Newbie Mini Mafia XLIV - Page 82

On July 17 2013 05:42 Hurricane Sponge wrote:
Full disclosure, if I had zero meta on Gotard, this lynch would be a no-brainer. But he let this happen to him in NMMXLII as a useless townie, too. That doesn't exonerate him, but it does tell us that sometimes bad play is just bad play.

On July 17 2013 05:47 hzflank wrote:


Do you want him at a LYLO though? Regardless of his alignment I doubt that he will be night-killed (assume that we have no Vig for now). How much time can we give him to become active? He has had time.

Look at the players who are left in the game. Just by numbers there has to be a 50% chance of Gotard flipping scum. Combine that with the fact that he is too dangerous at the LYLO unless we can somehow get a good town read on him and have some idea of how he will vote.

On July 14 2013 19:12 Gotard wrote:


I would say him being scum is more likely even now than it was before because he can't really defend himself. Yes, he had some pro town post giving his reads in semi-aggressive way but then he writes something like that:



My problem is that after seeing stuff like that i usually tend to think: "Isn't it to easy to be true" and I would put mistakes like that into inexperience basket but he admitted himself that he played mafia on some other forums...

His way of getting out of trouble doesn't seem pro town whatsoever so i have to say hi's scum if he won't change anything in his posting.

Overall I still think jrkirby is a little bit more scummy.

On July 13 2013 23:56 Superfluous wrote:
To be fair to Umasi, he has stopped tunneling on me in terms of asking me stuff since I gave my 3rd or 4th post explaining my reads/ logic. I'd still like to here some more from Hzflank, cloud 9, night cat and other lurkers I've forgotten. Koshi and Gotard have euro time zones so it makes sense that they weren't active early on, and right now they are trying to contribute something so they're town reads for me.

On July 17 2013 05:53 Hurricane Sponge wrote:
Has anyone supported Gotard as town at all in the thread? You'd think scumbuddies would have said something if he actually were mafia.

On July 15 2013 08:58 jrkirby wrote:
Ok, Gotard is an excellent lynch target tomorrow. I think chrom should only be lynched after a scum is found, but maybe checked by cop.

I have less of a feeling about koshi, umasi, super.

Xzavier is decent, but not the best lynch.

Chrom and super should be lynched together should one of them be scum by flip or cop check.

That's the best I got, GG guys.

On July 17 2013 06:03 Hurricane Sponge wrote:


Remember the dead

On July 17 2013 06:04 Chromatically wrote:

What about it?

On July 15 2013 09:18 Koshi wrote:

Chrom is becoming the target and not Super.
I hope I have time to make a good case in the next 24hours. Because the defense of Chrom was UNHOLY.
Even if Super flips town, the reasoning of Chrom was getting out of control.

At this point I feel
If super is scum than 100% Chrom is scum.
If super is town, 50% Chrom is scum.
Reasoning --> That defense, he must have known Super was town, because that defense made 0 sense.

I am not talking about kirby here. I am talking 100% Chrom putting his neck out for a guy that was not better than kirby.

On July 16 2013 05:23 Rainbows wrote:
We're lynching Gotard tomorrow btw guise.

Chrom, your case on me is bad. It boils down to me lynching the guy you wanted, and not really caring. Nobody wanted to lynch Gotard so I lynched the other dude. I can't really oppose the lynch when all I can do is watch and write little snippets from my phone at work.