A Quiet Game of Mini Mafia - Page 5

On January 09 2014 16:05 wherebugsgo wrote:
I am not suggesting though, that yamato has to be scum. He very well could be based on how much of a useless asshole he continues to be. However, considering him town is stupid.

In fact I would say it is so stupid that it's even worse than someone coming up with an elaborate conspiracy that Yamato had to have bussed, because at the very least in the second case the player still leaves open the possibility of killing Yamato. In the first case it is nearly impossible to convince a player who has taken on the mentality that counter wagons have to be of opposite alignment to lynch someone like that later in the game when it is completely obvious that you have no choice left.

On January 09 2014 16:33 wherebugsgo wrote:
I'm lecturing you assholes because you're all saying really stupid things like "day 1 countered wagons have to be town" and "if we kill a townie we just rinse and repeat"

If it didn't sound like you were all clueless I wouldn't have to keep yelling at you for forgetting the newbie guide.

On January 09 2014 16:52 wherebugsgo wrote:


Not in the least, no,

WoS's reasoning at least to me seems very organic. The tone and thought process he displays is completely open and actually quite thorough. If more townies played like him it'd be great, because even if their reads are wrong you can be sure they've given you a real opinion that they've independently thought about, regardless of what you end up doing with that opinion.

While I didn't agree with some things he said, almost everything he's said so far makes complete sense from a town perspective. The only thing that can be labelled at all scummy is the hesitation to vote corazon, but even that has a far likelier town explanation-he was probably afraid his interaction with Cora (the one that's really hard to fake if they're both scum, btw) caused his opinion on him to be biased.