Movie Star Mini Mafia! - Page 41

On June 27 2012 01:04 marvellosity wrote:
I'd shoot VE because town doesn't have the balls to lynch him. Snarfs is lynchable.

On June 27 2012 01:02 rastaban wrote:

I feel like claiming Vig was the safest claim for mafia since there is no way to disprove it with a night situation as it can be blocked and there is no second chance like a normal blue role would have where you force mafia to take care of it.

On June 27 2012 01:19 VisceraEyes wrote:
Okay, well ignore me guys - going active lurking for a bit whilst I read Marv's filter armed with the knowledge that later in the game, THAT GUY IS CLAIMING VIG.

Stay tuned.

On June 27 2012 01:26 rastaban wrote:
Snarfs huge post on zephirrd just before he died seems a bit strange. Mafia would have known the kills were off and probably scrambling to get it rectified instead of writing a giant argument against someone when they knew the NK post was off. I find it hard to see him as mafia at this point.

On June 27 2012 00:17 marvellosity wrote:
His argument is thusly:

He's played this was as town before, so he can't be town!
He's not played this way as scum, so I'm going to ignore that fact and say he must be scum!

Logic fail.

On June 27 2012 01:30 Snarfs wrote:

Actually, my argument is thusly:

Premiss 1: He was recently mislynched as town
Premiss 2: If he's town he'd be more worried about being mislynched because of (1)
Premiss 3: He is not acting like he's worried about being mislynched
Conclusion: Not town.

Premiss 1 is verifiable
Premiss 2 is hard to dismiss on the basis that your mislynch contributed to us losing the game and I don't think that you like losing games.
Premiss 3 is reflected in your "I'm actually playing a scummy town game" defense.

---

@risk.nuke: You say VE is the towniest town that ever towned. Marv says he's going to kill VE if you let him live. You say that marv should be left alive. What? Now that's a logic fail.

On June 27 2012 01:32 risk.nuke wrote:
Like marv gets to be in charge of who he shoots...

On June 27 2012 01:33 marvellosity wrote:


This game is fun.

Premise 1: I never play scummily as scum
Premise 2: I therefore never get lynched as scum
Premise 3: Therefore I would not put myself in this position

Premise 1 is verifiable
Premise 2 is verifiable
Premise 3 is reflected in this game.

BUT, you dismiss the scumplaying marv argument, and only stick to the townplaying marv argument. Scum.

On June 27 2012 01:33 marvellosity wrote:


This game is fun.

Premise 1: I never play scummily as scum
Premise 2: I therefore never get lynched as scum
Premise 3: Therefore I would not put myself in this position

Premise 1 is verifiable
Premise 2 is verifiable
Premise 3 is reflected in this game.

BUT, you dismiss the scumplaying marv argument, and only stick to the townplaying marv argument. Scum.

On June 27 2012 01:47 Snarfs wrote:

But if nobody expects you to play scummily as scum, then that's the perfect scum play T_T.

On June 27 2012 01:37 marvellosity wrote:
Remember in Magic, Matt, when you ended up sheeping me on Zealos despite not believing your read? How I worked out Hiro was red and I called Katina scum?

When I flip, sheep me.