So, maybe I'm insane but that was a double scum claim from cross, no?

he 1) did two damage to everyone which as I already explained is a scum claim and he 2) didn't read the thread where I said that since he still did it, also a scum claim. (obviously mutually exclusive but either he knew it was anti-town and played it anyways or he didn't read the thread and knew it because he was scum)

can anyone, cross included, point out any flaws in this argument? I think we'll be killing him today.

p

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:37 GMT

#1120

Everybody claim what creatures you can put out, how much damage you can do, and what other cards you have that can make it easier to kill Xfire

I have :

3 Chain Lightning-> 9 damage
Use Grim Lavamancer, tap him, deal 2 damage
Thus total 11 damage (forgot I had GL lol)

Alternatively, I have Unearth I can cast for 1 black mana; and put Dark Confident or Spark Elemental in the field.
Have Keldon Marauders as well, and Reckless Abandon

Someone that is good with MTG tell me how to use this cards to better kill Xfire

I don't give a shit about outing our hands, we should kill confirmed scum today.

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:38 GMT

#1121

You are slow Prome

Of course it's a scum claim

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:39 GMT

#1124

He's at 30

Also I fucked up, I can't use 3 CL AND Grim L.

I'll try to see if I can figure out a way to deal maximum damage...

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:40 GMT

#1125

Also, I concede: Apparently your case was indeed better than mine (since you made scum out himself)

GG Clock

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:41 GMT

#1126

Anyways, no matter what happens we are still in a better position than town was in the previous game lol

Rock, will you use your other "useless permanents" for something?
We can use it to destroy that Goblin card of his so he can't block with it

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:43 GMT

#1129

we'll max out at 9 damage. Everyone note that his new shaman gives him one life every time you play a creature he'll gain 1 life. Make sure any creature you put into play will do at least one damage to him.

Everyone pile on!

we can also attack with GL, like attack for reals.

P

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:45 GMT

#1134

Wait

Xfire was at 12 health
He gains 2*number of players (besides him of course)
That's 8*2 = 16

So 12+16=28

So where did he get 2 additional HP?

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:46 GMT

#1135

well we can do 10, not nine. The G-man forgot our Grim Lavamancer can actually attack.

p

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:46 GMT

#1136

On February 01 2013 08:45 Clockwork Hydra wrote:
Anyways, we can (and will) do 11 damage (provided he doesn't block)

Gonzaw can do 9.

rock(?) said he can do 2.

So we're 8 damage short atm. Did i miss any potential damages? I sure hope i did

We can do 10, we have GL.

Although that goblin needs to die first, we don't want him blocking our nice GL

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:52 GMT

#1143

Okay, this game is kind of solved:

Bin: Basically confirmed town since scum is so desperate to kill him (and most likely will next turn with the mafia beast, unless someone can heal him)
Rock: Basically confirmed town for being here, and taking out Soul Warden that easily without putting up a fight. If he was scum there'd be no reason for scum Xfire to "claim scum" and take out Warden if Rock would just instantly take it out
He's also making sense here and trying to get Xfire to have EVEN LOWER HEALTH, so yeah no.
Clock: Pretty likely town, for the case, for pushing Xfire in early D1, for being active, for trying to scumhunt all freaking game, etc
Suck: Likely town because marv is townie, acts like townie, etc what I said before

So that leaves Nova, Stutters and Aperture

Now Aperture....would you like to continue to pursue the "1 hydra is surely scum" idea? If so then please attack yourself thank you

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:54 GMT

#1146

BUT ARTANIS

Xfire had 7 HP last night! Not 11!
Are you sure you made the math right? Come on, put him at 23!

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:54 GMT

#1147

Damn, I wish I had attacked him with my little GL instead of Appy lol.

Anyways, we can find solace in the fact Xfire attacked his scumbuddy for 2 HP as well lol

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

January 31 2013 23:56 GMT

#1150

I propose this:

Aperture: Destroy your Braid of Fire with The Abyss and destroy Xfire's Goblin

If you do not, then you'll claim scum along Xfire

Does this seem like a good idea to enforce?

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

February 01 2013 00:00 GMT

#1153

I still await Nova and Stutters and Suck, they could have the key to the missing 4 KP!

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

February 01 2013 00:02 GMT

#1156

Yeah but that card of his is useless to kill Xfire and he doesn't need to pay mana to use the global card :/

So why not force the scummy guy to handicap himself instead of you for instance (since you can use your other permanents for something else in the future)?

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

February 01 2013 00:03 GMT

#1157

On February 01 2013 09:01 Crossfire99 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Me too. It might be hard to get him to do it because he totally wasn't around when I wanted to talk with him. Why do you think I attacked Bin. That was the only person I know he for sure wanted to die because he made a case on him.

So Xfire, you attacked Bin?
Hmm, but you didn't attack yesterday!!
This is a contradiction!!

Explain yourself Xfire! You are town right? If you are town you should have an explanation for this!
Also, you could start contributing if you don't want us to kill you!
Post who you think is scum!

/G

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

February 01 2013 00:04 GMT

#1159

Shh! I'm pressuring him!

If he's town he'll surely contribute now!

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

February 01 2013 00:06 GMT

#1163

Can you post your QT Xfire?

I swear I won't tell anybody
Unless....it's the same QT MIDNIGHT POSTED THE OTHER DAY AND YOU ARE "SCUMBUDDY"!!!!

IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW

(DontFear)ThePoster

Guernsey584 Posts

February 01 2013 00:07 GMT

#1164

If we can't kill Xfire today, then we should destroy all his permanents.
So Stutters, maybe play a creature, and we can't get the numbers to kill him, sacrifice him to destroy his Shaman (for instance)
Although I'd prefer Aperture sacrificing everything instead of other people that are likely town.

/G