Newbie Mini Mafia XXIX - Page 11

On October 28 2012 20:59 Alsn wrote:
Also, I'd like to point out that scum killed someone who was suspecting Djo no matter what. Both kush and sylver were outspoken anti-Djoists, even to the point where sylver looked scummy because that was the only thing he contributed to in the entire thread. I still think this is pretty sketchy territory since we don't know the motivations for why they were killed but I think we can safely assume that their suspicions of Djo probably was a deciding factor. What we need to figure out is whether or not he's being framed or not.

On October 28 2012 21:40 Dandel Ion wrote:
What Alsn said.
I don't know which one is the scum kill.
It's more likely it's Sylver, that I admit. But in no way, shape or form is it IMPOSSIBLE that Kush was the scum kp.
If I wanted to speculate up reasons for it, I could come up with some. But it would be pretty useless specuation, and most importantly, fluffing up the thread.

You unwillingness to even aknowledge the possibility that kush was scum-killed, reads to me like you have relevant information on the subject.
That's why I think you were involved in one of the kills. If you're SK, you most likely killed Kush, if you're scum, I could see a reason for you to kill either.

You're right that this lynch is pretty fucking important. That's why I don't want to waste time twiddling my thumbs like you all seem to prefer. We're already full of lurkers that probably don't read the thread more than once per day. So what rationale do you have for NOT pushing your reads early?
If you wait until right before the flip, it won't do shit, because 3/4ths of the game won't even be there.

Ergo, I think I'm pretty damn justified in pushing my read early.

On October 28 2012 22:59 Alsn wrote:
I agree that nackh's participation has been worrisome at best but other than asking him to talk I'm not sure what we can do. I suppose I wouldn't necessarily be opposed to lynching him but only if Dandel turns out to not be an option.

But we also need to consider the very real possibility that Roco gets modkilled and flips town. Sure he could be scum and hope is great and all but we can't in any way distance ourselves from the possibility that we are only 4 town left in the game.

On October 28 2012 23:08 Dandel Ion wrote:

That was not even thrawn's own meta, he was heavily coached that game.
I'd assume you coach will have told you the same thing thrawn heard.

On October 28 2012 23:36 Dandel Ion wrote:

So you WANT people to make association cases?
I'm not sure you understand how this works.


Also, if your buddies are both lurkers, that's also an explanaition for the lack of defense.

On October 28 2012 23:27 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
I have a few minutes so here are my reads:

Djo is scum or SK - I am sure of it. I have little reason to vote anyone else at this point
Dandel is leaning scummy for me; he completely avoided one of my questions:

I find this especially odd since you've advocated against using the noobie card, then proceed to use the confused card which is just as bad.

Rad is leaning town for me. Although that association case between me + Kush bore no merit at all.
Debears. Hard to tell. Pretty null, especially since we haven't heard from him in a while.
Nackhtogger. He's afk.
Roco. He's afk.
Inig. He has a few walls of text that are exactly that: Walls of text. A little scumhunting here or there but I don't see a reason that I should consider town as of yet.
Alsn. I see his case on Dandel. I agree that he looks fairly scummy at this point. But I'm sticking by my Djo lynch unless someone can seriously convince me otherwise.
I'm very interested in hearing from the two lurkers, Inig, and Debears on their thoughts on everyone including myself but especially Djo/Dandel.

To get this out of the way:
##Vote: Djodref

On October 28 2012 23:53 Dandel Ion wrote:
Yes, Master Djo.
The world revolves around you.

Well, in this game, it actually might. Considering that nobody else is playing.