EPTTL Mafia LVII - Page 91
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Mementoss
Canada2595 Posts
| ||
|
Mementoss
Canada2595 Posts
| ||
|
ShiaoPi
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5956 Posts
Probably should just do a reread on everyone as well if I can snag the time to do it | ||
|
ShiaoPi
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5956 Posts
| ||
|
grush57
Korea (South)2582 Posts
Sloosh your not being yourself Why...... :'( | ||
|
slOosh
3291 Posts
What do you think about strongandbig? | ||
|
grush57
Korea (South)2582 Posts
| ||
|
slOosh
3291 Posts
| ||
|
mkfuba07
United States1151 Posts
Why do you find Z-BosoN scummy? @Z-BosoN: I'll accept most of your responses. There are some that I would disagree with, but not many that I still feel I can consider scummy. A combination of quickly approaching deadlines, a previously scummy view of you after reading extremely quickly through the thread, a desire to save Forumite (though late, I admit), and confirmation biases contributed negatively to that last post. I've gone through it and narrowed it down to anything I still consider somewhat scummy. There's one thing that still bothers me. What made your belief in a scum vigi so much stronger than your belief in a watcher? | ||
|
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
I was basing myself on imallinson's post: On September 09 2012 06:42 imallinson wrote: I've been out all day and caught up with the thread on the bus home. The day is almost over so sorry if this is a bit hasty. I'm not buying BKE's watcher claim. First a few assumptions I'm making: 1) Mafia has one vig thus had effectively three kp night one not including GK's bomb. 2) Mafia used all their kp. Someone suggested they saved some to out blues but that seems like it would only work if pressure was being put on that blue so I think it's unlikely. 3) Mafia did not shoot Ottox. If BKE is watcher then GK must have bombed BM and shot BC without a double stack. Therefore we are missing two kp. The only way for this to happen is a combination of a medic/jailer getting a lucky save, a scum shot hit an assassin or the jailer rb'd a scum. To me this seems very unlikely because BC seems like the better bomb target and barring a medic saving BKE he should be dead. Also missing two kp feels really fishy to me. One getting blocked I could understand but two seems a little far fetched given the information available at the time (that no one apart from the two dead people seemed that town). Since I don't know this setup, I just went with his assumption. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
| ||
|
mkfuba07
United States1151 Posts
On September 12 2012 12:00 Bill Murray wrote: i really didnt want to lynch forumite. PERIOD. Then why did you vote for him? | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On September 09 2012 15:08 Bill Murray wrote: i cant believe you all lynched BKX You all need to listen to me, even if I've been drinking lightly. On September 10 2012 07:43 Bill Murray wrote: ##Vote Forumite On September 12 2012 12:00 Bill Murray wrote: i really didnt want to lynch forumite. PERIOD. Someone Vig Him. | ||
|
Maverick32x
United States311 Posts
On September 12 2012 09:23 Mementoss wrote: Shit son 8 mafia in a 26 person game. Also everything about your TOP 3 scum reads can be said about you, you have a 2 page filter and lurk just as much as shiopi, shady sands or rewok. So why doesn't the case on them apply to you? Read ShiaoPi's filter.... All of his posts are like he is just side-commenting on the 'meta' of the game, as opposed to actually digging into it. So few of them have any substance. Shady is similar in that he isn't digging into the game. There is just nothing there? I don't know how I can be clearer... This whole "you're stupid town" seems more like an effort to discredit me than anything else... As for the copious amount of scum in my last post- yes, but those are who I have strong reads on currently. Voting for ShiaoPi once day hits. | ||
|
ShiaoPi
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5956 Posts
