Hogwarts Mafia - Page 7

On October 29 2013 21:34 Hopeless1der wrote:
I would say BH is fully aware that he shouldnt be posting that stuff. I recall a post of his from WhoseLine a while back where the endgame held this post:

I dont remember the context exactly but that BH would lynch our BH. Not because of the emotional posts, but because he's really scummy looking.

On October 29 2013 22:46 Mocsta wrote:

Im not sure why BH isnt automatic for you? I thought HF has said that you have been mildly suspicious of him all game?

On October 29 2013 23:21 Onegu wrote:
So skanjab scum slipped, when HF asked if KP was factional hosts said closed setup right?

On October 31 2013 12:58 Skanjab1s wrote:
rayn has given me reason to think that he is town, whereas you have not.

On October 30 2013 17:45 Mocsta wrote:
I just finished Onegu filter:

I disagree with Holyflare saying Onegu was unjustified on Mattchew.
The reasoning exists: Storr voted Sn0. Matt votes Storr; then Matt votes Sn0 --> the classic vote your scum reads, scum read.

That aside: I have some peculiarities with Onegu that I can reconcile

Namely

(1) Power
The phrasing suggests the power must be "ACTIVATED"

Now his power is passive (as phrased by him).
I find this highly misleading. Given that he was one of the last to claim, the misleading factor of this is highly suspicious.

---

(2) JAT


becomes



becomes:


This attitude makes no sense. How do you go from JAT is 'OK" to lynch him, and then back to "OK yeah then" ?

The kicker:


This sequence of thought process makes zero sense.

---

(3) Skanjab

into

As stated by Cephiro previously: Onegu does not follow up with this promise to read Skanjab.
I believe Onegu response was:
Basd on the format of the reply its hard to ascertain if this was indeed the retort. Contextually it makes sense.
This is the only reference to Skanjab in that time.
Alarm bells are now ringing

---

Onegu replies with:

I have several problems with this.

Firstly,
"Better but there is another flip that if I saw I would give him a scum read. Talk about it after the resolution period. But unless both thos people flip tonight Im not interested in lynching him now."
We know Yam is town; so in essence he is stating that Skanjab becomes town. How does this even make sense? Theres no reasoning behind this, and in my opinion Yam being town makes Skanjab look scummier as this is his only contribution (other than a case on Sn0

Secondly,
"The other flip was BH as I thought one was scum but not both if BH flipped town then skan was scum. After the house check in griffendor I have revised this theory."
The theory is that one of {BH, Skanjab} is scum... again... we expect BH to flip town.. Skanjab now becomes town.
Further to this; Onegu states explictly in point 6. that he expects BH to be scum.

No matter what occurs in this situation, Skanjab is a town read for Onegu. A false dilemna indeed.

So who is Onegu voting for?

I get the thread is voting for Cephiro and he is following the check on Gryffndor; but the above is simply not congruent with his vote behaviour.

---

---

I believe scum is {Onegu, Skanjab, Blazinghand}