PTP IV - Demon's Run - Page 42

On June 24 2013 04:49 s0Lstice wrote:
what do you think of Austin, xatalos

On June 24 2013 05:06 Zephirdd wrote:
ok so BC didn't actually claim to be RB'd, just that his shot was refunded. Didn't see that.

Ah goddamnit.
+ Show Spoiler [Macro meme] +

I still hold my belief that BC is town and that was my main reasoning to call Sk8r mafia.

I don't know who to vote for at this point. I'd love to see others who disappeared(acrofales where are you)

Dandel, what was the reasoning to lynch s0lstice again? He made a post that I liked concerning austin, altho it could be just pressuring an afk player, or austin could be just fine with whatever is going on.

On June 24 2013 05:06 Xatalos wrote:


I haven't put too much attention on him, but he's a heavy lurker without any actual impact on the game so far. That's very suspicious compared to my memory of him being a very clear town (as town) when we last played together a long time ago. Now he's everything but clear town. Certainly most suspicious of the lurkers in this game, and would lynch him rather than most other players, but not rather than you or WOS. Not exactly sure where I'd put Kurumi atm.

(Btw you should refrain from dodging a question for once now that I answered you clearly, don't you think.)

On June 24 2013 05:08 Zephirdd wrote:


I did it to find out who made my role. I purposefully posted it wrongly at first.
I prefer to not disclose who I plan to activate my ability on

On June 24 2013 05:06 Zephirdd wrote:
ok so BC didn't actually claim to be RB'd, just that his shot was refunded. Didn't see that.

Ah goddamnit.
+ Show Spoiler [Macro meme] +

I still hold my belief that BC is town and that was my main reasoning to call Sk8r mafia.

I don't know who to vote for at this point. I'd love to see others who disappeared(acrofales where are you)

Dandel, what was the reasoning to lynch s0lstice again? He made a post that I liked concerning austin, altho it could be just pressuring an afk player, or austin could be just fine with whatever is going on.

On June 24 2013 01:35 Xatalos wrote:
s0Lstice...

1) Why haven't you basically mentioned me at all (except dodging the question once when asked directly) after initially throwing dirt on me?

2) Why haven't you responded to my reply to your soft accusation?

3) Why have you pretty much ignored/dodged Gonzaw´s case on you (except downplaying it once in a vague manner) and then conveniently forgotten it?

4) Why did you suddenly bandwagon Zephirdd, an "easy" lurker lynch, despite not even mentioning him before this?

All this makes me feel like you don't even care who gets lynched. Just throw some dirt around, then forget it, then avoid attention, and then jump on an easy bandwagon when the opportunity arises. Frankly, your filter reeks red.

On June 24 2013 05:10 Zephirdd wrote:


I do think the activated part of the role has its best use on night 1 when there are more people around. That's why.

On June 23 2013 09:57 gonzaw wrote:
Welp, now I want to kill Zepphird for that post of his.

Goddamit, I'll just finish reading and make sense of it later.

Regarding stuff that makes Zepphirds post scummy:
(reference: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=415738&currentpage=25#487 )

It's entirely possible (maybe likely) that BC is town.
I get the feeling that if that's so, then some if not most of scum will just come out and flat out say "BC is town" in their posts.
Why? Goes with the flow (general consensus is both confusion about BC's alignment/actions but thinking he's stupid town as well), fake contributions, etc.

Zepphird made that kind of post, and I think kita and others made that kind of post as well

That kind of post bothers me.

I'm not too interested in lynching geript based on that. It'd be way easier for scum geript to do the same thing and sweep any pressure off him (as he's having now)



You just made a "case" against 2 dudes and then conveniently ignored it until I asked you about them (you were supposed to...you know...either vote them, ask people for opinions, etc)

Anyways, I finished reading so I'll just post my thoughts about you now, and reread and shit later:

---

Here's the thing solstice.
You started "fine" I'd say. You started joking, jumped to the lovetap thing. Normal early-game-derp. Not super townie, but well you weren't scummy or anything.
You made sense with some comments you made, and I had similar thoughts about you Acro had (that you were making comments that seemingly reflected that of his own, etc)
But then came this post: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=415738&currentpage=18#349



This striked me as a "antagonist scum" kind of post.
It's not the aggressiveness itself, but also the contrast.

Like, it's odd to me you'd go from this:






...to stuff like "cool I can kill Kurumi and be cool with it" or stuff like that.

There's also the fact that your sk8/BC comments seem like filler

Also your Xatalos thing makes very very little sense:


I can't understand how Xata's question can make you suspicious of him like you make it out to be.
How about this for a response:
1)Xata was DIRECTLY asking sk8 if his lovetap is a joke or serious
2)Xata wanted other people to chime in on that thing to make more sense of it

Your "case" doesn't convince me at all, and it doesn't convince me YOU are convinced he's scum (or you are suspicious of him) either.

After that you make "usual" posts, but sparse in between.
Different than WOS's interaction with people and activity in discussions, I just see you make ocassional posts arguing with WOS, or making some comments about some stuff other people said, etc.

And you ignore your own FoS on Xata and S&B, in the sense that it seems you don't care about it.
You ask nobody what they think of Xata/S&B. You make no effort whatsoever to either:
-Get them lynched
-Convince people they are scum/suspicious
-Get more thoughts about them to get better reads on people or drive discussion forward
-Get thoughts about them to convince yourself if they are scum or you are looking at the wrong direction

Instead of doing stuff like that, I see you have a pointless discussion about BC's meta, and you just appear to be in the "sidelines" of the BC discussion, appearing that you are contributing about it, but I just don't get the feeling you actually are.

That's what makes me suspicious of you.

....meh, I'll let you guys post your thoughts and shit, I'll take a closer look at Zepphird, and maybe reread Xata (I thought he was fairly town before he arrived here, another reason I didn't really understand solstice's FoS on him....nor WOS's either to be honest).

Again, tell me if I'm wrong with my approach to the Xata stuff. I thought he seemed fairly townie, for his initial "get ball rolling" case on WOS (I certainly got that feeling from it at least), his continued activity, his behaviour, etc.

On June 24 2013 05:10 WaveofShadow wrote:
You're all dumb, I knew sk8 was town since yesterday.