TL Mafia LXIV: A Game of Intrigue - Page 78

TL Mafia XLIV: A Game of Intrigue

1 Townie point = -1 Mafia point
Therefore 1 townie-point+ 1 mafia point = 0

1. raynpelikoneet
clicky! If this was a sarcastic sidestab this guy is golden for putting it this way and not even giving any openings. Seems unlikely so it's only 0.1 Townie-points
clicky! Seems pointless but I like the pressure if it's supposed to be pressure. 0.1 Townie-points
clicky! You're missing the point that BH liks to try out weird crap that only works in very specific situations like claiming he's a medic and that people don't need to protect insert-vet because he'll do so just to find out that he lied and the vet is dead the next day. Those kind of gimmicy plays are abyssal in normal games but are somewhat encouraged in PM games and actually work if you do it correctly.
Clicky! Finally someone having the balls to point that out. 0.3 Townie-points.
Clicky! In response to Yamato's case! I like this guy. 0.1 Townie-points.
Clicky! Good train of though. 0.2 Townie-points
clicky! This is how you scumhunt. It's not about what people say but why they they something and how they got to the conclusion. Those are 3 excellent questions that DrH has still refused to answer which makes it look like he can't, which in term makes it look like he just sprouted some "reads" he can't back up, which is a heavy mafia read. 0.3 Townie-points.
Clicky! Why do you need to get someone else in office for him to listen to you so that the person you want lynched dies? Wouldn't it be easier to just do it yourself? 0.4 Mafia-points
clicky! Seems like legit rage but that kind of stuff is super easy to fake so only 0.1 Townie-points
clicky! I actually agree with Mocsta here, this looks faked so I take back the 0.1 Townie-points from before.

2. BloodyC0bbler 

3. chinstrap 

4. bumatlarge

5. marvellosity
clicky! Good post, sadly this is marv and he's able to make these posts as mafia without giving a crap. I'll just divide his points by 5 if they're on the good side I guess, so 0.1 Townie-points.
Clicky! Decent post but I'm not going into 0.XX points (after dividing by 5) so nothing for you Marv!

6. Yamato77
clicky! Too lazy to read the entire thing but the parts I read were nice. I disagree with his take on BC and don't think that's scummy but I haven't seen the game he's talking about. Only 0.2 Townie-points because I haven't actually read the whole thing and need to do later when I finished catching up.

7. Mig

8. kushm4sta VayneAuthority

9. Alakaslam 
clicky! I like the first line despite not agreeing on VE at all and despite him being very ... paranoid? He's overdoing it but whatever. 2nd line is utter bullshit. Cancels out I guess.
Clicky! Still too paranoid... but I'll give him 0.1 Townie-points for that?
Clicky! Post about him I agree. 0.2 Mafia-points.

10. VisceraEyes
clicky! I'd like to see this PM...
clicky! Ever so slightly nice post. 0.1 Townie-points
clicky! I really don't like that VE keeps defending Dr.H. I'm not talking about the fact that I disagree and think Dr.H is scummy but I'm talking about the fact that VE shouldn't be defending one specific person that much. It's his third post like this. Just let him post for himself? Yes I know VE said himself he's a townhunter but that doesn't mean you get to slide by simply by putting tons of easy to make posts into the thread. 0.4 Mafia-points.
Clicky! The fact that he feels the need to emphasis that he IS INDEED talking about him, just not in public is something scummy. Town-VE should let this slide now the question's just if he WOULD also do that.. 0.2 Mafia-points.
Clicky! If that's your intention you should not have told him that you're discussing him "secretly"... no points because same as above.

