|
On November 04 2013 07:40 OdinOfPergo wrote:
Vonthin, could you try to include the name/date portion of a quote.. It would make this a lot easier.
Also, you rehashing a lot of things, not bringing a whole lot in.. Frankly Poofter looks the worst out of lurkers and these post seem like you are just trying to focus on someone other than him if we have to lynch a lurker.
I said I would lynch him, I just think OWB is a better lynch. Poofter looks suspicious but I think he at least tried to contribute. OWB has done nothing all game imo
|
On November 04 2013 07:41 OdinOfPergo wrote:
His day 2 consist of the same style of play with less activity. I don't like the fact he's mia most of the time but I don't think he's scum for it. His D2 focus is mainly about you and I don't like you that much myself.
he has been around day 2.. he responded asap to my post. and since then made 1 kinda post. and then rest 1 liners and then afk'd
but there is no more point talking about him today. since we need a lynch.
|
and what's your opinion on any of the other reads? It's not like you have a shortage of things to talk about.
|
Vote Count
JonnyLaw (0): Obzy, OdinOfPergo
onlywonderboy (1): Vonthin, Obzy
StorrZerg (2): nyxnyxnyx, cakemanofdoom
Vonthin (2): Balla24, onlywonderboy, OdinOfPergo
nyxnyxnyx (0): StorrZerg
Tehpoofter (2): JonnyLaw, Balla24
Not voting (4): Tehpoofter, E00e, Obzy, StorrZerg
Currently no one is set to be lynched. With 11 alive it takes 6 votes to lynch.
This game uses Majority Lynch. Voting is mandatory. Please format your vote properly as such: ##Vote: Marv
Please ##Unvote first when changing your vote.
Day 2 ends in at 01:00 GMT (+00:00).
If there are any errors please let us know.
|
On November 04 2013 07:43 OdinOfPergo wrote:
and what's your opinion on any of the other reads? It's not like you have a shortage of things to talk about.
what opinions do you want to know
|
K going to try and look to see who i want to lynch of OWB (preferred as of this moment) Vonthin and tehpoofter.
|
Thoughts on my case of Jonny, Storr, Vonthin? Thoughts of Balla's cases, what do you think about the Nyx case? How do you feel about Cake right now? I realize you don't OWB, while I don't really agree with it that's not the only reason I don't like you right now. I want to know more.. You coming in posting a lot of irrelevant stuff and then a crumby case on a lurker instead of trying to kill scum is not a town oriented play style.
|
ebwop I realize you don't like OWB*
|
On November 04 2013 07:42 onlywonderboy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 04 2013 07:29 Vonthin wrote:Even after OWB most recent posts I still think he is a good candidate for a lynch today. I think I explained my case about e00 pretty well. There are a lot of uncertainties surrounding the day 1 lynch. More times than not they come down to hunches rather than hard facts just because there is so much less information to work with. e00 was playing in a way that wasn't directly benefiting town and I thought there was a chance he was scum. You did not explain your case about e00 pretty well. All you said was is that he is under suspicion from other people and then a feeling about him. That is not a strong case, that is just plain sheeping. You do not give any explanations about the vote at all. I would not have been mad if you actually made an explanation and had good reasoning and then left the vote on him. He's been more active recently, but I think there's a chance he's a scum who knows he needs to work his ass off to try and turn the suspicion away from him. We'll see how the discussion goes down around deadline, but for the moment What the fuck am I supposed to do about this? If I got called out for not posting enough do you just expect me to not post anything and continue being a dead weight to town like you are currently? You still haven't done anything all game besides besides just sheep on the e00e vote and call out lurkers when you are a lurker yourself. When you do start posting again you call me scum for weak reasoning mainly because I am the most vocal about you. You have made 0 reads on other people and are just trying to hop on my vote after Balla voted for me. I don't know that to tell you about the e00 vote. It's day 1, of course a lot of the votes are going to just come down to suspicions rather than hard facts. Balla even said the vote itself was a good town play despite not liking how I left the thread.. I also don't know how you can claim I'm jumping on voting for you just because Balla started it. I made my post calling you yesterday, I had you pegged as scum then even though I didn't put my official vote in.
