EPTNewbie Mafia XXXIX - Page 9
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
virtu
United Kingdom147 Posts
| ||
|
Frorgon
United States146 Posts
I wasn't necessarily suspicious of Raven. I was trying to provoke some more discussion, because up until that point there hadn't been much. I'd get a gist about Raven based on his response and I think I was fairly successful in that. Comparing it to the previous game I'd say as of now he leans town for me. | ||
|
Frorgon
United States146 Posts
The point I was trying to make was that Raven pointed out jarjar as potentially suspicious, and then later in the same post backed off and said that the behavior could possibly explained. It's a scum move to give the appearance of suspecting someone in order to look useful, only to avoid committing to it later on. in the same post. | ||
|
virtu
United Kingdom147 Posts
| ||
|
JarJarDrinks
United States1302 Posts
On March 23 2013 04:26 Frorgon wrote: The impression I got was that you realized your scum buddy made a pretty scummy post and got called out on it. So you made sure to call him out as well while @ the same time trying to cast suspicion on me by implying that we were teammates:@ray The point I was trying to make was that Raven pointed out jarjar as potentially suspicious, and then later in the same post backed off and said that the behavior could possibly explained. It's a scum move to give the appearance of suspecting someone in order to look useful, only to avoid committing to it later on. in the same post. Why would you accuse him of trying to cover for me when I had just called him out on his post? | ||
|
Frorgon
United States146 Posts
On March 23 2013 00:48 virtu wrote: So far the only person that's really caught my attention is ray, for how aggressive he's being, the speed of which he's exchanged his focus and vote. These are all points that have been brought up by others, but it's the only truly suspicious thing happening atm. @ray what do you hope to achieve by switching focus at the drop of a pin with your agressiveness? two or three more posts like that and you're going after half the thread. Do you think this is an effective way to find mafia? why? So you don't want people to actively scumhunt? You want to discourage people for trying to find answers? It's day one, of course there is going to be no trust and questions asked of everyone. How else are we going to get reads? On March 23 2013 00:53 Rainbows wrote: Holy crap you're scum. ##Unvote ##Vote: Virtu Cute. Your tone so far has been confident bordering on arrogant. Traits commonly found in a new player that thinks he's invincible when he gets Godfather handed to him and doesn't know what to do with it. [QUOTE]On March 23 2013 01:05 raynpelikoneet wrote: So now you're concerned because Rainbows is onto you. Lets call him the supreme mafioso for it! Sorry, I don't think you're going to scare him that easily. I don't like how virtu is seemingly antagonistic to anyone who is being aggressive in trying to find scum. ##Vote: virtu | ||
|
Frorgon
United States146 Posts
On March 22 2013 22:53 JarJarDrinks wrote: OK, now a post has stood out to me. This seems scummy: Pointing out that I'm suspicious and hostile (am I being hostile?) to make sure everybody else is aware of it but then posting a weak defense for me. Basically telling everyone: You should suspect jarjar, but I don't. So keep in mind what you said here jarjar. Now why would Raven suspect you and then soft defend you if he is scum and you are not? If you're town wouldn't he just push for your lynch? So this is what seemed off to me. I mean maybe it is the case and Raven is just using real evasive maneuvers. | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
anyways imma hit the filter and the the thread. @geript, where are you good sir with your nutta butta's, I need food | ||
|
JarJarDrinks
United States1302 Posts
On March 23 2013 05:06 Frorgon wrote: I feel like the reason for that should be obvious.So keep in mind what you said here jarjar. Now why would Raven suspect you and then soft defend you if he is scum and you are not? If you're town wouldn't he just push for your lynch? Scum doesn't want to be responsible for lynching a townie but he still wants a townie lynched So basically he points out that I'm suspicious and hostile hoping to maybe influence some people and get me lynched. Then when I turn up green, he doesn't look suspicious because he "defended" me and can go after one of the people that voted for me. I would think that the best result for mafia is getting a townie lynched with the least amount of scum voting for that person. And notice that he still left himself an out so he could go back to voting for me if the situation required it. He said he sees "no reason to punish it till after other people show up." | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
