Bastard Mafia 2 - Page 54

On June 20 2012 05:27 talismania wrote:
Well I think I'm probably wrong because it feels like the kind of thing I would be wrong about. Like too crazy to be true etc.

The hypothesis/conspiracy theory is that Nisani is actually the Monarchist Activist. He made KharadBanar king for some reason. The king gets to decide the lynch with the "hello X smiley face" thing. (I don't buy that KB typed that because he was saving Nisani from the vengeful townie thing - he had already unvote-voted after nisani's vote and said nothing then. This was done after fourface's vote, and kb was aware that he was just vote-unvoting for fourface as you can see from the thread).

KB was so willing to be the last vote on dropbear because he knew that even if dropbear was a vengeful townie it wouldn't matter because he knew he was king and actually got to decide the lynch. In fact he might have even figured that dropbear was scum faking his claim (knowing about the king mechanic), and didn't want him to die because it would increase his chances of surviving longer (more kp at night, another lynch distracted). KB probably saw that Nisani was similarly unconcerned about dying, and figured that nisani must know about the king mechanic, and figured him for the Monarchist Activist. Therefore he tried to meet his first wincon by lynching him, even if it meant he would likely not be around to meet his other wincon.

Unbeknownst to KB, the king actually can't lynch the MA. It's like my dayvig power. I couldn't have shot the king - I would have died instead. If the king tries to lynch the MA, the king dies instead. This also fits with KB's death post "Zephirdd PM'd me the whole story" implying that there's a "whole story" and that KB was surprised more than usual by his death.

Nisani being MA also fits with his claim of a "crazy role" and of having extra wincons and extra losscons. He loses if he is killed, and he loses if town loses. He wins if town wins and... something else? The king is never killed? He survives to the end? Dunno. But it seems like it would be the kind of role where that would fit.

On June 20 2012 05:32 strongandbig wrote:
Talis, I think that KB didn't know he was the king. He changed his vote to himself and thought nisani would die from the vengeful townie thing. However, in actuality whoever the king votes for gets lynched. KB voted for himself, so he died.

This is pending a response to my question above. If the answer is "his vote was too late" then I'm wrong. If there is no answer then I think I'm right.

I also think fourface gets informed who the king is each day, and knows kb was the king and that's why he keeps insisting that the king dies, which is retarded.

On June 20 2012 05:33 strongandbig wrote:
And as soon as you said "I think I know what you are" the nisani-as-MA theory popped out to me too.

On June 20 2012 05:38 FourFace wrote:
strongandbig is behaving most scumishly. And you talis should also stop making inquiries about the identity of the MA. Only AMA want to know who the MA is and since the AMA are 3rd party you could be one of them even because you killed a scum

On June 20 2012 05:32 strongandbig wrote:
Talis, I think that KB didn't know he was the king. He changed his vote to himself and thought nisani would die from the vengeful townie thing. However, in actuality whoever the king votes for gets lynched. KB voted for himself, so he died.

On June 20 2012 05:46 HiroPro wrote:


Hm, this might be the right explanation. The only thing is, why would the MA pick KB....