11. Koshi

12. DoctorHelvetica
click! Too much text for a simple "duh, no?!?" but I guess I shouldn't be the one saying that... anyways 0.1 Mafia-points
clicky! So NOONE in the thread takes BH serious, DH accuses him to be the kind of player that only tries to confuse town and get town to talk about bullshit (see previous link), which if it was to be the case, failed horribly until DH himself gets in here and goes wall of text about this when everyone else pretty much completly ignored it to begin with. Big red flag. 1.0 Mafia-points
clicky! The fuck? The first link is about how BH makes the discussion worthless with his "discussion", 2nd one DH does exactly what he's accusing BH to do (which I did not see happening) and now he's saying that if it was his intention to create discussion that's good despite calling it useless discussion in post1?!?!? And still, he's the only one talking about this crap. If I was a dayvig I'd shoot him right about now and it's like 5 pages into the game? 0.5 Mafia-points
clicky! More useless stuff... I'd get it if he was discussing this with someone like Marv or VE but he's talking to the self-described noob. What good is that supposed to bring? If he's right, and he certainly is with his points he's making the nooby overwhelmed by this but it's still a null because you don't expect them to have the game figured out anyways. So that's why if this discussion was something with Marv, VE or someone else on equal footings it'd be something but like this it's just a show-off which certaintly is a mafia treat... Not going to give him more mafia-points for that because it's basicly the same as above and he tends to be the kind of guy who thinks he has to be the Savior of Mafia who raises the skilllevel of everyone in the game according to his ideas... but he's still not talking about useful stuff while complaining about BH and how he supposedly ruined the discussion.
Clicky! Again the same thing over and over again... if this guy is town he has to work on that. Not giving mafia-points for that as it's still the same deal.
Clicky! Could be nothing or a mafia trick "duh, I didn't even know godfather get's elected how am I supposed to be mafia". Certainly not a townie "trick" though. Not worth any points because it's pure speculation either way and unlikely to be a trick (imo) but if it adds up later on it's worth noting.
Clicky! I'd like this post if that would have been his first response to it. I haven't fully read the BH big post. If there's something in there about it, fine, if not it's a question why he thinks it's necesarry to write this out this way after already answering earlier with another post. No points because too lazy to read BH's post yet.
Clicky! Yet another bad post imo. He's assuming the "wagon" changing has to be something bad. It's certainly possible but if there's a god damn reason that a wagon changes you don't hammer the other guy just because... which again makes it look like he's writing good looking phrases and nothing else. 0.2 mafia-points.
Clicky! I actually read that whole thing. The post is decent except for the very last paragraph were he's pissed about rayn for no reason. He should be better than to this but it's a long post and there's bound to be stuff I disagree with in such a wall of text.
Clicky! That's a lie, people were mostly ignoring it with onelines along the lines of "i object to BH being mayor ". That's not discussion. Only 0.2 Mafia-points because he could actually be that self-centered.
Clicky! He never said he has beef with DrH to begin with but with the people who are backing him for no reason.

13. WaveofShadow
clicky! He's not usually that self centered is he? Weird but no idea yet.
Clicky! Slightly concerning post. Why is he questioning how the other guy can know that he'll be a good mayor. Not only is there no answer to that question and he's obviously being trolled to some degree here, he's doubting himself in a kind of backpaddle way. Do not like. 0.2 Mafia-points.
Clicky! :D
clicky! Good question. 0.1 Townie-points

14. Xatalos
clicky! Slightly too scared undertone for me. Don't like how he's putting emphasis on the "as town or mafia" with his commas. Could easily be just be mad at him and not mean anything or maybe just think it's necessary to put it like that. 0.1 Mafia-points.
Clicky! Again, ever so slightly to "friendly/scared" for my taste. 0.1 Mafia-points
Clicky! Being overagressive... you didn't even give him a full hour and he said "soon (tm)". Could be a mafia desperatly trying to find things that look scummy or an overagressive townie, has yet to be seen, no change of points. 0.1 Mafia-points

15. gumshoe 
Disclaimer: A LOT assumes that he is a noob, need to figure that out. If he's a smurf insta lynch dat.
clicky! Slightly townish if he's a new guy, ever so slightly townish if he's not new but just bad like he said himself. Have to check that out and check timestamp again to get a guess about how likely this is to be someone elses post/suggestion, assuming he's mafia. 0.3 Townie-points
clicky! That's the 3rd post like that in a row... he should start talking about stuff other why he is the most dandy mayor due to his noobiness. 0.1 Mafia-points
clicky! Exactly what I mentioned under Dr.H when he made that post... it's obviously correct and everyone who played games in the 2 digits knows this but it still looks townish to noobsies for absolutely no reason. I guess that's a slight town tell for gumshoe to be so straight forward and agree to this. 0.1 Townie-points.

