EPTSmurf Mini Mafia
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Let's play a game... | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
until he makes himself seem more town: ##vote smccoy | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
strong response by smccoy | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
fuck i wish i watched that show it would make it so much easier... Um yeah I'm usually pretty useless d1 sorries. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On May 30 2013 03:11 TheDavison wrote: I'd like to bring attention to H3's posting, in reading and rereading the thread I found him less than useless. He has a fair number of posts and has been involved in discussion without adding anything to said discussion. He blatantly sheeped an early case without adding anything to it and unvoted as soon as the casee responded. Since that moment he has been complaining about the difficulty of reading an all smurf game, which is the reason I've read the thread more than once, and hasn't added anything to the progression of day one discussion. For now I find H3 the scummiest player in the thread and shall, therefore, vote for him. I ask each of you to either vote with me and tell me why yo agree with me or, if you are not voting with me, tell me why you disagree. Vote:Hurndall ok ##vote thedavison pretty self explanatory imo. This is his first post! | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
it is commonly seen as a scum trait. that is why we were suspicious of you. : | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
@ms1 how Thedavidson jumped on me looked scummy. Obviously you try hards were yapping it up about nothing then he comes in with this case on the current "low hanging fruit" as his FIRST post. The case he made on me is newb like, but more importantly it is easy for scum to make. so it looked inauthentic. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
"uscumbro?" is null possibly leaning town. I know you don't like it because of how it effectively accomplishes nothing, but town does it all the time. 2 people are searching for something to talk about early game. This is true of both town and scum. DrTennant is not a scumread and I think there are already a bunch of better lynch candidates out there: Eccleston PTroughton2 JPertwee Actually rereading all those filters I am gonna unvote TheDavison. His response to my OMGUS looks marginally genuine: On May 30 2013 03:21 TheDavison wrote: + Show Spoiler + That is indeed my first post, I have been absent from the thread until now. Upon reading the thread I found you scummy. Instead of doing anything to refute that you have instead reinforced my belief that you are an alien monster who must be purged by our security forces. ##unvote JPertwee might be a too scummy to be scum scenario. He is overly agreeable, wishy washy, and constantly asking people to expand on things they've said rather than contribute his own original thought. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On May 30 2013 22:39 TheDavison wrote: I shouldn't need to push it. If GM made sure that only reasonably good players got into this game making the original case and allowing other to draw their own conclusions should mean that I don't have to create the giant push onto H3 when instead I can simply show all of you why he is scum and you can decide whether to believe me or not. This is a game where none of us, even you, can make people listen to them based on their names so each of us should be evaluating individual cases on a merit basis and I should not have to be in thread actively pushing for it to be considered. Because I could be anyone from Grush to Syllo I expect you to look into my cases as if they come form someone worth listening to. If it wasn't my case that convinced you that H3 was scum what was it? 1 why are you assuming that gm was selective? I think he took every player that pmed him an /in. 2 are you convinced that I am scum? because I made a bunch of useless posts in the beginning? That case is terrible. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
##vote ptroughton | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
"some people play mafia like assholes" from where im sitting you are the one playing like an asshole. all about perspective. @tom lol u such a hardass i hope you aren't vig @person who asked about me to expand on a point about some guy who's not getting lynched "too scummy to be scum" I said. He is displaying certain scum traits with such a high frequency that I think he might not be scum. Scum try to hide their scumminess. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
it kind of looks like he was trying to rp and got bored. ##unvote I haven't made my mind up on an alternative yet. @Baker it seems pretty weird that you are so UBER active yet you don't have a scumread you are pushing?? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
because i join and leave bandwagons easily? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
##vote DrT k I think I can sheep this DrT shit now that I read the case thoroughly. these are the points that convinced me to sheep. 1 DrT's overdefense 2 unnatural calmness 3 repeated appeal that scum is among the inactives 4 one dimensional scumreads | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On May 31 2013 19:25 Eccleston wrote: Can you explain to me why you think that these points are exclusive to a scum mindset? For example, point three could be explained from a town perspective too; if DrT is a townie being tunneled, trying to shift the attention toward the lurkers is a perfectly valid thing to do if he thinks that the mafia are lurking. Before, you dismissed his "overdefense", as brought up by MSmith1 here (it's point two in his post), saying that "2 people are searching for something to talk about early game. This is true of both town and scum." What made you change your mind? You can explain all this stuff from a town mindset if you try really hard (see tom's posts). You can more easily explain it from a scum mindset though. If you want to make a better case on someone else I am all ears, but as of now the only alternative is a policy lynch on PT rper. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
