Grackaroni, the elected leader of House Hufflepuff by one vote, carries word from Hufflepuff. We (which totally includes all of Hufflepuff, and not just Grackaroni) have reached the conclusion that Last Argument is not actually a smurf. The smurf hunt is over!

LastArgument

United States152 Posts

October 17 2013 23:50 GMT

#863

In that case, you should be voting me as a liar, sir.

@rayn/koshi - I will wait to see what Cephiro posts tomorrow. One post does not a contribution make, that I can certainly agree with.

@Holyflare, while I admire your sentiment, I'm still not going to lynch someone I've played with several times to uphold your idea of good play. I either have a mafia-read on Palmar or I don't, and right this minute I don't have another option than wait and see.

I agree with your suspicions about Sn0_Man, he looks particularly uninvolved compared to his normal towngames and he doesn't have anything in his filter this game which suggests he might be town. There's actually a whole slew of players with a little contribution but nowhere near enough, I'll see if I can make anything of it tomorrow.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 17 2013 23:54 GMT

#864

On October 18 2013 08:50 LastArgument wrote:
In that case, you should be voting me as a liar, sir.

@rayn/koshi - I will wait to see what Cephiro posts tomorrow. One post does not a contribution make, that I can certainly agree with.

@Holyflare, while I admire your sentiment, I'm still not going to lynch someone I've played with several times to uphold your idea of good play. I either have a mafia-read on Palmar or I don't, and right this minute I don't have another option than wait and see.

I agree with your suspicions about Sn0_Man, he looks particularly uninvolved compared to his normal towngames and he doesn't have anything in his filter this game which suggests he might be town. There's actually a whole slew of players with a little contribution but nowhere near enough, I'll see if I can make anything of it tomorrow.

Why ask only me to vote you for lying? It was obviously a completely unanimous group decision that you were not a smurf, and not just the musings of a lone Grackaroni! Your reading comprehension skills are lacking. Can you come up with a last argument?

raynpelikonoshi

Cayman Islands1087 Posts

October 17 2013 23:56 GMT

#865

There is a growing trend of "this guy might look bad here in thread but he looks good in house QT". I hate that. Same thing happened in GoT where people "cleared" other people by their contributions in house QT's. Easy for scum to call people out even if they look town in QT's, people need to post in thread and look town. ffs.

-rayn

LastArgument

United States152 Posts

October 17 2013 23:57 GMT

#866

But every time it matters, all my words desert me; so anyone can hurt me, and they do. So what happens now?

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 17 2013 23:59 GMT

#867

On October 18 2013 08:57 LastArgument wrote:
But every time it matters, all my words desert me; so anyone can hurt me, and they do. So what happens now?

I don't know.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 18 2013 00:24 GMT

#868

By a vote of 1, Palmar has been booted out of the Hufflepuff House QT. He will still be able to post in thread and vote on item use but he will have no say in important house activities. The vote shall remain anonymous but from here henceforth Palmar shall possess no vote in the Hufflepuff House Elections!

As a reminder, Elections are coming up. Grackaroni has always been a powerful leader of House Hufflepuff and is running for re-election. Grackaroni 2013

My house does not seem to understand the importance of elections so I am allowing non-citizens of Hufflepuff, besides Palmar, to take part in this historic event! Currently I have no opposition.

##Elect: Grackaroni
LET THE BATTLE OF THE CENTURY COMMENCE!

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

October 18 2013 00:47 GMT

#869

Grack if you have a mason ability please mason me so we can solve this game.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 18 2013 00:58 GMT

#870

On October 18 2013 09:47 Pandain wrote:
Grack if you have a mason ability please mason me so we can solve this game.

Ok we shall create the greatest town circle of 2013, even better than Gonzaw's circle in MS Paint! ( though that was a great circle)

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

October 18 2013 01:01 GMT

#871

While I'm all for jokes, can we discuss the actual game? What do you think of the 3 people I listed? Have you anything/anyone to add to that?

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

October 18 2013 01:06 GMT

#872

I liked all your posts except Sn0man played very much like this in one of the previous games I played with him so I don't think day one will be the best day to pin him.

Agree with Stutters and Palmar.

raynpelikonoshi

Cayman Islands1087 Posts

October 18 2013 01:09 GMT

#873

Stutters is capable of making good posts as town. We should lynch him if he does not contribute.
Palmar's "apathy" seems like town!Palmar. I can't really explain that better at this point.
I have no idea of Sno, i always want to lynch him. Need to see more from him.

-rayn

raynpelikonoshi

Cayman Islands1087 Posts

October 18 2013 01:10 GMT

#874

So HF (or anyone else) what do you make of Cephiro making one post here and 7 posts in our house QT explaining why he has not posted or why he posted what he did or what he is about to post next?

-rayn

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

October 18 2013 01:15 GMT

#875

On October 18 2013 10:09 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Stutters is capable of making good posts as town. We should lynch him if he does not contribute.
Palmar's "apathy" seems like town!Palmar. I can't really explain that better at this point.
I have no idea of Sno, i always want to lynch him. Need to see more from him.

-rayn

My basic problem with this is that even though there is a possibility that he just doesn't give a shit about the thread right now,

He's not acting like it, he's keeping up with the thread and waiting to see if Mocsta responds.
Along with keeping up with the thread in that regards, he has to also read it, or it's some really really weird counter-productive isolationist approach to mafia that deliberately keeps him ignorant
It's ultimately not justifiable from a town perspective in a good way, only the I don't give a shit way.

Hope that explains my view on that.

Also agree on Mattchew of course.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

October 18 2013 01:15 GMT

#876

On October 18 2013 10:10 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
So HF (or anyone else) what do you make of Cephiro making one post here and 7 posts in our house QT explaining why he has not posted or why he posted what he did or what he is about to post next?

-rayn

He basically summarized what he wrote in the QT and then added actual analysis which I liked.

It doesn't prove him town in itself but it's definitely significant and means we shouldn't lynch him.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 18 2013 01:17 GMT

#877

This is how I view your scum reads Stutters/Palmar/Sn0 Man:
Lurker 1, Lurker 2 and Lurker 3

Sn0 Man I have no clue.

Stutters I don't like because he has 2 posts, 1 defending Palmar for genuine frustration. (What frustration??) and another saying that he's not scum because his play would look more like his town meta (it normally doesn't) but I don't know if that makes him scum.

Palmar I like lynching because he enjoys scumhunting, not being scum and he doesn't care about this game. I would think if this was his first town game in a while he would have more enthusiasm to play.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 18 2013 01:25 GMT

#878

That is also a pretty nice Palmar contradiction from Pandain.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

October 18 2013 01:40 GMT

#879

I can't believe this is only day one good work team

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

October 18 2013 01:46 GMT

#880

Huh Cephiro looked like a good lynch too oh well.

Anybody who thinks storrzerg's arguments have merit aren't reading I dont think. Mostly because storrzerg doesn't have arguments. Its literally "I think sno's scum who is with me? *biblethump*" recently spiced up with "well he's now afk certain scum" or something.

Wish I had good thoughts on who is actually scum instead of dumb. I could lynch palmar maybe. I'll be around for a bit maybe tonight and the 6 hours preceeding the lynch.