On August 15 2013 12:55 Mocsta wrote: ? No acro. What a weird question.
Do u object to what I posted in the thread?
I have no clue what you have posted in the thread since you woke up. I just wanted to gauge your response. You seem timid.
Well. It's a dumb question Anyone would answer no
But u showed signs of intelligence with the rayn case so it was unexpected to be asked something so useless from u.
Now. Yes we are same timezone. Let us use this to our best advantage.
??johnny?? said sharrant had an awesome case on koshi. Have u sighted this?
We aremost certainly not in the same timezone. I am in
and you are in
Regarding Sharrant and Koshi, I could have sworn there was more discussion, but I cannot find it right now. When (if) I sober up I'll give it another try. But atm all I can find is a question from Sharrant asking whether the final post on page 111 has a scumslip. I swear I replied saying I didn't see it, and Sharrant replied to that, bit I can't find either of those PMs.
But I may be delusional. I'd ask Sharrant. He doesn't bite.
Anyway, I don't think asking you whether you're scum is a weird question at all. Of course everybody says no, but it's the WAY they say no that's interesting. You seemed rather cautious, especially for someone with as much bluster as you.
You're in House Martell, so you're safe for now, imho. What's with the caution? As for your culling of the houses, it's pretty fucking stupid. I say we shoot into houses we've culled town to few scum. Greyjoy for instance, one of Risen and Rayn is bound to be scum. So lets kill Rayn. Woooohooo. Get on the Train of Statistical Justice (not the catchiest name in the world, but can't go wrong with math!)
On August 15 2013 11:06 Risen wrote: And Chrom your version falls apart when you realize Sharrant gave Acro the option of Yamato and kush. He wasn't hoping for anything. Nice try?
No. He said "dude, I'm a cop. Who should I check?" (paraphrasing, duh)
Shit. I was going to ignore you. Failed already
Wait until you get farther in man... it gets dark for me...
On August 15 2013 04:02 Vivax wrote: I need to know if Onegu's claim was real, is he really One-shot-medic? This is important cause we need to think about the chance that there is a 1-shot cop in this game compared to normal cop. If there really was 1-sh-med and medic too then that makes Sharrant's claim more credible.
Usually when there are 1-shot-roles then there are multiple or none in a game of this size, 1-shot and standard seems unlikely.
Also, did anyone else notice Chrom, s0lstice and Grackdisappearing?
I'll always be here for you babe. Onegu fake claimed
On August 13 2013 00:02 kushm4sta wrote: neither. i honestly believe this. for this game and future games we need to start plynching fake claimers so they stop doing it
So should I be lynched also, why not actually scum hunt and try to win, once people figure out fakeclaiming is bad they will stop dont need to policy lynch them.
Still want an explanation for this. You are saying fake claiming is bad but you didn't dissuade Oberyn from fakeclaiming and in fact went out of your way to fake claim yourself. Why?
Just pointing out policy lynching is dumb and if fake claiming is really bad people will stop eventually. I believe there is a time and a place for fake claims, some are stupid and some arent, wanting to policy lynch formthem is stupid.
Acro, how are you so confident in your rayn scumread? I can see reason to slightly doubt him, but I don't see why he's 100% scum or especially a good lynch. Seriously, we are NOT lynching rayn. That is simply not an option. You should also read his long argument with me. Would scum be that persistent about their own innocence? I mean, with genuinely explaining?
Where did snb disappear to? He hasn't yet done anything basically. No reads (outside of Risen&Vivax, but nothing new there). Not even a list. Nothing. Why? Scum perhaps?
Same with Vivax... Long disappearance at a weird timing. Just as pressure was starting to drop. Why?
Kush is dying tonight 100%. Senseless to let him live with this apathy and senseless to waste a lynch on him with his low HP. The secondary choice is open to discussion. Lords, we should maybe discuss this in PMs. PM me (and others) suggestions. And as a sidenote, I'd prefer the first timeslot. During the last 2 I'm probably sleeping. Others are fine though.
On August 15 2013 14:57 raynpelikoneet wrote: Okay, kill Mocsta. He isshiting up.
As a sidenote. You wanted to smack me in the face? Keep in mind that I've practiced karate for some time now You'd be in for a surprise.
Where is Mocsta? Don't leave us hanging please. You have so much to prove and so much to lose by not doing that.
I'm busy and at work.
What I have to say is in my filter
If u don't like it. Feel free to ask something that leads to a productive outcome.
