EPTGolden Sun: The Lost Age Mafia Djinn Edition
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
Steveling is the first one for asking a neutral filler question, followed then by xatalos and marvelocity grabbing that opportunity to provide an easy fake contribution. From those 2 I dislike marvelocity the most, since xatalos was already there bantering, so I'll read less into his response for now. The other person is meapak_ziph. On May 21 2014 06:13 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: wait there are four factions in this game? Guess I might as well read the op then. Wave that was a mighty suspicious post, sounds like you're trying to make excuses for future bad play... He came into the thread with a weak confusion comment and something that didn't need to be said. Your post is basically the last line, which is pretty weak if your intent is to gather info from wave. What's up Marv, steve, MZ? | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 21 2014 17:17 geript wrote: Valenus I'm not quite seeing as mafia. Like there's a bit of seeming honesty and levity in his posting that I find a bit towny. Like I get why Hapa thinks he could be an ok lynch but he feels more like a "fun Fred" gamer instead of a "competitive Carl" gamer. It's not a real solid read but I'm looking elsewhere for D1 unless something more specific pops up. This is my perspective on him as well. His posts do not read like someone feigning contributions, just someone casually posting because he felt like. Holyflare's reason for considering him town is also the type of weak evidence that I find compelling early on. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 21 2014 17:28 geript wrote: You mind telling us who you are? Like you're obviously a smurf of some kind. I'm not going to, because it not only invalidates the purpose of signing up as a smurf, but it feels also feels cheap to reveal your identity based on your alignment. That is, players are more likely to do that as town than as mafia. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 21 2014 18:33 marvellosity wrote: The fact you are a smurf and the fact you characterised my answer to Steveling as suspicious, when anyone on this forum knows 100% that my answer to Steveling was in no way suspicious and I would certainly answer that way as both alignments. It was just an answer to a question. The reason I am now voting for you is that because this page confirms you are a smurf, and if you are a smurf, you should know better. Which means you were just bullshitting vomit reads, so you're mafia. I'm not sure what I was exactly thinking when I made that post, you will know later when I ask myself, but my guess is that it was more about you entering the thread with that type of post. Personally I'm not impressed by the rest of your posts so far, as I'm not seeing any of the pointed questions you tend to typically ask. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 21 2014 18:49 marvellosity wrote: Literally irrelevant. A townie who has even played a single game with me would never even bring up what I said as suspicious. Not even casually. Bad, bad, bad. The fact you know/think I ask "pointed questions" makes your original point on my post look even worse. Keep going? If you are town, you should take a deep breath and reassess the strength of your perceived meta point. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 21 2014 19:01 marvellosity wrote: There's nothing to reassess, what I said is perfectly clear. So you stand by the notion that literally no town aligned player who has played with you could find the way you entered the thread suspicious? Does it follow that you consider me confirmed mafia now? | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
Bunnies looking to put pressure else and off of her, looooooking sccummy again. He appears to be suggesting that attempting to find mafia is mafia behavior. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
I stand by my marv read so far. I think it's more likely he enterss the thread like that as scum than town, and his unwarrated anger after he got called out doesn't read natural either. The rest of his filter is really uninspiring for someone who has been on the thread for basically the whole game, even if you are just skimming. He is bickering on irrelevant points and not asking the right questions, which further enforces my feeling he might be mafia. The level of confidence he later uses to say that we are scum for questioning him on his entering post is also way off. That said I'm willing to give him a pass for today, because even if he isn't town aligned he is capable of uncovering other mafia and if he is town aligned it's a shame to mislynch him in the first day. Also there is a chance that he atracts a bullet too as any alignment so lynching him today is not the highest ev. I still feel a bit uneasy about MZ, but wouldn't lynch today either. I think his posting improved a bit after the the first couple. And speaking of entering the thread as scum, after I reread the thread jampi caught my attention: On May 21 2014 06:09 jampidampi wrote: Right back at you: who do you refer to by "we"? Your faction? All of us? Non-town factions? This string of quotes don't look natural at all. As I've said when you enter the thread as scum you have to force yourrself into a mindset and it often looks a bit off. In this case the level of aggression and "scumhunting" which are normally characteristics of a townie are way over the top and forced, thus I feel there is a strong chance jampi is scum. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
Jampi still looks bad for the reasons the other head mentioned, as does Austin for fluffy and underwhelming content, in contrast with what I've seen from him as town recently. Essentially all of his reads so far have been in response to someone specifically asking him for them rather him being proactive. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
| ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
People on top of my lynch list currently are jampi ritoky and austin. I'd like marv HF and fool to comment on those 3 for me. And austin in case you are town you can start doing something useful and comment on the other 2. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 21 2014 12:33 layabout wrote: Her posts are logically consistent and represent a reasonable approach to the game particularly for a new player - not wanting to call people scum before you are confident or have had enough time to make an argument that is worth consideration by others. Her tone is generally good and her posting is on the productive side as far as the thread goes. However Your point that she does not consider that you are scum voting for her is significant. She immediately talks to you as if she thinks you are town which is not the typical reaction to being voted for. The interpreting your vote as a mafia read could just be how ninja uses language but it also suggests guilt. And that is my opinion on you case. Pls shoot people that post like austin's hula stuff, it's tempting to go with gut scum reads but town kp is our only way to effectively deal with that crap and in large games the tone of the thread and proportion of inactives and shitposters has a ridiculous impact. I like this post. I'd like to hear more from laya. | ||
|
bkqyrldp
49 Posts
On May 22 2014 05:52 marvellosity wrote: I'm curious what you like about it? As far as I see it, this post says this: First para: She is not suspicious Second para: She is suspicious Third para: This is my conclusion (she is suspicious and not suspicious) Fourth para: Shoot austin who has barely spam posted but posted 2 pictures. I actually think the post is terrible for paras 1-3, because it basically just says yes and no without actually coming to a conclusion himself on tamb's alignment. I actually like the first paragraph more. But it shows someone trying to figure out the game. 2nd para I disagree with, but still shows a natural thought process. I'm not saying laya is town for sure but I would like to hear more from him before I decide if I want to lynch him. Now can you tell me about the 3 I asked you about? | ||
| ||
