|
On January 27 2013 11:52 Promethelax wrote:
You wanted him dead. That means your mind was made up. Also you want him dead as a 'hardcore lurker' over EZ who is 'scum'
##unvote
##vote:xsksc
Now you're just misrepresenting. My vote is still on EZ, I think he is scum. Nothing has changed there. Where do I say I would rather lynch him over EZ?
I am willing to kill thrawn because of his extreme lurking. Are you saying if thrawn came in here and started making quality posts and glowed townie, I wouldn't re-evaluate the situation because my "mind is made up"? That seems a very silly assumption to me.
On January 27 2013 12:01 Promethelax wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 11:43 xsksc wrote:On January 27 2013 11:32 Promethelax wrote:
Well I meant to say I've and not ice.
You are. You say you are willing to kill thrawn ergo you think he is scum. You say he had better get in here soon and make a sad face which is saying he is town. You don't have a read and you are setting yourself up both to vote and to not vote him. How did you arrive at the bolded part? I'm sad that he's completely lurked and been useless so far...how on earth does that indicate I have a town read on him? That's dumb. If I thought he was town I wouldn't have just agreed to kill him... I'll happily kill anyone who makes a couple of posts and then lurks for the rest of the day. Yes = I am willing to kill him. D: = He has done nothing and I want him to be contributing. Okay, so why did you agree to kill Tfunk but not any of the other lurkers I just mentioned? Why is he the scummiest for you.
He comes in, makes a couple of posts and joke and then disappears forever. He was a LOT more active in Hero mini iirc, the others you mention have at least contributed something and we aren't seeing the same guy in this game.
|
hi boys <3
i want to ask you all a few questions. i'm not understanding some things about both hapa and thrawn. but maybe your answers will help me figure out which one of them to lynch today. right now i maybe want to lynch thrawn a bit more. just a bit though.
when i voted hapa he delurked and said good morning. but if i am not mistaken he is american, and it was around 6:00 kst. why would hapahauli say good morning if it is between 1 pm and 4 pm in the USA? maybe he was actively lurking before i voted him. maybe he is scum?
second from what i have seen thrawn does not play very very lurky. i think he is scum. i would expect him to maybe call someone scum or do something by now but where is he? has anyone played a game with him where he afks like this?
thank you loves 
|
It's not unheard of to sleep into the afternoon on a Saturday you know. I did the same ^^
What is it that makes you think hapa is scum, apart from the delurk? Why does it have to wait until just before the lynch?
|
I've said this before and I'll say it again. Look at thrawn as scum in Mario mini.
Now answer my questions.
|
On January 27 2013 12:37 Promethelax wrote:
I've said this before and I'll say it again. Look at thrawn as scum in Mario mini.
Now answer my questions.
He didn't even play day one in that game? Why is that game relevant to this situation?
And hey, if you're going to ask me all these questions, I'd appreciate it if you'd do me the simple courtesy of replying to what I have to say.
|
You answered my questions. What do you want me to reply to? And the hell do you mean he didn't play day one of Mario? Isn't that the same thing as here?
|
My bad - I thought he replaced INTO that game, not out of.
On January 27 2013 12:48 Promethelax wrote:
You answered my questions. What do you want me to reply to?
"Now you're just misrepresenting. My vote is still on EZ, I think he is scum. Nothing has changed there. Where do I say I would rather lynch him over EZ?
"Are you saying if thrawn came in here and started making quality posts and glowed townie, I wouldn't re-evaluate the situation because my "mind is made up"?"
This?
I love how djodref came in and did the same thing as me (staying on his main read but has agreed to kill thrawn) but he's not getting shit for it.
|
You haven't pushed EZ. You said you would kill thrawn. I misinterpreted your stance I guess. Please update your EZ read.
I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying that you said two things which aren't congruent.
I can't call djo on his bs after he vanishes. When he comes back I can. And I'll be here since I'm working for another six hours.
Also: Hapa, do you really thing mr Z wrote the above post? It doesn't sound like him at all.
|
On January 27 2013 11:52 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 11:43 Promethelax wrote:
Er....wat?
