|
On July 17 2012 04:47 s0Lstice wrote:austin I want to hear from you on this. what do you think of Milton's point Show nested quote +On July 17 2012 03:27 Miltonkram wrote:
Regarding the case on talismania, I'm really uncomfortable about it. There's a lot in his filter that I find strange such as his obsession with his D1 plan and his subpar case-making. The thing that gives me pause is the fact that he continued commenting on his plan despite getting a ton of shit for it. I realize this is completely different from what I was saying earlier, but the fact that he followed his plan through to completion, whether or not it was a good plan in other people's eyes, gives me the impression that he thought it was a good plan. His D1 plan counts as a townie point in my book.
Fun answer - The last time I saw milton post that he was getting pre-lynch jitters, we lynched scum and he was scum as well. 2/3 down! Also, I'm MORE uncomfortable with the fact that Gonzaw was right about low vote counts and we had 4 people that hadn't voted 44 hours into a day phase.
Real answer - I guess I fundamentally disagree with Milton here, because he references talis as making a "plan." Again, I have been struggling with talis's calling gauging reactions his true plan, and then saying that it was not planned from the beginning. Nobody, milton, talis, or otherwise, has really commented on that from what I remember, and I believe I brought it up both D1 and D2. If you look at talis's comments as contradictory, then there hasn't been a "plan" to stick to, and I don't love that milton doesn't even touch that possibility.
Like...seriously. Do people think I'm wrong about those statements being contradictory? Does that indicate a townie talis? Do people agree with me but think it doesn't matter?
|
If you don't want to vote for talis, then who DO you want to vote for?
|
Got back from work, power out. Going to be semi-inactive this evening until it returns, but will.check phone some.
Hope everyone's wrists and friends improve.
|
Ugh, setup talk again? Stay away Gonzaw! Stay away!
The unintelligible zergtalk in the setup is nice flavor, but makes it difficult to know exact roles. Can framers target scum and make them look town?
|
gg talis.
On July 15 2012 10:19 austinmcc wrote:Show nested quote +On July 15 2012 09:50 gonzaw wrote:
I'd like people to come in and state what they want this D2 (i.e who they want to lynch, which player they want more info from, stuff like that). If not we'll be like last day where it was 5 hours before the deadline and nobody had any idea of what to do. (1) not have gonzaw speculate about setup CHECK(2) lynch scum CHECK(3) currently would most like to lynch matt/talis, perhaps drop/solstice as other options CHECK(4) would like more info from ... dear lord, everyone?
Numbers 1, 2, and 4 still hold true for tonight and tomorrow. Will be revisiting 3. I really wish we'd had a more chatty day, had multiple players, too many to be scum, inactive the day away. No bueno for town-o.
|
The hammer is my penis. SnB changes his vote from dropbear to talis and was the hammer.
On July 17 2012 04:50 strongandbig wrote:
Hmm, I guess I'll change my vote to talismania. I should put my money where my mouth is, and I haven't been too convinced by the defences so far.
I still think s0lstice and dropbear look scummy though.
##unvote
##vote: talismania
On July 17 2012 06:28 Risen wrote:
I'm really sdorry guys I've been with my friend in the hospital all day. I did a quick read through and I'll be voting talismania based solely upon my town reads voting for him. I have no case and I'm really sorry guys,.
##vote talismania
Also, s0L I like how you bring up something I later took back about Mattchew. He went from being town in my eyes to scummy based on his posting style. Is there a reason you're trying to make it look like I'm defending Mattchew when I'm actually calling him scum?
|
Matt, I see the case on gonzaw. I appreciate you pushing talis yesterday. I'm still kind of wary of your D1, sorry, but the whole posts vs. actions thing is still in my head.
You ended up not posting on sciberbia. I'd like to know what made you think he was scummy before talis's flip. Like, you voted him D1, gave reasoning. You let him be while still finding him scummy until N2, then decided he was town for pushing talismania. What happened in the meantime that made you keep finding him scummy?
|
gg all. Really enjoyed this game so far. So come on town, mason-buddy, carry it home cuz I haven't won a game yet!
|
|
|
gg all.
Note to self: never second guess a scumread based off Ace advice.
|
On July 21 2012 07:37 sciberbia wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2012 07:33 Keirathi wrote:From Mason QT: sciberbia wrote:
Will anyone ever take the hint and fakeclaim... As a VT, getting yourself killed at night isn't such a bad thing
I thought about it. Too much of a risk when I don't know who the real Mason is though. I felt like whoever was mason was waiting to claim in the hopes that someone would fake-claim and they could get them lynched. I was pretty sure you were Mason (hence why I said I was 95% sure you were, and then accidentally said your name in the heat of the argument with Risen), but I didn't know what your feelings were towards me. If I fake-claimed, you probably would have outed me and wasted a mislynch. yea I guess it would have been risky :/ i should've explicitly hinted or something. you couldn't know how I would react. For the record, mason QT blows scum QT out of the water! Fuck yea! Was really fun austin. Couldn't have asked for a better role or mason partner Yup yup, enjoyed it. Much better than getting masoned with scummy ol' marv for a couple days. I keed.
Gonzaw, I liked your post N3 about what the possible third scum role could be, and what it meant for various claims.
Sorry all for my weird play D1. I seriously just got flustered or something, and then just kept digging myself deeper and deeper. The moment I felt I looked scummy, the more concerned I got with trying to boost my towniness, and it made me look awful. Hopefully I came back looking normal on N1 and D2.
Also, thanks bugs for hosting, and for providing thoughts in obs.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