I think tom is really town. He has written so much and gone really in depth about his thought process. Scum is between pt, pf, ec, td. Don't shoot pt (thats the rper right?) cause he prob gonna get modkilled. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 02 2013 05:10 SMcCoy wrote: Who's pf? What do you think about JP and Hartnell? Yesterday you gave JP a 53 % chance of him being scum, it should now be around 99 %. by pf i meant JP LOL. Add hartnell to the list of possible scum also. I forgot about him. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 02 2013 21:16 A McGann wrote: The idea of both remaining scum being on Dr.Tennant (and therefore everyone not on that lynch is town) is outlandish enough that I'm willing to discount it. dumb | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
jp is looking town from that last post. going with the alternate wagon. Besides I thought td looked scummy from his first post. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
his recent post looks hella town. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
##unvote ##vote JP NOT THAT IT MATTERS | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
YUP I knew that post looked uber townie I was right and now you want to punish me for my correctness by believing im scum... The truth is I have been busy the past few days.. overtime and such. So it's like I was pretty shit tier town before that and with 0 time on my hands I am demoted to borderline should be modkilled tier. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 04 2013 11:18 TheDavison wrote: McCoy. I agree Get rid of h3 bro that's not even what he said... | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 04 2013 11:32 HartnellWill wrote: I got home minutes before the lynch and took me about 20 minutes to catch up on the thread. I was working all day for several days in a row now. But I'm not going to blame that. Truthfully I didn't think I needed to try that hard because town was just owning it up I really didn't have anything to add with my limited time. Also everyone thought I was town so yeah.. my job was done kind of. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
if you think that, I think you need to l2dictionary | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 04 2013 21:01 SMcCoy wrote: Yeah. Why did you write this at the time I was going for the DrT lynch: At that time I thought that you were town and also DrT was town. (I didn't really get the cases against him at the time. It wasn't until someone wrote this excellent summary case that I read it really thoroughly and changed my mind). So I was explaining why I initially thought smcc was scummy, and I was also explaining why i thought a town DrT also found smcc scummy. On June 04 2013 21:23 A McGann wrote: Who do you want to lynch tomorrow and at least give a paragraph outlining why. This is gonna take some time that I don't have right now. I have to read the filters of TD, Ecc, HW, pf?(I may be forgetting someone else I found scummy) first. I will do this for d3 though. Oh and TD saying "this game is still solvable"..that phrase strikes me as pretty scummy because obviously it's still solvable, in fact I think we are winning. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
while I was writing this message I could have been reading filters lol. prob should have been doing that instead. but doing this is easier because it doesn't require thought. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
HW SAID (too hard to quote shit properly) I'm not the scummiest looking if the fucking medic gets lynched before I do. You don't even need context. Contained in that single sentence is an attitude that is impossible to fake as scum. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
but that credit does decay over time without upkeep PT what is your point? just to call me bad townie or are you accusing me of being scum or what? because alignment doesn't decay. it remains contant. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 05 2013 08:58 PTroughton2 wrote: You might get further with your point if you read posts that divert from the norm rather than accusing the norm of being scummy. But look at his sig! The illusion is always one of normality. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
I guess he hasn't been reading hws recent posts. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
He wants to kill hw and me because we are bad lol. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 06 2013 03:48 SMcCoy wrote: We were rallying people for a voteswitch. You and H3 only posted shortly after his death, which suggests you were there pre-deadline. That suggests you were scared to show your presence when it mattered, or that you don't give a shit about the game, either of which is bad and justifies your lynch. I can only speak for myself when i say this is simply untrue. I was busy that day. I probably was posting on my phone. I had no idea that the lynch had already happened when I posted. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