Why are we lynching x? Why can't we pressure him? Are you really this much of a fool? Why not EZ? Ok alright. Let's assume for a moment that he is the first scum. We have to find the second. Everything xsksc posts from now on is done of his own will. If he redeems himself, fine, if not, he's dead anyway. ##Unvote
##Vote Sharrant
Lengthy post with scumreads I don't agree with. He starts on picking on Prom for posting a useless first post but doesn't see xsksc's posts. The post is designed to look like he's putting effort into the game and suggests he posted that to not get attacked by us so he can go back lurking and doing nothing while resting on some made up reads.
I'm interested to hear where you disagree with my scum reads, would you please elaborate?
I have not missed xsksc's posts, but I haven't felt the need to comment on them yet. My first read through the thread I thought he was pretty scummy, but I did not have time to write a post at that point. In subsequent readings I've had him anywhere from null to slightly townie.
On January 26 2013 14:06 xsksc wrote:
It's just us 3 on? zzz
Where are the Americans? It can't be that late across the pond o.O
On January 26 2013 14:11 xsksc wrote:
Marv is british, no? It's 5.11am here ^_^
Posts like this make me think he is very enthusiastic about this game, something which for most is a town tell, perhaps that's how he plays as mafia, but I haven't read his past games. We share at least one town read, and he has at least one of my town reads as a scum read. His interaction with Djo was a rather protracted and silly argument, but that's more Djo's fault than his I'd say, and I have a notoriously hard time reading Djo so it's neither here nor there to me until I have a better grasp of both players.
Xsksc has some strong town tells to me, but has a number of iffy things that bring him down to nullish-town. I don't feel the need to talk about town reads with the thread unless specifically asked about them, or if a strong town read is being attacked, that's why there's been no comment.
|
On January 27 2013 13:27 Promethelax wrote:
You haven't pushed EZ. You said you would kill thrawn. I misinterpreted your stance I guess. Please update your EZ read.
+ Show Spoiler +On January 27 2013 09:51 xsksc wrote:I re-read this little interaction and I still can't get my head around it. EmileZola switches his vote from thrawn to Hapa with no explanation, and thrawn still hasn't posted by then. So the only event that could change his mind would have to have come from Hapa, right? Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 06:38 xsksc wrote:
I'd like him to explain his thought process behind the vote on you. Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 06:41 EmileZola wrote:
i wanted to see if he's there and delurks if i vote him... and he has only 1 filterpage of game right now. I heard as town he usually has more :-] Hapa has been one of the more active players so far, and his posts have been pretty solid. Seems like a really silly reason to be voting him. Then there's this... Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 06:42 EmileZola wrote:
there is also one additional reason, a reason i will tell you in exactly 22 hours from now on. Apparently he has a secret reason for voting Hapa too, but he won't share it with us until 3 hours before the lynch, wtf? Does that not strike anyone else as incredibly anti-town? ##vote EmileZola You guys seem reluctant to lynch him IF he's zentor, why is that? Is he somehow excused from scummy behavior if his identity is different?
On January 27 2013 11:18 xsksc wrote:
-emilezola scum.
It hasn't changed.
|
@sharrant Level of enthusiasm is a pretty bad way of reading someone I think. Mafia can pretty easily fake it...those posts would be just as easy for me to make if I was scum.
|
On January 27 2013 13:59 xsksc wrote:
@sharrant Level of enthusiasm is a pretty bad way of reading someone I think. Mafia can pretty easily fake it...those posts would be just as easy for me to make if I was scum.
I would disagree with you, even many of the strongest scum players on the forum are easiest to spot just by their interest and enthusiasm for the game. That's been Marv's downfall in several games and I'd say he's the strongest scum player I've seen on the forum. An earnest enthusiasm is a difficult appearance for mafia players to keep. You could be proving me wrong right now, or you could just be very enthusiastic because this is your first scum game in just under a year and a half. That was an avenue of thought I had not explored.
|
is it time to get the search party together for thrawn???
anyways the wagon on thrawn is now the wagon of justice.
thrawn lurks when he is scum
show him no mercy.
|
On January 27 2013 14:21 iamperfection wrote:
is it time to get the search party together for thrawn???
anyways the wagon on thrawn is now the wagon of justice.
thrawn lurks when he is scum
show him no mercy.
