TL Mafia LIX - Page 2

On January 22 2013 03:17 JieXian wrote:
*snip*



No one would bother to slowly dissect your long post for a time zone when your tag says US.

Don't need to give me a defense that was already mentioned, wth can't you even realise yet that I don't think it's very likely that you're scum? I was very worried about being too rude and pissing you off.

But I guess I should be clear: I think it's more likely that you didn't change from our first game rather than you being scum.

Cool story, if that's the only argument I think you just got lucky that game and you're townie then.

On January 22 2013 03:22 Vivax wrote:


Cool, why did you lie then?

On January 22 2013 17:06 Oatsmaster wrote:
Toad, just to make it easier to read, do you mean
Character Treats where treats mean
An event or item that is out of the ordinary and gives great pleasure.
or Character Traits where traits mean


A distinguishing quality or characteristic, typically one belonging to a person.

On January 22 2013 09:34 Vivax wrote:


+ Show Spoiler +

I took a look at what reads he meant.

Written by gonz very early, probably not serious:

+ Show Spoiler +

Here gonzaw says the same thing JX said later about me. We could interpret this as one of the reads JX was agreeing with.
It's also pretty interesting that austin and gonzaw share the same preference for stutters. Should be scrutinized.

+ Show Spoiler +

In summary, it looks like JX trusted gonzaw and his reads at the time. Among those, he preferred to comment on me rather than stutters or sandro.

However, in the next post:


+ Show Spoiler +

He's implying that both me and sandro were attacking him cause he's weak and suspecting us rather than responding directly to the points sandro made.
Telling us, the (scum)reads from gonzaw he agrees with, to "chill" lol.

I would rather expect a townie with us as scumreads to become suspicious of both of us here, not to write that we're just omgusing him as his defence.
He also says he doesn't want me as mayor, later he will say he would vote for me based on what Toad said.
+ Show Spoiler +

Okay. He agrees with gonzaws' reads, so he should find me, sandro and possibly stutters scummy. Yet he asks Toad a question about...gonzaw himself? Why? He knows he agrees with him, why is he asking information about him and not me or stutters?

As you see in the first post in this quotechain, Oats asked Toad about sandrobas reluctance to run for mayor.
Toad replied that he already wrote it (he wrote that it's troublesome that sandro's not running but later, that he still wants him elected even if he doesn't want it).

Now, JX doesn't care about that exchange, he asks Toad if sandro is bullshitting or feeling lazy (which is a strange question to ask about someone you should find concerning). All the while ignoring what has already been written about him.

These two are the sort of random stuff scum asks to look useful. Detached from their line of thought/set of reads.
More or less like this one in the second post after:

+ Show Spoiler +

He asks Toad another random question after he answered the previous one with this:

+ Show Spoiler +

As you see, Toad says sandro doesn't look like town sandro.

JX just asked him a question about sandro, gets a semi-null read as response, and doesn't give a fuck about it (I assume sandro would be his current suspect if he's asking questions about him and agrees with gonzaw).
He also doesn't ask why Toad doesn't want to talk about gonzaw.

No. He goes on to ask a question about a debears being talked about by austin.To which Toad replied:

+ Show Spoiler +

JX -again- never expanded on Toads' answer. What did he ask them for then?

+ Show Spoiler +

And subsequently he doesn't give a fuck about anything he was agreeing about with gonzaw earlier, yet he still wants him for mayor in a later post.

Then this here is also pretty scummy, but it's rather subjective:

+ Show Spoiler +

Would you say this to someone you think could be scum?

On January 22 2013 02:58 debears wrote:


Unless the mafia sub in for both bodyguards, the sheriff and mayor cannot be nked until the bodyguards are taken down. That means that we should place good town players who are likely to get nked in the mayor and sheriff spots.

Vivax is not by any means a player at threat of being nked as town. He doesn't have good reads.

Austin and Gonzaw are two players that are nk targets as town and have good reads from what I have heard. I'd say either of them is a good choice for sheriff, with Gonzaw preferred

On January 23 2013 02:32 JieXian wrote:
gonzaw : Started out good but ended up babbling to himself and giving empty promises. Don't trust him with reads and may be scum