TL Mafia LXIII: Time to Die - Page 16

On November 26 2013 10:00 marvellosity wrote:

Day 4 Final Vote Count:

Risen (5): Mr. Cheesecake, VayneAuthority, Pandain, Risen, Koshi, Mig, Holyflare, Grackaroni, Alakaslam, Onegu

thrawn2112 (7): austinmcc, Holyflare, Hopeless1der, Coagulation, Grackaroni, Mr. Cheesecake, LoneMeow, Holyflare, Alakaslam

Pandain (0): Hopeless1der

VayneAuthority (2): thrawn2112, Alakaslam, Alakaslam

Alakaslam (1): VayneAuthority


not voting (1): Oatsmaster

thrawn2112 is lynched! If you see a vote out of place please inform me or someone else on the hosting team so that we can correct it.

On November 30 2013 14:01 Pandain wrote:


Your "read" on onegu is pretty bullshit. Never even mentioned him before last cycle; what happened to your forever top read Coag? I'd like to hear why you think onegu is scum

I think its simple. If we're going with "mafia didnt want to bus thrawn" we lynch into my list. If we're going with "mafia bussed thrawn" then thats a high risk high reward play by mafia. Im willing to just play the most likely scenario amd say o buss which means everyone on the wagon is town. The unknowns are oats/onegu/pandain/vayne/'slam. 3 are mafia. Sont want to lynch pandain right now which leaves 4 dudes. This is why i said game was easy if risen flipped town.

On December 02 2013 00:10 LoneMeow wrote:
I want to lynch Oatsmaster, and here's why:

1. Smoke screening during D3 votes.

This is what he posted in the game thread:





But, in the voting thread:





2. D3 votes

He keeps calling BC scum before the D3 wagons start forming, yet once they do he votes someone else, and in the end his votes end up outside all of the viable lynch wagons. Then he tries to collect cred for "being right":


Also, he called Risen scum and had a vote on him, then ended up switching away without any explanation whatsoever. Then starts pushing Risen after the lynch - now why would you switch away from a viable lynch candidate to someone who's definitely not going to get lynched only to start pushing again after the lynch.




3. (Not) pushing lynches

Despite having called people scum he never pushed a lynch until Risen (who flipped town) and Onegu. Despite calling BC scum many times he never really seemed to care if others would vote for him or not.

On December 02 2013 01:42 austinmcc wrote:
Reading coag then oats. Just to try and find stuff.

Coag town imo. Doesn't try to get BC elected D1 at all, calls him town, yes, but whatevs on that. He doesn't really try to push anyone off BC on D3 either, calls him town but no effort into saving.

He ... is mostly inactive but gets really, really active when he thinks people are super lying - grack about himself, and then the pandain/SS situation. I actually like that, just gut read is that those are things that might pull in someone not overly paying attention, and he's consistent in getting active whenever someone appears to be lying.

N3, coag randomly says to lynch thrawn/oats if he dies. I HAVE NO IDEA WHY HE SAYS THRAWN HE HASN'T MENTIONED THRAWN AT ALL AND THAT IS VERY CURIOUS!?!?!?!?!? IF HE WAS MAFIA HE KNOWS HE WON'T DIE AND HE DOESN'T WANT THRAWN LYNCHED ETC. ETC. LIKE THERE JUST ISN'T A REASON TO DO THIS AS MAFIA, GIVE A FAKE DEATH THING AND ONE THAT WILL LOOK A LITTLE WONKY?

Then he's cool with risen OR thrawn lynch, wants oats, but doesn't care between the other two. I don't understand why he goes lynch thrawn if I die --> thrawn neutral --> vote thrawn if he's mafia. He doesn't need to, and ... he KNOWS that he's gonna start catching some flak and maybe get lynched soonish. Why does he go wonky like this? If he's trying to protect someone and die in their stead, maybe, but scum doesn't WANT to lose anyone.

Then he's really concerned about why Mig wants to lynch him if Risen flips red. Scum coag knows risen won't flip red, probably doesn't care so much about that? + Show Spoiler +. Yeah, sure, scum dont' want to get lynched or suspicified, but scumcoag knows this doesn't matter. And instead of calling mig out on this read, this statement, whatever, trying to make himself look a little better or get mig to update a read, he doesn't really interact with mig afterward. Imo, less trying to save his mafia skin and more just wanting to know why mig was going to lynch him, legitimate townie question?

On to oatstown!