until i put some time into filter reading | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 07 2013 00:42 TheDavison wrote: H3 The candidates for this lynch are: TomB4, Eccleston and Hurndall3. You need to step up; because that vote on PT earlier was a load of bullocks. Are you going to vote Tom or not. I dont like any of those lynches though! Haven't looked into Tom real close but his activity looks pretty town just from glancing at it. Why not PT ;_; | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 07 2013 02:45 SMcCoy wrote: H3 was among the last to jump onto the wagon with a reasoning he used previously to defend DrT. THAT's scummy, and that's the reason H3 has to die today. This is not really true. At first I said his overdefense could just be him wanting to talk about something. Later when i voted for DrT i said actually it does look like a scummy overdefense. The change in my mind was a result of more thoroughly the overdefesnse and the post it was responding to. I don't think that is that scummy. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
I did not know that time had expired. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
for now ##vote PT | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
there is a very scummy connection between the two. Neither ever tries to figure out if the other is scum. They both push Ecc, TD mislynches. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On May 31 2013 05:00 HartnellWill wrote: ##Vote DrTennant. Other than skimming the thread, Tennant's filter is surprisingly empty of anything that would contribute to town. Mostly asking others to do work for him while he sits and waits and gets his postcount up. And while I'm reading PT2's case right now, it wouldn't be a surprise to see both of them role scum. DrT votes him without saying another word. Sheeping the wagon that isn't him because it isn't him that will get killed if it goes through. At this point his vote on DrT doesn't matter. His reasoning for voting him is not true of DrT's play. the fact that he feels he needs to provide some unique reasoning is scummy. He points out the scummy connection between DrT and PT. They both might be scum, he says. This is a move to distance himself from PT and DrT by telling the truth about his own scumteam. And he doesn't follow up at all. he never again writes about the possibility of PT being scum. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
##vote ecc | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
##vote tom ill listen to you since you have been paying for attention than me | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 07 2013 11:27 HartnellWill wrote: Now can we pls pls pls pls pls lynch eccleston day 4? no! | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
I plan on doing some massive phone posting today. I like this phase of the game better than early game because the game is easier to solve. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 07 2013 23:57 SMcCoy wrote: Yesterday you had to tick in your definite vote cause you had to go after 10 minutes and wouldn't be around at deadline and today you say you can phonepost? yup completely different circumstances. today I am working at a group home that is not very busy. last night I went out to see a movie. hangover 3 which sucked ass ofc. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
one read down, 6more to go. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
his early game record looks really scummy (shown by msmiths analysis.). In fact it looks so bad that scum would probably be more careful about how they were treating DrT, since all the powertowns were on drts wagon and it was pretty obvious he was going to be lynched. this is a tooscummytobescum argument but that doesn't mean its wrong. secondly there is this quote: On June 06 2013 15:12 Eccleston wrote: and then you also start thinking 'well we can afford to mislynch once... maybe its better town lynches me now instead of at lylo" and thats the kind of thought spiral you get into and it makes you not want to read the thread... because you feel demotivated. I really can't imagine writing this as scum. And I don't mean the thought is particularly pro town. It's just that scum doesn't have thoughts like this. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
I know I have unfulfilled promises but I am finally getting into this game so believe me I will start doong shit | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
look at my most recent post on ecc There are things he says that look VERY town, even if his play isn't very pro-town. MSmith's vote analysis makes Ecc look very bad, but there's one problem with MSmith's argument: It assumes that PT is town. If PT is scum along with DrT, then suddenly his entire analysis is irrelevant. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Also realize this: a town Ecc was demotivated as fuck and very disconnected from the game. So disconnected that he didn't realize Smcc is obv town like we do. I think it was simply a case of activity without intellect behind it. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