I was asked about my read on you, it is stupid townie, it's not as if I haven't tried to reason with you. Seeing you ignore my answers to your (kind of silly/stupid/invalid) arguments about lurking while you are doing the same thing is just tiring for me. On the other hand I makes you more town in my eyes since I doubt that scum would be that stupid to keep tunneling me when they see that it does not stick. I can only encourage you to read my posts more clearly.... On to boson: Cannot really add more to the cases on him, without just paraphrasing what others have said already. As I might not be back before deadline let's just throw out some suspects of mine in no particular order: If toad survives tonight he better be able to offer a good explanation why he did. Seeing him as most likely to get shot. Boson: see above Bm is just being silly, seeing that the only game I played with him he got vig'ed d1 (flipped red though), I can understand the calls for policylynching him etc. what is much more annoying is his attitude after the lynches of bke and forumite, "I told you so is ridiculous if you voted him anyway. So yeah leaning scum on him Gravan and shady could very well be scum, not much to base a read on. Sadly the rest is either nullish or town-leaning so not fit to share | ||
imallinson
United Kingdom3482 Posts
On September 12 2012 09:44 slOosh wrote: ARGGHHH!!!! This game is so annoying. ShaioPi I want you to answer this one before deadline: Mav - do you think he is scum? imallinson: any reason why you decided to snip out the timestamps in this post? Because you straight up lie in quoting Z-boson's two quotes which have a whole day between this post and this post? I sniped out the time stamps because I copied just the bits of text from the post not the whole thing. As for those being a day apart I'm an idiot, I read 9:24 and 10:14 and didn't bother looking at the day. That flip makes a lot more sense given that time frame and I'm glad ZB didn't get lynched because of me messing up. | ||
|
imallinson
United Kingdom3482 Posts
On September 12 2012 07:50 Maverick32x wrote: Okay. Just read through the latest lynch... I was planning on dropping my notes but it just would look cluttered so I'm going to settle with the people that I'm REALLY sure are mafia and give my explanation for it. I am ranking them in the order of my confidence in my read. My top 3 are tied for number 1 reads. ShiaoPi - Scummy. Really scummy. DISAPPEARS when the vote comes. <- this is copied straight out of my notes that I was taking.... Honestly.. just read through his filter/posts!! There is no way this guy is town. 0. No chance. I think he voted Z-Boson because he knew it would be a throw-away vote. Shady Sands- just scummy. Hard defends Shiao. Argues with Hapa (town). DISAPPEARS when the vote comes. <- So similar to the play style of ShiaoPi and there seems to be some really slight buddying occurring. He continues to live in "Matthchew" land and never seems to snap into the current thread which kind of shows me a lack of understanding. His most recent attack on Gravan to be honest is just an attempt to push an early vote while scum is being successful. Rewok- side steps responsibility constantly. He has ONE PAGE OF FILTER. (@!#*(@!* So either awful town, or scum. DoYouHas Mementoss- Totally uninvolved. Voted me besides it having zero impact on the game. Scummy. His ONE saving grace is that he repped DoYouHas... the only problem with that is DoYouHas was kind of scummy.... and Mementoss is doing just about nothing to save that... Also Shady's 'coin flip' indicates that one of his options is scum... and its Mementoss. Toadesstern- Random poker talk? Discusses roles bit. Rustles up the forumite case based off a different game. Makes an interesting accusation that either Grush OR sandy is scum… makes me think Grush is likely town and Shadey is scum based on my reads above. Defends Shady shortly after that "Or" post and soft attacks him same post indicating some sort of ambivalence about being too closely connected. DISAPPEARS when its voting time, even though he kind of was a major advocate of the Forumite lynch at the start..... slosh- posts late. Softly attacks forumite. References past games a lot. Afks most of the game when discussions are getting active. Gets active on Forumite then gone. He references that scum's plan is likely to lay low.. which is exactly what he is doing. So there you have it. It will take a miracle from God to get me to vote anyone but those top 3. The bottom 3 have some leverage to work with, but not much. Does anyone else find this post really off. His 'top 3 scum reads' is just a list of lurkers there isn't anything substantive to go on. By now there should be more to build a case on than 'disappearing around the vote'. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
im clear town, as i would have killed austinmc n1 if i was mafia PERIOD | ||
| ||
