. Just seems like a lot of pointless fluff. Yam - I can't really explain it but this is based on tone for me. The last big game with mayors I played with yam he ran for mayor and seemed so much more confident and his posts were way more direct and to the point. This game he starts out writing 10 paragraphs when he could have explained his thoughts in 2 and I don't see him being nearly as aggressive. I would probably prefer if one of those 2 were lynched, but I imagine I am in the minority on that for now. Cpt obvious I think would be a bad lynch candidate. He is putting 0 effort into appearing to look good, even after people have yelled at him about looking shitty. Strikes me as a bad/lazy townie. Xat - I would be ok with a Xat lynch. I don't think his indignant pms to you really point to him being town. I haven't read the most recent stuff yet but his early posts to me seem hesitant and a lot of his early questions were pointless fluff. Look at the difference, in LXIV townreads + scumreads with a couple good new reasons. I read that post in LXIV and I immediatly felt it was good. Here, I believed that Mig was on the right track with Snow so I didn't really care too much but now that I am actually awake and can see Snow is not scum for those first 5 minutes in the game I put serious ??? with Mig. Now I will look into more games from Mig and see if he does this monotome "follow up" questioning like he did after. __________________ Grack is scum for being away from the thread for 15 hours or so. Same as in LXIII, trolling into 15 hours afk. Pretty sure he didn't do it in any other game. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 17:36 kushm4sta wrote: its ok because next time as scum I am going to be indecisive as fuck ofc more importantly: nubs read this agree or disagree? He could be scum because I don't consider him as scum at all. Mig town? Why? | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
Are you seeing this shit? It is the exact same. 1 person is scummy for Mig. All consecutive posts about this guy. ##vote: Mig | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 08:31 Hopeless1der wrote: i distinctly remember someone commenting on rayns game saying that he has good day1 reads and he gets worse over time. anyone remember who and when that was? This was marv and it was in Intrigue. My conspiracy senses are telling me that Hopeless knew this and was pushing Kush like this. So if Hopeless is scum Kush is town. After reading filter I guess that Hopeless is on the Grack/Kush are scum boat with rayn. However, he is not really defending or giving reasons why Snow is town and he is talking to Snow as if he is talking to a scumsuspect. So that's quite strange. Hopeless was also very vocal around the rayn/mig/toad 1 is scum period. He was sounding pretty confident and not trolly there. He might know more. All in all. Not really sure. Way less feelings about Hopeless scum than Mig/Grack. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 18:25 thrawn2112 wrote: Koshi have you read all the stuff I said about hopeless? He hasn't called kush scum the entire game. The only thing he's ever said about kush is that he finds kush unreadable. So why is he voting him? Why is he voting kush over any of his scumreads, especially grack who hopless has been adamnt about all game? Here's why: Might be serious.... might just be trolling. Either option is really scummy. Either option is a terrible reason to justify voting for what he calls an unkown. I think Grack also made a good point about the way hopeless treating grack at the start being similar to how hopeless treated pandain in mason chats from Time to Die. I've already pulled those mason logs, they are in the consolidated case. His playstyle doesn't look like the one from Time to Die though. He was pushing Pandain senselessly there, I just reread and remembered thinking that for the entire game. I don't agree on Hopeless. meh. He radiates being insanely useless which is like Witchraft II. But my townread on you is 54327 times stronger than the read I have on Hopeless. Could sheep. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 19:38 kushm4sta wrote: koshi this is weak. His approach is completely different in this game. That game was more of a nitpick that turned into a tunnel. Plus Mig has only been active for a very short period of time, so you can't expect him to have pushed a bunch of different people. Also he has mentioned other people he found scummy (cephiro and someone else). What? It is exactly the same. + I am working. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 19:40 kushm4sta wrote: also why are you ignoring hopeless, koshi? Why are you ignoring Mig, Kush? | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 20:30 kushm4sta wrote: Pretty much because he's been afk for a very long time, so he doesn't have that much to analyze. So what is your read on Mig? Be specific. On January 17 2014 20:36 kushm4sta wrote: KOSHI WTF. I can't see a townie ever thinking this way. It doesn't make sense. Just because someone is town that doesn't make all their reads right. Sure Kush. Sure. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 09 2014 03:30 kushm4sta wrote: rayn why do i have to read the thread when i can just read some of your excellent posts instead and get summary + analysis ok nvm it is different. You are still scum. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 21:04 kushm4sta wrote: LOL koshi why am i scum now? 1) You started with bussing 1 teammate and pushing 1 townie in Grack/Snow just like in Intrigue with JAT/WoS. 2) rayn case 3) On January 17 2014 15:51 kushm4sta wrote: rayn cephilis grack/mig final answer Here you have mig as scum, I make case on Mig. You call it a bad case and say Mig is null. HOWEVER, you have been agreeing with Mig his "tunnel" on Snow 24/7. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 21:08 raynpelikoneet wrote: Koshi you post about Mig is really good. Basically what he did intered the thread when kush was under attack and didn't say anything else than attacked Sn0. That's not what town!Mig does. You better not be scum this time. I remember your comments on VE case in the not mafia game Resistance. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
tell me in how many games as town you fakeclaimed (casually). As scum: Persona: Veteran fakeclaim LXIII: Mason | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
It was Golden Sun in which you fakeclaimed Vet. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On January 17 2014 22:13 raynpelikoneet wrote: Koshi in a scenario where the asshat is town who is scum? VA --> Pretending to know more than he actually does, typical town VA. thrawn/rayn --> both 7 page filters representing. town. snow --> Town or bussed like a motherfucker. Cephiro --> Sure why not? I got something to read him if he starts posting. Toadesstern --> I did like LSB banking a lot more than his play atm. Would not lynch though. Skanjab1s --> Where are the results of your questionnaire bro? There was something this guy said in LXIII why I thought he was town. Haven't seen that here. Got no scummy feelings though, so null. Grack scum, also made a case on me when he was scum in LXIII. Mig scum but I am interested in his next post. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
---> How sure are you? +why is 1 out of Grack/Mig scum? | ||
| ||
