kush are you really not considering that a scum could just make up a inanimate object and claim vt with it? i really don't see why you are leaning so strongly on this unconfirmed flavor theory that scum can just manipulate by claiming well.

like it's so hard for me to accept that you're playing the game based on that theroy that i'm starting to doubt the accuracy of my check

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 05 2012 22:55 GMT

#841

##unvote
#Vote hopeless1der

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 05 2012 22:57 GMT

#848

ebwop

##Vote: hopeless1der

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 05 2012 23:06 GMT

#861

lol

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 01:53 GMT

#970

acro, if we catch an sk what do we do with them? assume that catch = confirmed, just hypothetically

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 02:17 GMT

#972

the post said acro not darthpunk, oh well. guys please dont answer questions specifically directed at somebody else

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 17:19 GMT

#1008

On November 06 2012 23:50 mkfuba07 wrote:
Thrawn, when you're back, what are your current thoughts on kush?

I don't think he's scum. The chances of him being gf are small after that last flip and I don't think that'd he'd have been the optimal person to frame during N1. I am glad that a scum claimed one of kush's "vt names" so we can finally be done with that. Once he starts contributing ideas other than that I'll be able to reevaluate. Also.. it wasn't his original case, but he was the one who put the hopeless swing in motion and it neither looks like a bus or reminds me of how scum kush likes to bus.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 17:37 GMT

#1017

I do agree that there is a lot of stuff to consider for drazak's case but I'm hesitant to decide on that right now.

ATM I think kush and acro are town. As far as scum suspects other than drazak, I'm somewhat at a loss right now because we weren't really able to get discussion about the hopeless lynch, it just happened. Going through his filter didn't give me much.

For me the only thing to consider about kush has been if he's actually silly enough as town to to rely on flavor theories. Like I said in my last post, now that that's done with I'll have a chance to reevaluate him

Ok I took a break from writing this post and was staring at the votecount and I just saw that were only 2 candidates not voting for hopeless... it's kush and release. (and hopeless but you mustn't count him, he's dead) I've been playing this game under the assumption that there are 3 scum so that means that either A) kush and release are scum) or B) hopeless was bussed by at least one person

more thoughts when i'm less stoned, probably in that twilight period posting thingy

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 18:23 GMT

#1029

On November 07 2012 02:40 mkfuba07 wrote:
So I take it you didn't find it strange that despite kush's over-adherence to his flavor theory, he still found your claim to be legit even though he listed your name explicitly as one of the possible scum names?

well if he's town it's as simple as blue not being green but on the other hand,

I'm actually considering lynching into release/kush thinking that maybe at least 1 scum wasn't bussing. I have the green check on kush but I still can't rule out him being framed. All that he's really done so far is vote based off of unflipped vanilla town role claims. He also voted for, then pulled a vote off of hopeless for that theory. So the actual heart of the matter is, was his flavor voting a real town tactic or scummy kush trying to match his meta? If you've played with him before you've probably realized that his emotional attachment to this game seems much lower than in any of his previous games.

darthpunk, when you were commenting on how it was weird that the thread slowed down after the hopeless votes... what did you think was weird about it? Did it make you think hopeless was town or scum?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 22:35 GMT

#1086

acro what does my claim have anything to do with nks from N1?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 23:03 GMT

#1092

fuba you claim you blocked prom? so that means that prom was the nk target.. or he was scum carrying out the nk?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 23:06 GMT

#1095

ofc prom needs to verify the rb

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 23:17 GMT

#1097

this better not be some LC bs, for now I'm assuming that mafia didn't skip the nk.

So prom is either scum, or was the nk target. Out of those two options, prom being scum seems more likely. I don't exactly remember prom being super high on most people's townie lists.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 06 2012 23:18 GMT

#1099

mkfuba real quick tell me what you think is more likely...

prom is scum
prom was nk target
mafia withheld nk

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 07 2012 00:04 GMT

#1104

release, you think that acro claimed mason while knowing that muso was town? seems too crazy

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 07 2012 00:17 GMT

#1109

On November 07 2012 09:07 Release wrote:
Yo. I was roleblocked.

##vote drazak

His defense before the deadline wasn't tenable. avoid a mislynch?
The response that would have exonerated him (in my eyes) is that he had no reason at all, or that he was dicking around with his vote because already secured.

why did you change your mind on drazak? because he didn't respond by some arbitrary time?

you said a lot of words during n1 about how acro is scum, and you specifically said that acro, prome, and kush are your top scumreads.

to me your drazak vote looks like you're abandoning your scumreads to sheep onto the popular vote

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 07 2012 00:33 GMT

#1113

So if he provides a tenable reason, are you open to changing your mind? Do you have any kind of response you think you're likely to believe? (obv if ur town then don't say what it could be) Your vote is up there with kush's flavor voting... just doesn't make sense imo.

BTW: if there is a town jailer then they need to claim ASAP

We have a claimed jailor (mkfuba) who claimed to rb prom
We have release who claimed getting rb'd.

That means we have potentially up to 2 roleblocks last night.

If you are town jk and you rb'd release, you should claim.

edit ok wtf now kush is claiming rb. so that's 3 potential rb's. Anyone that rb'd either kush or release should probably claim, especially if you are 1 shot. (or just pretend you're 1 shot in order to wifom mafia)

sorting this out could end up leading to a 1-1 trade scenario

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 07 2012 00:54 GMT

#1118

I'm having the same thoughts about release's drazak vote that I had about release's early game suspicions of kush: they aren't true town suspicious. I don't buy release's drazak vote at all. On top of that, he's only gotten worse about looking inherently guilty since the last time I mentioned him.

##Vote: Release