What's your stance on rayn at the moment? Risen said that he opposed rayn being Lord and rayn wanted to see what Risen would do as Lord. Why not allow him?
On August 15 2013 14:57 raynpelikoneet wrote: Okay, kill Mocsta. He isshiting up.
As a sidenote. You wanted to smack me in the face? Keep in mind that I've practiced karate for some time now You'd be in for a surprise.
Where is Mocsta? Don't leave us hanging please. You have so much to prove and so much to lose by not doing that.
I'm busy and at work.
What I have to say is in my filter
If u don't like it. Feel free to ask something that leads to a productive outcome.
What's your stance on rayn at the moment? Risen said that he opposed rayn being Lord and rayn wanted to see what Risen would do as Lord. Why not allow him?
Scumreads besides rayn?
I don't understand how u can ask me this. If u have read my filter.
My position on rayn is clear. As for the lord stuff. That's all weak tells and looking for cheap ways to categorize someone as town or scum Ultimately the house is two ppl and it is advantageous for a scum rayn to not be lord. As it is advantageous for a scum anyone to not be lord
On August 15 2013 05:04 Koshi wrote: SnB. Same question that I asked you a million times in Sicilian. Who else than you? You always just defend yourself and don't do anything else. In Sicilian you were blaming Vivax his tunnel on you. This time you are going to use the fact that you and Yamato can't be on the same scumteam... You flipped scum in Sicilian and all my townreads are on your ass atm. If I would have a vote I would vote you in an instant.
Ok so how is the post not uber scummy and no one calls him out on it. He gives no reads, adds nothing new to the arguement, but happy with the lynch because his townreads are voteing SnB? I am going to look at his NWM filter now as he was scum that game, but for now Imstick with my stance that he is scum.
I have a better feeling on acro now he has dropped the roleplaying, he seem much more town now.
I also like chromes post on the sharrant claim amd I agree with his point as that is the most likely option.
I am null on rayne for now, I think there are better lynch options than him for now, since he hasnt been lord I feel his play has suffered though.
Looking through vivax now, I remember I thought he was town day 1.
I would like people to make a case on me that isnt raynes case, I am getting alot of I am scum messages in PMs but not alot of reasons why.
Out of tue lords I have spoken with I am getting heavy town feelings from clarity, xata, chrome ans s0L.
I was baseing alot of my mocsta read off of my jrkirby read and the fact he has been open in PMs. That being said he needs to be more active in thread, I guess I need to also.
Ok. Skimmed all filters and was left with a couple that stuck out to me
Snb Grackeroni Koshi Vivax
Rayn I'm back to 50/50. I think my issue with him is we are treating the same tells 100% opposite. But he's standing up for his belief, as am I. That's indicative of town. So will give him a beeather.
Vivax is scum for sure. His filter is just too "polite" and just prods people but never takes hard stances. Vivax didn't become a respected town player with this type of filter. I fully endorse a vivax lynch this cycle.
Koshi still sticks out to me. The really poor logic throughout the game. Not wanting to run for lord and then changing mind when an opportunity came through. He has also shown an inflexible mindset. I'm happy with his lynch too.
Grackeroni. I can't pinpoint it off my first skim but.. he's blending it. He shows enough understanding of the thread so is keeping up. But I don't like the moments he chooses to come into the thread. He's not really driving anything so the contributions I feel are fake. Plus u have the whole gumshoe 1hp leak thing. He made a defense of it which was handled well I admit. But too slick compared to his other posts. Smells very funny to me.
Snb.. shoulda realised this earlier. But a town snb always pushes oats as a lynch. Didn't get that this game.. I need to do another read on him too but I don't think yamato pushed him that hard. U could argue he pushed snb as hard as he pushed acro.
In short. My preferred lynch this cycle is vivax. I can live with snb though.
Well with joshi maybe I have a hardon for him cos I lost to him as sk I can say with confidence he's not matching that meta.but I didn't accuse him of being 3p either.
For me. The sole point of koshi that is townie is that he has the balls to shit up the thread... But really all his justifications are so bad Like he refers to past games but then doesn't bridge why it's relevant to this game
Personally I think he's scum cos he plays the way I would as scum i.e inflate small things and make a hoohaa
Day one he was alot more active than anyother day, he pressures johnnywup. Says Oats is town. And posts thoughtful posts that seem like he is scumhunting and pushing people that need pushing.
EPT
You'd be in for a surprise.