16. Derrida

17. Blazinghand
clicky! Sadly a null because it's BH. Would be townpoints for being retarded and fearless at the same time but since it's BH it's only retarded. 1.0 Retard-points. No idea if his 2nd part is supposed to be a troll/joke or if people actually consider him to be a target these days. Please don't let it be the latter one.
Clicky! Please tell me you yourself are baiting there... 0.3 Retard-points
clicky! Either scummy or bad choice of words. He knows exactly how kush is going to play but has no idea how to read him? In that case the first one is either a lie, an exaggeration due to anger or retardation. 0.2 Mafia-points
clicky! Not his post but it's about him. He better have a god damn good reason to do something like that. 0.2 Retard-points and no Mafia-points because it's BH
Clicky! :D
PM's he send out: slight town tell? 0.3 Townie-points, be happy you don't get more Retard points for that because I haven't read the pm.

18. justanothertownie
clicky! I think that's a smurf I know but the two people who used it (about 2 years ago and 0.5 years ago?) are both playing in here... so I'm either wrong and confusing him with someone or the smurf is used by someone else. Important thing being: If it's a smurf that's slightly scummy, if it's a noob it's a null. 0.3 Mafia-points and go ask that guy if he's one of BC's smurfs.

19. thrawn2112
clicky! I like this guy 0.5 Townie-points
clicky! Still like this guy. 0.2 Townie-points
clicky! Still like this guy. 0.2 Townie-points
clicky! First not nice post by this guy... but than again, would a Mafia lie like that? Marv did it in.... whatever the gamename was when he replaced in for someone d1 as mafia and I don't think it's that unheard of that anyone would boldly claim "no" to that question.
Clicky! Likes a guy I like, 0.1 Townie-Points

20. Mocsta
clicky! He's overdoing the troll to a point that it looks faked imo... 0.1 mafia points and 0.1 Retard-points
Clicky! He's REALLY overdoing the troll... but it's overdone so badly that I'm only giving him 0.2 mafia points for this because this has to be planned either way... for whatever the reason may be so 0.5 Retard-points as well.
Clicky! I tend to agree but I also think you're scummy for acting scummy on purpose. I guess that cancels each other out while giving alakaslam mafia points.
Clicky! Probably a troll. If so I have just decided that he has accumilated the critical amount of Retard-points required to be ignored unless there's a good reason not to ignore him. 0.8 Retard-points and need to adjust BH's points (lower them) by 0.5 to still make sense

21. suchdoge
clicky! His first post. I like the post, I don't like the fact that he doesn't post anything besides that. All easy to say stuff. Still 0.1 Townie-points.

22. Captain Obvious
clicky! Please be Palmar

23. Aquanim
clicky! Super bad post for two reasons: Firstply because the phrasing sounds awfully forced (might be wrong, as always on such things but if they add up it might be something). Secondly and most importantly because he's basicly asking BC about BC's "key" to looking like a useful townie. If BC answers that it's the easiest thing in the world for mafia to fool BC, at least in PM's... 0.5 Mafia-points.
Clicky! Super bad again... but so bad it makes no sense either way so I guess he's just being honest either way?

24. mkfuba07 Coagulation
25. Hopeless1der
clicky! Slightly bold text stating that he wants people to tell him their alignments. Very likely to be nothing but a mafia might be too scared to put it like this. 0.1 townie-points