sup Jar Jar, what's with this vote? what kind of evidence is this? this is weak town play/kinda scummy: it seems like this kind of thinking: oh herp, ray thinks raven is scummy; oh i think so too => sheep vote. it's interesting/suspicious, since more or less you have identified some scummy behavior, but still only quote a sentiment... my FoS has upgraded to a Hand of Suspicion HoS on you. On March 23 2013 02:50 virtu wrote: If you take the GF thing seriously, you're stupid. I'm clearly responding to your utterly ridiculous attempt at calling me scum with an equally ridiculous response. Simple as that. Also, your comparison is terrible, I'm ADMITTING i'm not adding anything to the thread in my own post because I know I'm not, and I have nothing to add at that moment in time. Still, I post it because it's better to post whether I agree/disagree with things others have said than to not post at all, even if it is one way scum hide amongst townies. In AD's post he accidentally adds in the fact that he's sheeping others, in a post trying to look like he's adding to the thread. they're completely different posts. hmm, so you read the previous newbie mafia... ok so what you think of the meta or far, any deviance, do you see any changes in the players in this game and the last game? btw you're kinda sheeping too, where is your scumhunting? youve just been hostile. scumhunt, man. dumbledore'll get mad at you. | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
On March 22 2013 22:28 TheRavensName wrote: I gotta agree that jarjars post and hostility might be a little suspicious... however I know I did something similar in the last nmm and ended up doing some pretty decent work so I see no reason to punish it till after other people show up. Day 1 is a scary and uncertain period for those unsure how to get the ball rolling. hmmm, so Raven, good sir, are you still for FoS,HoS, or Voting for JarJar? help us guide through Day 1 and get the ball rolling. + Show Spoiler + and honestly, Raven, we really don't needs star wars blasphemy in a harry potter world. On March 22 2013 23:57 TheRavensName wrote: My favorite part is Frorgon gets to sheep a post in and doesn't get called for it, but V gets jumped 10 minutes after he shows up.. I posted my explination for wording and reasonings behind it. Pease find something else for me to do other then respond to the same points over and over again. ...what the hell does this post even mean? world unfair? and btw you never followed up for this explanation. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43268 Posts
What do you think of Frorgon's case on virtu, and his post about JarJar after that? | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
Well case on virtu is valid, virtu if town has terrible play, honestly I kind of want to curse virtu's play. hasn't done stuff besides defending and saying crazy stuff @Virtu are you town? haha at this pt, at least do a good job of pretending to be town. idk about the post about Jar Jar. seems somewhat like a soft defense of Raven, but honestly I can't read too much into it right now. need some more input from frogron, raven and jarjar | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
I want to know what you think. Otherwise your question doesn't mean much, besides a little input from nobodywonder. It seems you want a lil' dirt on Frorgon though or some dirt on JarJar. | ||
|
TheRavensName
United States911 Posts
On March 23 2013 05:56 nobodywonder wrote: @JarJar, thou shall quoteth well. you meant this post right? hmmm, so Raven, good sir, are you still for FoS,HoS, or Voting for JarJar? help us guide through Day 1 and get the ball rolling. + Show Spoiler + and honestly, Raven, we really don't needs star wars blasphemy in a harry potter world. ...what the hell does this post even mean? world unfair? and btw you never followed up for this explanation. I don't actually don't think Jarjar is all that suspicious, I was trying to defend him and not attack him but whatever, I've repeated that enough. Fr and Ray worry me a bit mor. As to what that means... I don't know what it means, I posted it on my way home from class so I don't think I even knew what it was whn I was writing it. I think I was trying to suggest the fact that Forgron was ignored was kind of suspicious, like he was trying to contribute to make it look like he was and it was just getting either ignored because it agreed, or because Ray and him are both scum. + Show Spoiler + On March 23 2013 05:42 nobodywonder wrote:hmm, so you read the previous newbie mafia... ok so what you think of the meta or far, any deviance, do you see any changes in the players in this game and the last game? btw you're kinda sheeping too, where is your scumhunting? youve just been hostile. scumhunt, man. dumbledore'll get mad at you. I think its simiilar. personally, but I don't want to really read too much into it.. but for that reason I'm starting to doubt my scum read on Ray. | ||