And vice versa. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 08 2013 10:42 HartnellWill wrote: He didn't set off my scumdar yet. Night ends in 18 minutes right? yes he did On May 31 2013 05:00 HartnellWill wrote: ##Vote DrTennant. Other than skimming the thread, Tennant's filter is surprisingly empty of anything that would contribute to town. Mostly asking others to do work for him while he sits and waits and gets his postcount up. And while I'm reading PT2's case right now, it wouldn't be a surprise to see both of them role scum. DrT votes him without saying another word. Sheeping the wagon that isn't him because it isn't him that will get killed if it goes through. Also the reason you say DrT is scummy is not the reason he was scummy at all. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Ecc IS TOWN. Do you think it's a coincidence that PT and HW (both scummy fucks) are now pushing him uber hard in tandem? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 08 2013 11:21 HartnellWill wrote: Is there a coincidence that you're a scummy fuck and you're defending him? Unlike you, I have reasons for my townreads. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 08 2013 11:16 TheDavison wrote: H3, if Eccelston is town. Try and explain to me why a townie would push SMcCoy out of all people? Even when SMcCoy had a fit and said he just wants you/HW "OUT". You two didnt try to lead a lynch. Where is town motivation for this? And do you think my scum motivation is over the top (i.e. saw an opportunity to stab the town leader in the back in a vulnerable moment?) ECC's townstory is consistent and believable. He did not read the game carefully enough to comprehend SmCC's towncred. Can't you see how someone saying "bad town is pissing me off I want them to die" can be construed as scummy? Because it looks like he wants to lynch people for being bad instead of being scum. Here is a question: Why would scum push SMcCoy at that time? Really there is no reason. there were plenty of other scummy townies (myself included) that would be better choices. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
the only quote you point to that is "scummy" is just early game aggression...that is completely alignment indicative, leaning town actuallly. Your "pearler" is that DrT was protecting Ecc with that attack on smmc. Again I disagree. There is no way scum would feel the need to defend their scumteam against such an inconsequential attack. DrT identified town wishy washiness, and thought he could pass it off as a scumtrait and look like he was scumhunting. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
The logic is not conclusive. Let's look at exhibit B: On June 09 2013 00:44 TheDavison wrote: Exhibit B (Talking to Eccleston) + Show Spoiler + On May 30 2013 22:13 DrTennant wrote: ive made reads you must not be reading my posts. He is much more reserved here when addressing Eccleston, compared to Baker in Exhibit A. I would characterize his response as quite aggressive actually. it doesn't look like how scum would talk to each other. @td you are suffering from confirmation bias pure and simple. You are looking at all these little things that don't cohere into a bigger picture. You are seeing signs where there aren't any. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On May 31 2013 05:00 HartnellWill wrote: ##Vote DrTennant. Other than skimming the thread, Tennant's filter is surprisingly empty of anything that would contribute to town. Mostly asking others to do work for him while he sits and waits and gets his postcount up. And while I'm reading PT2's case right now, it wouldn't be a surprise to see both of them role scum. DrT votes him without saying another word. Sheeping the wagon that isn't him because it isn't him that will get killed if it goes through. @smcc You brought up this post as an answer to why PT and HW can't be a scumteam. I think this is actually evidence that they are a scumteam though. The thing he says about PT and DrT being a scumteam is actually very insightful. In fact it's the most insightful thing in his entire filter. DrT gave up because the alternative lynch was also scum, so there was no point in fighting. HW is in a position where BOTH of his scumbuddies are the two lynch targets d1. Bussing is an absolute necessity at this point. Also HW never acts on his realization that they are both scum. He never mentions PT as scum again. When I ask him why is PT town, he gives the absolute scummiest answer possible: On June 08 2013 10:42 HartnellWill wrote: He didn't set off my scumdar yet. Night ends in 18 minutes right? Town would say "he has a lot of activity" or "he has said townie sounding things" but instead we get this complete nonanswer. Then he changes the subject like it's no big deal. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
1 Why am I defending Ecc so hard.. well because you are going at him so hard. I am quite sure you are town and I want you on my side. Also Ecc seems like a newer player and he isn't trying or maybe isn't capable of defending himself. Also my townread on ECC is extremely strong. 2 Early game aggression is leaning town MAYBE for some people but I would be more comfortable saying it's alignment neutral. It's somewhat harder for scum because they have to find something that they can misconstrue as scummy. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
This is another one in response to TD. i mean Ecc read the Ver guide on how to play town for fuck sakes. I'm really sorry if im being disrespectful to you. it's just that I feel very strongly about the wrongness of your arguments. I have been refuting point by point. I have been saying WHY I think they are not conclusive. Please, I welcome you to present your most damming arguments, and I will say why I disagree one by one. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Nothing happens until you reach 2v5, d4, and then the entire thread becomes a scum trap. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
If he's town I will be completely shocked and heartbroken. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
