Okay, I've read the whole thread again. First of all, where the fuck is prplhz and why isn't anyone else curious? He has literally 4 in game posts and while he appears to be interested in "thread atmosphere", I just have no idea who he thinks is scum.

Djo bringing back up the whole Oats/Mocsta thing is just...confusing. What's the point? I'm not even sure what he's accusing Mocsta of in the first place. @Djo What exactly is your problem with Mocsta? It's like you're suspicious of him because he didn't join your random lynch (which you say that you didn't even really like).

As I said earlier, I'm very very interested in clearing out the trash, being players who signed up and aren't playing. Right now that list is:

Palmar
prplhz
Snarfs
JX

There's no way in hell they're all scum. Here's what I want to do. I think everyone should choose one name off that list that they believe is the most realistic lynch candidate based on what they perceive to be town sentiment. Then I want them to explain why they aren't voting for that person, and explain in detail why their lynch candidate is better.

Know this. GM made it clear in the OP that lurkers will ruin this game. You don't even have to take my word for it, it's right in the OP. The worst thing townies can do in this setup is lurk. Therefor, I don't want to lynch someone active today. We can start lynching into active posters with more flip information.

I think prplhz is the most realistic lynch candidate, and I'll tell you why (though you probably won't like it.)

Palmar apparently wants to lynch prplhz.

Is that fucked up or what? But it's true. If Palmar comes back in here and says "Yeah I still want to lynch prplhz" then I believe that prplhz will get lynched. In spite of fucking off for the entire game, Palmar has more say over who gets lynched than I do. But I'm not bitter - all is not lost you see. For I can also get down on a prplhz lynch. I'd still do somersaults over a Palmar lynch or Snarfs lynch, but honestly I just don't think I can make it happen today.

____________________________________________________________________

On the active posters:
I'd like to see more from slOosh. Him backing out of his yamato read, while admirable I guess, leaves me wondering just who he thinks is scum. He mentioned phagga as a means of determining prplhz' alignment...somehow? But made it clear that he wasn't really a scumread. Ultimately he wants it to be clear that he's not doing nothing, which generally sets off red flags for me. He started out as a super townread too, which is why this is concerning for me.

@slOosh
You say "let's work with what we've got". I've got a case on Snarfs that you haven't commented on. I've got a lurker policy that I'd like you to consider. I'd really like to hear who you think is scum.

yamato is on my to-do list tomorrow morning. So is Cheesecake. I'm going to bed now.

##Unvote: Palmar
##Vote: prplhz

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 17:41 GMT

#621

I'm up and reading. Why cant people be this active when I'm NOT asleep X(

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 18:02 GMT

#637

Still no quotes from this game explaining your viewpoint. Just vague meta references and now you're throwing in non-alignment indicative bullshit.

##Unvote: prplhz
##Vote: Snarfs

WOOOWOOOOOOOOO This is the lynch guys, all aboard.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 18:11 GMT

#651

Lulzy? Fuck this game.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 18:11 GMT

#652

By which I mean, I'm getting ready for work and will be phoneposting up until the lynch.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 18:33 GMT

#674

I'm willing to consolidate onto JX.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 20:12 GMT

#693

I AM WILLING TO BET MY LIFE THAT PALMAR IS MAFIA.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 20:36 GMT

#698

The JX wagon popped up quick. FAST quick. I mean, this is like the end of the phase really with people going to bed.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 20:48 GMT

#700

That's the spirit. Take your ball and go home.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 21:52 GMT

#704

##Unvote: Snarfs
##Vote: JieXian

It's still true - it was just an observation. I wouldn't say he's been discussed "all day"...he doesn't even have enough content to warrant all-day discussion. And his resurgence into the thread when the threat of lynch is real certainly doesn't speak well for him either.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 22:06 GMT

#706

I didn't read Death Note. Tell me this: what motivation is more likely for a player who "isn't invested in the game" to come in and, while he doesn't have input on who we should lynch, tries to put the lynch off of the present candidate AFTER they've reached majority? Town or scum? Just remove the fact that it's Palmar from the equation, you'll come to the same conclusion I do.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 22:21 GMT

#708

prplhz summarize your case against jay. All I see is a lot of convoluted summarizing his play. You didn't like something about his interactions with Djo?

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

February 07 2013 22:26 GMT

#709

Palmar is already going to have attention on him because he's promised some kind of "plan" to take advantage of scum nominations or something...he's lurked unrepentantly all of D1. Do you mean to tell me that you were going to let him do the same D2? What about D3 phagga? When does it end?

If he's town, his play is lynchworthy anyway - but he's not. I would think (or at least hope) that he wouldn't play a game like this as town.