|
JarJarDrinks
United States1302 Posts
On March 23 2013 05:42 nobodywonder wrote: sup Jar Jar, what's with this vote? what kind of evidence is this? this is weak town play/kinda scummy: it seems like this kind of thinking: oh herp, ray thinks raven is scummy; oh i think so too => sheep vote. it's interesting/suspicious, since more or less you have identified some scummy behavior, but still only quote a sentiment... my FoS has upgraded to a Hand of Suspicion HoS on you. You're taking this out of context. Yeah this was one post but I had made several prior to this post already stating my reasons. In fact Ray voted for raven based on my initial read of his post. I stated why I thought Ravens post was scummy. Then when ray posted his analysis which confirmed what I was thinking, I stated that I agreed with him in believing Raven is mafia. Not sure how you can interpret that as a sheep vote. | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
@Raven, double negative in your post. anyways you seem ...off and perhaps nervous at this thing called scumhunting. why do frorgon and ray worry ypu? | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
btw i did get one on the wagon On March 22 2013 12:40 TheRavensName wrote: ##Vote: Geript I'm eating one right now... and I am making up for all the times I didn't get to do this last game. lol, btw raven you're still technically voting geript with me right now. lol. you should revote and post the reasons again + Show Spoiler + On March 23 2013 00:22 TheRavensName wrote: Damn it Rainbows... I try to do something other then complain and you get this up before I do.. Oh well I'll just tack it on the end. Something that your missing is the fact he calls me out for "Spreading Fear" by saying I'm wrong to say Day 1 is scary, but he himself is already doing that by calling out the only two people who have said something along those lines and also he just sort of drops the whole thing he had on Jar Jar who was saying the same thing. WIFOM Warning for coming far too early in the game + Show Spoiler + Per chance it was a set up, with Jarjar posting, Ray respnding, and then they team up on whoever takes the bait (me.) I also again did not meant to say he was supicious, but how his actions could be seen as suspicious. I would not defend him in that same post if I really thought he was supicious. In my opnion, I think Ray is just someone swinging out for the blood of an early myslynch and he is going to keep switching around till he finds one that works enough. Why did he drop Jar to focus on me instead of calling out more people who were lurking? This one gained traction first. So you dislikemy joke vote/ I'll change it for ya. Unvote: Geript Vote: Raynpelikoneet | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43268 Posts
On March 23 2013 06:08 nobodywonder wrote: I think of things, what do you think on these things too? Well case on virtu is valid, virtu if town has terrible play, honestly I kind of want to curse virtu's play. hasn't done stuff besides defending and saying crazy stuff @Virtu are you town? haha at this pt, at least do a good job of pretending to be town. I don't think the case is valid at all. Frorgon is saying virtu is suspicious because he called out my aggressive behaviour. virtu later said it was to look for reactions from me. It's completely another thing if Frorgon believes his explanation or not, but the case presented this way has no merit because it's based on false pretenses. I also fail to see how virtu is being "overly defensive". He just called out Rainbow's bad comparsion of behaviour, i wouldn't label that as "overly defensive". idk about the post about Jar Jar. seems somewhat like a soft defense of Raven, but honestly I can't read too much into it right now. need some more input from frogron, raven and jarjar I don't understand why Frorgon thinks Raven and JarJar are both scum given what Raven said. First of all, you can't base JarJar's alignment on what Raven says about him. It only gives us clues about Raven's alignment. It's not uncommon for mafia to soft/hard defend townies to make them look worse in case the mafia guy flips. Second of all, do not make connection cases pre-flip, that's just dumb. So in my eyes Frorgon looks worse. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43268 Posts
Why are you ignoring the fact that i called Frorgon out right after he made his post about you and JarJar? You should really read the whole thread and not only the parts that fit into your cases / suspicions. | ||
| ||
