TL Mafia LVII - Page 14

On September 22 2012 23:08 DarthPunk wrote:


I thought I was scum BM? Isn't that why you voted for me instead of your town read allison? And shiao's 'agenda' was to get me lynched no matter the evidence or what I said.

On September 04 2012 19:55 Bill Murray wrote:
ahhh, man, i just thought I could clear blackmamba and myself via vigilante talk...
i just realized MAFIA HAVE A VIG TOO? ASSUMING it's in the game
i was looking to see if we had a double lynch, but then i guess i should be just trying to break the setup. it would require people to go out on a limb, and I don't want that yet, so i won't propose any ideas until we have consolidated better

current lynch: Mattchew - Reasoning: Claimed a role he can't possibly know he is...
100% logical - 50% he's trolling? doubtful. Positive chance of lynching mafia. If he was blue, I feel like he would have claimed by now. If not, well, he's not playing to the town, and he's showboating... nobody likes a showboat.
Maverick had a bad defense of Mattchew's claim. Now, this wasn't just defending Matt for him to build cred, it was defending a claim that any sane person who was a part of this town would be all over. If he's town, I don't want him in lylo. I urge the vig to take action tonight... maybe even an n-word. This guy could easily be a ninjuitsu. awful. Mafia claiming townie is one thing, but who wants to be in a position of the town we are a part of having to let people off.......?

weigh in on this theory: townies who are found visiting people as nosy neighbors claim tracker?

new FoS presented: Hapahauli. Milton catches him using the word scummy in a way you'd not want to use as town. Admitting something you've done is scummy is one thing, like I did, but the way Hapa used this makes me want to scream scum. His interaction with my 1st suspect Doyouhas is also pretty bad.

Doyouhas looks like he is bussing mattchew to me. He tried to get a quick wagon on a good player (me) who is also a policy lynch (i am... i lurk... play scummy as shit as town... etc) seems like something someone would do with a scum agenda.

Too long, didn't read: FOS Hap, Mav, DYH from thread
prefer to lynch Hap tomorrow ... vig on mav as BlackMamba said

On September 04 2012 18:38 goodkarma wrote:
So Mattchew is a liar who made an impossible role-claim as scum. This is the easiest scum day one lynch I've seen in a mafia game .

##Vote: Mattchew


But we still should be trying to create a pro-town environment going into day two. Along those lines:

The guiltiest lurkers are listed as follows, in no particular order:
Gravan, austinmc, imallinson, Strongandbig, Miltonkram

I look forward to hearing more from these people in particular. That being said, you can expect from me tomorrow afternoon (~12 hours from now) a case writeup highlighting my current scum reads.


Good night all, and congrats on an easy day one .

On September 22 2012 23:19 DarthPunk wrote:
You seem really desperate BM. Grush Voted for SCUM you did not. You had a town leaning on Allison and were the only person who did not vote for her.

This is my third ever game. Of course I am unaware of your meta. I gave you the benefit of the doubt at the start. That has now gone. It is LYLO. I am not going to think you are innocent based on your meta only.

On September 22 2012 23:25 DarthPunk wrote:


I have no doubt that you have more than enough games by now that you could present your meta in any way that you wish. I do not think you are stupid BM. I think you are very fucking good at this game. Unlike Shiao Pi I do not dismiss you as a troll nor underestimate you. I think that your meta is very carefully crafted and that it serves your interests. I think your play this game has been deliberate and careful in your own way. The only scum you have voted for is Matt. When it didn't matter. You voted for shady instead of S&B which threw your vote away in a very close vote. You DIDN'T VOTE FOR ALLISON. Any other person and this would no longer be a discussion. But you are very good at this game. So now it is.

Anyway.

Who out of Grush and myself do you believe to be scum and why?

On September 22 2012 23:29 DarthPunk wrote:


WIFOM. Useless. and I will continue to ignore this as I have done when I first saw it.

On September 22 2012 23:28 DarthPunk wrote:


Exactly.

On September 22 2012 23:31 DarthPunk wrote:
BM. I am not going to read every game you were in so that your meta can clear you or whatever. You obviously sacrifice your town play for your scum play. And so everyone gives you the benefit of the doubt when you roll scum. I am not. Your meta will not sway me.