Is this a lurker lynch, or a scum lynch in your eyes?
|
On January 27 2013 14:39 Sharrant wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 14:21 iamperfection wrote:
is it time to get the search party together for thrawn???
anyways the wagon on thrawn is now the wagon of justice.
thrawn lurks when he is scum
show him no mercy. Is this a lurker lynch, or a scum lynch in your eyes?
i think i was pretty clear on what it was.
plus i only lynch in one way and that is scum......
|
On January 27 2013 14:47 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2013 14:39 Sharrant wrote:On January 27 2013 14:21 iamperfection wrote:
is it time to get the search party together for thrawn???
anyways the wagon on thrawn is now the wagon of justice.
thrawn lurks when he is scum
show him no mercy. Is this a lurker lynch, or a scum lynch in your eyes? i think i was pretty clear on what it was. plus i only lynch in one way and that is scum......
You were quite clear, but I wanted to give you a chance to clarify.
I agree that Thrawn lurks when he is scum, but I have never seen him lurk this hard. Comparing his filters in other games they suffer significantly when he's scum compared to town, but I find it a little absurd to compare this lurking to his lurking in other games.
I would be more agreeable if you had said this was a lurker lynch, but lurking this hard is headed into modkill/replacement territory, and at least from my perspective this seems non-alignment indicitave because of the severity of the lurking. I'll consider this more as we get closer to the deadline, but unless he pipes up soon, he's going to stay as a null read.
|
VE-VE-VE-VOTECOUNT:
yamato77 ( 0 ):
Sharrant ( 0 ): Vivax
Vivax ( 0 ): Promethelax
Iamperfection ( 1 ): VisceraEyes
Xsksc ( 1 ): Vivax, Vivax, Promethelax
Thrawn2112 ( 1 ): EmileZola, Iamperfection
Promethelax ( 2 ): Iamperfection, Vivax, Sharrant, Ghost_403
VisceraEyes( 1 ): Djodref
Djodref ( 0 ):
Ghost_403 ( 0 ):
Hapahauli ( 1 ): EmileZola
JieXian ( 0 ): Vivax, Promethelax
EmileZola ( 1 ): Vivax, Hapahauli, Xsksc
With 13 people alive it takes 7 to lynch someone.
|
On January 27 2013 11:04 Promethelax wrote:
Ghost, do me a favour and don't ignore after making the worst case ever. Why is VE scum? Why is EZ town? Why is your case so bad?
Imp, between x and Tfunk I'm with you.
Sorry but who is tfunk?
On January 27 2013 11:52 Promethelax wrote:
You wanted him dead. That means your mind was made up. Also you want him dead as a 'hardcore lurker' over EZ who is 'scum'
##unvote
##vote:xsksc
wth? Find me a post that says that. I did a search in his filter for thrawn and all I saw was xsk saying that thrawn is hardlurking.
I (and probably hapa too) won't lynch for MrZ if he is really MrZ because he was exactly like that in Witchcraft. Before anyone vote him please read his meta. Ghost was probably aware of his meta since he was in Witchcraft too. MrZ would be a null for me, for now. Not scumy yet.
I'm putting mario aside, since that seems to be the only game where he is loud as mafia. I want thrawn to come out.
##Vote: thrawn
|
No djo? I'm unimpressed.
Sharrent did you play any games besides LC (never forget) ? You seem to have some meta reads which I don't understand the basis of. Where are you getting this knowledge?
I'm going to sleep. See you in eight hours. Someone get that BE case from djo when he shows up.
|
Oh hey JX. Awesome timing. Thrawn is Tfunk.
I already said I misinterpreted x's post. Y u no read?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
