Bastard Mafia 2 - Page 40

On June 19 2012 07:39 Acrofales wrote:

No. Because it would tell you your scumbuddies and Talismania would NOT be among them, therefore with that wording you would be completely safe.

On June 19 2012 07:38 Drazerk wrote:


I just copied what he gave me

On June 19 2012 07:40 Acrofales wrote:

I missed that. Okay, that means we learned even LESS than I thought from that pointless exercise in futility.

On June 19 2012 07:34 deconduo wrote:


As I said I'm pretty sure all 3 of us are town, assuming talis actually uses his shot before we all die of old age.

On June 19 2012 07:41 deconduo wrote:


If you think we learned nothing you really need to learn how to play mafia.

On June 19 2012 07:39 Drazerk wrote:


That logic makes no sense

On June 19 2012 07:47 Acrofales wrote:

It does. If you were scum and Tali were town, you would know Tali is not on your scumteam and hence probable town. A tiny bit of looking at the thread would make that even more probable. Now lets go back to the logic:

Statements:
A = drazerk is town
B = deconduo is town
C = talismania is town

Theory:
A & B & ~C

Theory is FALSE, so we know:

~(A & B & ~C)
= ~A | ~B | C

This statement is true if any one of the following is true:
~A = Drazerk is not town
~B = Deconduo is not town
C = Talismania is town

Because you would already know C, that would make it completely safe for you.

If it's still not clear, replace "Talismania is not town" in the checked post with "Pigs can fly". Because pigs can, in fact, not fly, anything else in the post is irrelevant: it will be marked as false.

However, this is all academic, because Deconduo derped even more than I thought and we learned NOTHING from the whole ordeal.

On June 19 2012 07:47 Acrofales wrote:

It does. If you were scum and Tali were town, you would know Tali is not on your scumteam and hence probable town. A tiny bit of looking at the thread would make that even more probable. Now lets go back to the logic:

Statements:
A = drazerk is town
B = deconduo is town
C = talismania is town

Theory:
A & B & ~C

Theory is FALSE, so we know:

~(A & B & ~C)
= ~A | ~B | C

This statement is true if any one of the following is true:
~A = Drazerk is not town
~B = Deconduo is not town
C = Talismania is town

Because you would already know C, that would make it completely safe for you.

If it's still not clear, replace "Talismania is not town" in the checked post with "Pigs can fly". Because pigs can, in fact, not fly, anything else in the post is irrelevant: it will be marked as false.

However, this is all academic, because Deconduo derped even more than I thought and we learned NOTHING from the whole ordeal.

On June 19 2012 07:45 strongandbig wrote:


There is a good chance all three are town.

However - none of you are 100% confirmed, which you could be.

I was just thinking about this again. Look at it using logic.

If one of the statements is false, then knowing that the overall statement is false, gives us literally no information about the other two statements.

Based on the way you all acted around the time of the statement, I think you are town.

However, either Talismania or Drazerk could be scum. Look at their actions:
- Drazerk was being a troll and a moron, and hadn't read his PM apparently. Therefore, his actions give us no information about his alignment.
- Talismania wouldn't just post the thing you wanted him to, even though it was painfully obvious what was going on.

Other than that, I think Talismania is probably town, but he or Drazerk could still be scum.

On June 19 2012 07:51 talismania wrote:


Statement C was "talismania is not town" btw.

It's clear to me that deconduo should be town unless he's really dumb. Drazerk did initially write three statements that said he was town, dec was town, and I was a day vig, but deconduo did not elect to do that, and instead made him type what he did. Drazerk's statement if checked would have been incredibly incriminating against him had it come back a lie, and I would have shot him. So it makes the most sense that he is town as well.

On June 19 2012 07:56 Drazerk wrote:
Who ever you shoot I am placing a 30 min clock on it T_T