I'm not sold on the D2 lynch jumping around as him. At first maby.. and I need to go back and really do analysis. That said I feel like it's to convenient. I'm also really curious about the post he made on pg 70-71. These are just trying to make OWB look better.

StorrZerg

United States13921 Posts

November 06 2013 04:09 GMT

#1511

On November 06 2013 13:02 Balla24 wrote:
I was rolling around cake/owb, storr/owb seems a bit outrageous but not impossible...

lynch owb then easy peasy

granted your rolling around plenty of other scum pairs too

Balla24

2322 Posts

November 06 2013 04:10 GMT

#1512

Who are you talking about?

Balla24

2322 Posts

November 06 2013 04:11 GMT

#1513

**@Odin

OdinOfPergo

United States840 Posts

November 06 2013 04:27 GMT

#1514

Storr, now I'm not completely sold on it since I haven't had a lot of time to really digest what I've just finished reading since I've been gone.. I feel like Storr doesn't honestly expect to gain traction on OWB here. The thread being so dead helps in this regard, the modkill question on Poofter seems like it could be a last ditch call to get people to swap. This seems really illogical to me at first. But maby he intended this to look better when Poofter magically shows back up. But if he really thought that voting ended in 1 min I can assume he's counting on being on the scum vote to try to make himself look better. Not really sure how I should think about it. Then the post on not thinking OWB expecting a blue flip.. I read OWB post as if he was really hoping for a blue flip. And then it feels like the only reason OWB post at all here is that he wanted to try to fish blues to claim. So while he's still saying he's scummy for that post... other than the timing of the post coming up so fast, you disregard it's point entirely. I feel like the case against owb is still light enough that he doesn't honestly believe it will change anything.

Balla24

2322 Posts

November 06 2013 04:34 GMT

#1515

I'm gonna do some thinking and possibly make new cases tomorrow morning. Odin I don't really understand your post just now...... can you reword and make what you are talking about more clear? You're jumping around incoherently..

Balla24

2322 Posts

November 06 2013 04:38 GMT

#1516

##unvote

OdinOfPergo

United States840 Posts

November 06 2013 04:39 GMT

#1517

Ye, I can't really think of a way to word it. Given that people were having issues with my post being confusing, Maby I should just wait until I have the time to write an analysis.. Hmm, I'm going to wait until tomorrow so I can decide on how I feel about this. I shouldn't of brought it up because I haven't really got my own conclusion for it yet.

StorrZerg

United States13921 Posts

November 06 2013 04:50 GMT

#1518

All right lets look at odin

On October 31 2013 11:34 OdinOfPergo wrote:
Ok holy crap.
Actually you know what,
I'm not sorry.
I work really freaking hard to support my lifestyle. If anyone wants to call me out for it...
Well let's dance baby.
Anyway, I need to re-read this thread again but on first glance I don't like
Cake, July, or Jonny at all.
Their post offer little content or crumby arguments.
I need to persue these leads obv since I haven't been here.
But give me like an hour. Maby two.
I will type up an explanation for my reads.

first feeling he has, doesnt like 2 towns, possible a 3rd (cake) Posts a lot defending himself with out actually giving reasons why for his reads. He finally gets around to reads on Cake, Jonny, july, nyx
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=433102&currentpage=17#322
I liked his call out on jonny, i agree with his case against cake, his july case is kinda null imo. He defends nyx based on nyx play last game, but also inquires that nyx explain himself more on his reasons. (something i've personally been pushing for nyx to do since day 2)
overall it doesn't truly feel like "scum hunting" but i seem to at least understand his frustration in this post and why he is attacking these people.
His opinion on people changes (cake in particular, which i like since i read cake as town)

After rereading his filter from day 1. I like odin,
His defense of nyx seems reasonable. His attacks seemed reasonable. The way he came around on cake, seemed like a town. It doesn't feel like 2 mafia poking each other and moving on.
Going to reread the next cycle now.

StorrZerg

United States13921 Posts

November 06 2013 04:56 GMT

#1519

On November 06 2013 13:27 OdinOfPergo wrote:
Storr, now I'm not completely sold on it since I haven't had a lot of time to really digest what I've just finished reading since I've been gone.. I feel like Storr doesn't honestly expect to gain traction on OWB here. The thread being so dead helps in this regard, the modkill question on Poofter seems like it could be a last ditch call to get people to swap. This seems really illogical to me at first. But maby he intended this to look better when Poofter magically shows back up. But if he really thought that voting ended in 1 min I can assume he's counting on being on the scum vote to try to make himself look better. Not really sure how I should think about it. Then the post on not thinking OWB expecting a blue flip.. I read OWB post as if he was really hoping for a blue flip. And then it feels like the only reason OWB post at all here is that he wanted to try to fish blues to claim. So while he's still saying he's scummy for that post... other than the timing of the post coming up so fast, you disregard it's point entirely. I feel like the case against owb is still light enough that he doesn't honestly believe it will change anything.

If we get a mod kill, and a lynch. we gain more information as town.... the mod kill only works if tehpoofter stayed inactive and no replacement was found. This would be a really low cheap shot to do... To plan this out and act on it as mafia... I would not do it, i was upset of the possibility of it happening in the hogwarts game.

Read how you want the time, but i was completely honest on thinking the vote ended at that time.

What point am i disregarding entirely?
My case against OWB day 2 was light. he was not my #1 lynch..