@smmc you have pt as a town read? gross ew. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 10 2013 10:41 Eccleston wrote: there is still time to switch the davison... plz admit... u know, this is what scum town leader looks like... ill vote hw if needed but... the truth is out there just to see GUIZ EVERYONE LAST MINUTE SWITCH TO SMCCOY. ECC's rock solid case just convinced me. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 10 2013 10:45 Baker1986 wrote: This doesn't quite feel right, but honestly whatever. There's a bunch of people in this game I can't read at all. so yeah... well my first thought is baker looks bad for this | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 11 2013 09:54 Eccleston wrote: you have to promise me if i die, you at least look at mccoy with unbiased eyes... you cant just accept him... dude its lylo so if you die we lose | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
most likely scum is PT but i could easily change my mind after sinking some more time into figuring things out. unfortunately i wont be able to do that today. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Actually pretending to be noob town is a pretty good strategy for scum in a smurf game. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 13 2013 01:00 Baker1986 wrote: I asked you to explain how and why McCoy and PT must be the scumteam, or well my initial question was simply to get you to explain to me who is scum given the assumption I'm town. I'm more than willing to listen to you, if you have anything to say, because I believe we should take all the time we have to figure out today's lynch. But you've said Eccleston is town, I know I am town and obviously in your own version of this game you are "confirmed town". So that leaves only PT and McCoy as potential scum candidates when you try to explain your world to me (me, specifically). So if I am to listen to you at all, you must explain why PT and McCoy are the final two scum, the latter one I have a very hard time believing is scum tbh. ya you have the time but i dont lol. i'm not playing "scummy." i just honestly dont have the time to figure shit out atm. for me that takes extensive rereading and filters. your question makes no sense to me... I asked you to explain how and why McCoy and PT must be the scumteam, or well my initial question was simply to get you to explain to me who is scum given the assumption I'm town. I don't think mccoy is scum. So i guess it's you and pt? maybe pt and ecc. maybe you and ecc. i have no idea lol | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
the truth was I had a lot of free time during those days and now I dont | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Why would scum try so hard to defend him if he was town?? Therefore if he's town, im probably town. But if hes scum i could still be town. So you should lynch him first get it? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
if he is town i am probably also town. so that means why would you lynch me first? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
i honestly am doing other shit right now and i can take a minute to write this but i cant look at filters | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
dat laziness survival vote | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
dat ecc pt scumteam? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
#@baker the only person who isn't chill is pt for some reason. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
also what actions should I explain? A lot of them probably don't have good explanations. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Even though I dont have a lot of time I am in the thread a lot talking with you. I am not afraid to talk and PT is. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
don't equate tryhard to towniness. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
-just summary, no statement of who he think is scum. He randomly muses on if baker could be considered scummy. -Suddenly he votes HW then JP without talking about either beforehand. -Summarizes some shit HW did. Then says he's a good lynch. Note: only makes an argument against HW AFTER voting for him the previous day. -Votes ECC. This is the bus. The only reason he gives is "disappearance." Proceeds to disappear for the entire weekend. EXAMPLE: this is the only post that leads to an ECC vote. He never even says why he thinks ECC is scummy really. Just talks about a bunch of random unconnected shit: On June 06 2013 08:31 PTroughton2 wrote: + Show Spoiler + Less than enthused that there was nothing from Eccleston after his latest promise almost a day ago. The developments over the early part of this cycle lead me to believe that he is using the opportunity to not take part in discourse and remain in the shadows as Davison, who is arguably being the loudest, leads discussion away from him. Of course I appear to be in that same category but right now I'm trying to wrap my head around Davison's case. Tom's rebuttal reads incredibly townie and he has explained, at least to my own satisfaction, his thoughts on each of the points brought against him. Moreover, I am concerned that this case seeks to discredit Tom who was one of two people eyeing Davison for a potential lynch on D1. It seems the other was also one of his current scum reads: McGann. It may be just a coincidence, after all, and the game is dynamic after all, so I'll take a look at Davison's responses to those suspicions. Okay so that was in the period Davison was inactive and heading for replacement. Fair enough. I don't think I can attribute his read on Tom