Whenever I jumped on any votes early on and didn't give much reasoning I got called out by you ad others for sheeping my opinion? Now you are saying sheeping is OK since you were sheeping? As for calling me out you had weak reasoning, jthe main reason was that I was sheeping and was a lurker which is exactly what you are doing. And now that I am posting you say its just cause I got called out. Real strong argument.
|
odin do you have a different case on me, considering a large portion of your cass was miss guided,,
and odin there is no point asking peoples opinions on nyx. he isn't going to change his vote, and i don't think there are enough people to vote him out. It honestly would be a very sketch vote to suddenly have 2-3 people switching on him.
As far as lurkers, idk how forum lurking is in any way beneficial to town, but in RL or video mafia, i lynch those guys with fire...
and i thought my case on nyx was good
|
Odin, that's not worth talking about right now.
We have two hours to vote according to yesterday's update right?
Either way, guys we need a solid vote. Anything that's not Von, nyx or poofter might be too late. Please concentrate.
|
On November 04 2013 07:52 OdinOfPergo wrote:
Thoughts on my case of Jonny, Storr, Vonthin? Thoughts of Balla's cases, what do you think about the Nyx case? How do you feel about Cake right now? I realize you don't OWB, while I don't really agree with it that's not the only reason I don't like you right now. I want to know more.. You coming in posting a lot of irrelevant stuff and then a crumby case on a lurker instead of trying to kill scum is not a town oriented play style.
I think Jonny is town at this point, he had valid defenses for July and tried to stop the train. I don't think he was stupid enough to kill Van in the night since that put him in the spotlight. I think you(not sure if it was you but someone said it , doesnt really matter who since its a valid question) said wouldn't mafia want to kill people in the right direction? They should but when there were other people like Balla who might have been in the right direction why not kill him? Plus mafia coulda saw that hey Van was going hard on Jonny, if we kill him he will look really bad and might get lyched so thats a free kill for us.
I have a nuetral opinion on Storr, early on he didn't say much but recently I like his cases and questions against people. He also had good answers to the questions I had for him earlier.
Reading up on his Nyx case now. I don't like how he doesn't want to lynch lurkers especially when they have suspicious looking filters.
|
##Vote: onlywonderboy
as a placeholder at minimum
|
did you not even read my post last night? I said the polar opposite of that. Why would mafia not want to kill someone who was about to throw them on the block?
You are directly contradicting yourself with that Storr statement.
You previous said that "Storr's filter look like OWB"
But now he's null?
|
I think Ballas case against me does bring valid points. My filter on Day 1 was really bad, no excuse for that. One of the main reasons I thought Cake could be scum was the possible Jonny connection plus I didn't like his first couple posts but I chalked that up to mistakes from super fast pressure that he wasn't expecting, but after I saw the Jonny connection when Jonny was one of my main targets I thought he could be scum to, but after my Jonny scum reads were cleared I didn't think Cake was that bad looking. Why not pressure easy targets though If I think they could be scum? I also did say I was going to address Poofter when I woke up and I did do just that.
|
On November 04 2013 08:02 OdinOfPergo wrote:
did you not even read my post last night? I said the polar opposite of that. Why would mafia not want to kill someone who was about to throw them on the block?
You are directly contradicting yourself with that Storr statement.
You previous said that "Storr's filter look like OWB"
But now he's null?
At the point I thought he was suspicious his filter did look like OWB, but then he started posting good questions and cases whereas OWB did not. I did not go back and look for the question, was just going by memory and wanted to get a quick response out so I could get to other reads
|
does anyone here not want to lynch anyone?
|
I want to lynch Vonthin or OWB. I think they are different alignments so the lynch will tell us about the other.
|
place your vote then?
i don't understand why you are waiting
|
Right now I am deciding which of them.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
