Golden Sun: The Lost Age Mafia Djinn Edition - Page 5

On May 21 2014 12:14 thrawn2112 wrote:
Why do you think it's obvious that you're town?

The question you quote is intended to make her think about different possibilities. It's not me wanting her to answer in a certain why. It's clearly a question meant to make her think out of the box. Why would I vote on someone I think is town? Do you really just say "for information", and that's all? Like really.

On May 21 2014 12:18 thrawn2112 wrote:


You scum read Cav for accurately meta reading you last game, but you expect people to be correctly meta reading you right now?

On May 21 2014 12:26 mtamburini wrote:


He does deserve much more pressure youll get a better read of him, but he did do this shit last game and I tunneled on him hard to find him towny in 2 days

On May 21 2014 12:27 Cavalinho wrote:


I'll tell you on one condition:

You tell me how to link posts. Deal?

I kinda of liked the initial response to BH. Wasn't "RNG dum", but was like..."okay, so you have this idea, but why not do another thing instead?" It's not the laziest response, it's not calling him scum, it's not really doing anything other than what seems like trying to figure something out. Bueno.

On May 21 2014 12:40 27ninjabunnies wrote:
@TehPoofter: So I've read through yell0w's filter, and as I stated before, I like yellow's post here. I feel as if he was mafia, he wouldn't even bring this up, as he could follow exactly what he had spelled out.

[red]In our previous game, yell0w contradicted himself, much like he did this game, and I called him out for it. I pushed on him, which is how I got my read on him.[red] Yell0w seems to be joking a bit towards the beginning, such as his preferring a "alive cat to a dead cat" and pretty relaxed. I haven't played a game with him as mafia, but it seems like a town play to me.

I do agree that his switching to go with BH on the odin lynch is a bit weird, especially since he disagreed with it earlier, but it may just be him reassessing the game there.

He also hasn't posted much for me to get more of a read, but I'm leaning more town here.

On May 21 2014 12:45 austinmcc wrote:
Hf, do YOU think the 180 actually matters? And is there any pro-scum reason?

On May 21 2014 12:58 mtamburini wrote:


From the way many people have told me to read HF, hes prob town he seems disappointed and not having fun. I hear he enjoys being mafia 100x more than he is town.

On May 21 2014 13:05 Cephiro wrote:


I definitely agree that she is not scum for that reason alone. It's because of this combined with many other factors I pointed out. Like, what do you think of her claim of providing reasoning for her reads when she really hadn't?

On May 21 2014 07:23 27ninjabunnies wrote:
So here's where I am at.

I don't necessarily like thrawn. Not talking isn't productive for town. Whether he's stubborn town or straight up mafia, I'd lynch him in a heartbeat.

I also want to hear more from Jamp. He seems to be focussing on the 'reads' that I said I had within the first couple of pages, and then questions someone else on what they think about my reads, yet he hasn't really said anything about what he thinks. Also, why is he focussing on my reads? Not saying mine are bad, but im a new player, one he hasn't played with. So why does it matter necessarily what I think?

Tehpoofter, steve, and WOS were the ones that I were considering first out of the ones that have talked the first couple of pages, but my reads, as I'm sure you have seen since I talked about you and thrawn, have changed since then.