now to the things that Tom wrote about his slot earlier in the game, especially when those concerns over Davison were assuaged by McCoy: On June 03 2013 06:05 SMcCoy wrote: If we don't lynch JP the only guy I'll vote today will be HartnellWill, I've grown doubts about Davis cause of this post: This was right after DrT jumped onto the Trout wagon. If Davison is his scumbuddy, why would he try to disrupt the only way for DrT to save himself? Also, I think this post is really townie, although I don't agree with his conclusion since HW also made clear he would switch onto Trout: No Davis lynch please. I think we have a false positive here. The new Davison is loud and in your face and even though I feel he is incorrect about Tom here, I am having trouble placing a scum motive on this case when it can just be explained as a genuine misunderstanding or misinterpretation as shown by Tom's response. Davison, would you please flesh out what exactly it is about McGann you find scummy other than assocation with Tom, or have you reconsidered your renewed read on Eccleston in the face of his timely disappearance? ##Vote: Eccleston | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
its fucking obvious you are town. your level of tryhard at this point in the game is completely unnecessary for scum. if you were scum you would not be as active as you are being because there's no point. you will already have won. I don't get how I can prove I'm town to you. I can't elaborate on reasons that I didn't have. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
You tryinghard ATM is a huge towntell because if you were scum you would not need to tryhard to win. PT is tryharding to appease you, carefully answering all your questions without trying to convince you of anything or engaging in conversation with you. I may be lazy so I'm not writing long shit, but I am tryharding to convince you to vote PT because a town win is so close but it all relies on your decision. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
Early game: I was hella busy. Holy shit this town is uber tryhard and awesome. i really don't have anything of value to add with my limited time. Mid game: K town started sucking. I am totally going to put some time into this game, find the scumteam and impress everyone. After the game I'm going to be so proud to say who I really am and everyone will love me. After the HW mislynch: fuck i was wrong about everything. I suck. fuck this crapshoot of a game. fml Now: wow despite all my retardation town can still win. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
When i read the case against PT, I didn't realize that he only had that one rp post. I thought the quotes in the case were from multiple PT posts. When I realized, I decided it wasn't a good idea to vote for him just for that one post. I thought DrT was town for a long time d1. Why? probably because im bad lol. It's just his behavior didn't match my overly narrow d1 scum criteria (dont give opinions, say as little as possible, stay out of the spotlight). I remember the exact moment I changed my mind about DrT and proceeded to vote for him. I read Iforgetwhoseitwas summary of the case against DrT. I actually took a long time to read it very carefully, and understand the points it made. AND I also read DrT's filter closely. And I read the posts he was responding to closely. (That's how I determined his defense was quite exaggerated and unnecessary. (he wasn't even calling DrT scum). This is the second (well third, if you are counting the lylo groveling stage) most effort I put into this game. On May 31 2013 11:20 Hurndall3 wrote: ##unvote ##vote DrT k I think I can sheep this DrT shit now that I read the case thoroughly. these are the points that convinced me to sheep. 1 DrT's overdefense 2 unnatural calmness 3 repeated appeal that scum is among the inactives 4 one dimensional scumreads I believed all those points and I could point them out and find examples in his filter. I didn't think I needed to at the time, because someone else already had very thoroughly. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
my recent awareness of my own badness stems from being very wrong about this game. At that point I honestly thought I had 100% solved the game. I had reasons for thinking ecc was scum. In fact I couldn't stfu about it. I think the one that convinced you was how he quotes vers town guide. In retrospect, dumb reasons. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
phone posting now btw | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
On June 13 2013 09:07 PTroughton2 wrote: No, you know what, fuck this guy. This is not how you play TL mafia. Are we switching? look he wants to switch to me so bad. Why? because I am pissing him off. He started to get really "mad" at me conveniently when smmc wanted to switch. what set him off? I said "yalls are bad" | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
you played a good game pt but I guess you just got outplayed by town? | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
I look town without trying. This is because I really am town. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
baker is really palmar lol? second time you mislynched me ebdgame. and don't say I'm unreadable cause so many people would have known I was town there. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
If you were unable to determine my alignment than that is your own fault. I gave plently of content for a townread. I am actually proud of my play this game and in future games I will endevour to maintain this high watermark of quality. | ||
|
Hurndall3
237 Posts
| ||
| ||
