On May 20 2013 03:16 yamato77 wrote:
So you like a lurker lynch over a sheep lynch?

When do you know Dandel to not have strong opinions in the game?

since when is this a lurker lynch you dont think sputnik hasnt done scummy shit

The list post which fits the profile of scum looking like he wants to contribute
the im gonna random vote after i read but i actually am not going read and not care about the lynch at all.

He is not a lurker lynch

iamperfection

United States9645 Posts

May 19 2013 18:21 GMT

#1148

and when you combine that with general inactivity he has an amazing chance of flipping scum

goodkarma

United States1067 Posts

May 19 2013 18:24 GMT

#1149

Just woke up, and it looks like there's some time before the deadline. First thing's first.:

On May 19 2013 20:41 marvellosity wrote:
No, that isn't what I wrote, or what I meant at least. I meant he'd written out an analysis on s0lstice, and as such it would have been super easy for him to vote for s0lstice. Instead he changed his mind on his play and didn't vote for him.

As mafia, why bother including this change of heart? Seems an easy opportunity just to plop a vote down.

The thing with rayn is that he was super-active in his scum newbie game, which not only makes the meta weaker, but potentially flat-out incorrect.

Hopefully you'll be back before deadline.

Regarding Spicy:
As mafia, why bother with being decisive at all? If you don't stick your neck out at all, then you don't draw attention to yourself. I just don't understand what you're trying to get at here. As mafia you try to fly under the radar. One way to do that is to not really think anyone's scum. It may have been easy for him to vote Solstice, but he would be drawing some attention to himself by doing so.

Regarding Rayne:
As for Rayn if there's a game he's been super-active as scum I didn't see it. You would be correct I'd be flat-out incorrect if that were the case. It's not exactly like he made it easy for me to find his games by linking them in his profile. When I was diving into his last ten pages of posting history, I didn't manage to find the game to which you're referring.

s0Lstice

United States1832 Posts

May 19 2013 18:26 GMT

#1150

On May 20 2013 03:13 yamato77 wrote:
Solstice, do you like the Dandel lynch?

If not, why?

I was just looking at that. I think the jury is still out on whether or not he is trying. His filter is full of junk and trolling, but according to others (I've never played with him) this is something he does for either alignment.

His treatment of WoS seems reasonable. He keeps a level head in matters concerning grush. Iamp says Dandel's marv trolling is a town read, and Dandel corrects him by telling him its not. There's little tidbits like this sprinkled amongst the BS.

As an aside, how likely is it that we have town night kp in a closed set-up like this?

s0Lstice

United States1832 Posts

May 19 2013 18:28 GMT

#1151

Like...I really don't want to have to be talking about sputnik or stutters tomorrow

goodkarma

United States1067 Posts

May 19 2013 18:34 GMT

#1152

On May 19 2013 23:38 Spicydinosaur wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm wondering if this is an attempted scum vote redirect on me at the last minute to save someone else. Your entire post is hinged on me have 0 scum reads that you are so happy to point out a number of times. This is a complete flat out lie, and given my small filter, a deliberate misreading of me.

Show nested quote +

This is a scum read on sputnik that you completely ignore. Then in the same post I vote for jarjar because of his excuses.

Show nested quote +

GK's reading of me is completely false and his deliberate avoidance of my scum reads points to him being scum.

So in your defense post Spicy, you claim to have scum reads. The quote about Sputnik that YOU'VE PRESENTED includes this passage:

"More likely than not he'll show up as town, but everyone will have a solid defense for voting him."

I would say that's the EXACT OPPOSITE of a scumread.

And your second post refers to your vote post, which I already mentioned is the ONLY PLACE you've made any kind of scumread. And you botched it up at that, not even being able to keep straight the guy's name you were voting.

Spicy, THIS DEFENSE POST is a flat-out lie, not my case against you.

goodkarma

United States1067 Posts

May 19 2013 18:39 GMT

#1153

Can you guys please look at what I've said about Spicy? I know I may not have massive clout atm, but if you're going to be voting me the responsible thing to do is to look at the strength of the scumreads I've put out there. IN HIS OWN DEFENSE POST, he didn't really have much to say against my accusations. I just don't understand why he's gotten away with zero attention put on him.

yamato77

11589 Posts

May 19 2013 18:43 GMT

#1154

I'll agree with you, GK, Spicy is suspect. That sputnik read of his is particularly scummy.