Regardless of BH's alignment this game isn't normal. I don't think I've seen many normal conversations in this game. Like I get it, Slam having BH's role ame in his pm is weird. But I have, I think, 2-3 other players role names in mine (not sure bc I know nothing about golden sun). Idk, maybe I originally was right on both of them. Honestly like I don't see what you find super odd/weird/scummy. Could you clarify (on phone at work).

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 03:40 GMT

#3531

On May 24 2014 12:30 Steveling wrote:

Show nested quote +

The fact that slam knew that BH's role was not immune to that control power/thing/whatever.
That was his BH's bluff, he wanted to seem like is immune too.

I'm talking about these posts

Show nested quote +

and

Show nested quote +

I don't see how two people having the same roles makes them bot scum. HF might be vig, idk. But I don't think he's scum just because he has (claimed) the same role as me.

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 03:58 GMT

#3534

On May 24 2014 12:30 Steveling wrote:

Show nested quote +

The fact that slam knew that BH's role was not immune to that control power/thing/whatever.
That was his BH's bluff, he wanted to seem like is immune too.

I'm talking about these posts

Show nested quote +

and

Show nested quote +

Like I really don't get it. Pretend with me for a second that Slam and BH have the same role mechanically. K? Then BH claims that people can be controlled. Slam feels confident in BH telling the truth because BH's role aligns with his. Like that makes sense.

You know the number of times I've seen mafia make a play like this? 0. This gives BH 2-3 days to live max which is like fucking awful EV if he's non-town because there's so many non-town factions yes, BH is capable of a role like this. Slam is potentially capable of doing something like this if he had a controlling role. Highly unlikely either of them is not town. Highly unlikely that it's good play for both of them to come out like this. Hell, Slam should've role claimed fully D1. The odds of both of them being non-town are ridiculously low. The odds of them both being non-town together are ridiculously lower. Chill and use your head.

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 04:18 GMT

#3538

Yah that's a minor surprise, but I can think of a few twists considering his name (must drink a flask to continue to live, flasks must be used in order to vet up, flasks can be stolen, etc).

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 06:14 GMT

#3563

BH I would like to point out that if I had a vendetta against you, I would just egged Scumeling on towards you as much as I could.

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 21:00 GMT

#3690

I don't find you off your rocker snooglewoogle. I'm less impressed with the Kush case than before. Gonna filter once I catch up.

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 21:04 GMT

#3691

On May 25 2014 05:15 marvellosity wrote:
anyone fancy building a wagon on him and seeing if it makes him do something?

I wanted to kill him yesterday, twice.

geript

10024 Posts

May 24 2014 21:08 GMT

#3692

I disagree Austin. <3 policy.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:00 GMT

#3727

On May 25 2014 07:26 austinmcc wrote:
Pookie Pie you still here?

Got caught up with cooking dinner I'm back snooglewoogle

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:11 GMT

#3730

He's looked more and more townie to me in some regards. He feels really off though and idk what it is.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:13 GMT

#3731

Wait who was I planning to read again Austin? Nampo and? Idk. I'll just read lurkers.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:24 GMT

#3734

Ritoky, could you explain where and how your tambo scumread disappeared into Laya and Wave?

@Snooglewoogle. How Jampi jumps around seems really towny to me honestly. Like he's jumping around but all of the thoughts are connected in a natural way. Considering the time between the reads, it seems odd but not damning to me.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:26 GMT

#3736

On May 25 2014 09:16 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm curious if you followed YOSO after you died btw. Slam in many regards played... pretty sensibly, less all over the place, and I would say it wasn't that obvious he was "enjoying himself" (one of your things on him). On day 6 I think there he pushed Ace pretty concertedly and seriously with me. It looked frighteningly normal :p

Somewhat. Not much. Still though his early game was drastically different. If he's changed for good I'm going to be a little sad.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:28 GMT

#3738

On May 25 2014 09:26 austinmcc wrote:

Show nested quote +

Whatchoo mean about him jumping around?

Follow his thought process like he's scummy on Bunny, asked MZ what he thought of the Jamp-bunny interaction, bounces onto MZ. Like it's a clear natural progression IMO. Doesn't look or feel forced.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:30 GMT

#3739

That looks really townie from ritoky. I can't quite explain it.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:37 GMT

#3745

I just don't see a reason to exclude that type of progression what reading the player.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 00:50 GMT

#3755

I think Thrawn is mafia. Can't explain it well. The Kush read is really odd. He's also not withdrawn at all; like he's just angry. Like Kush is usually pretty detached from the thread and what I've seen of Thrawn (and how to read him) is that he's like 30% of Kush apart from the threat. Here it looks more like he has no interest in playing whatsoever which is more what I understand of his mafia play.

geript

10024 Posts

May 25 2014 08:47 GMT

#3998

I think whatever I caught got passed to Hapa