TL Mafia LV - Page 129

Post a Reply

Prev 1 127 128 129 130 131 158 Next

Hyaach

Singapore1737 Posts

June 06 2012 14:39 GMT

#2561

On June 06 2012 22:59 Toadesstern wrote:

Show nested quote +

I already quoted the post 2 times...
Night 2: WBG
Night 3: Jaj22

except both are death and there is no breadcrumbs whatsoever in your filter or theirs. very very easy claim and the fact you ignore my same question for past 2 day cycles.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 06 2012 14:41 GMT

#2562

On June 06 2012 23:39 Hyaach wrote:

Show nested quote +

except both are death and there is no breadcrumbs whatsoever in your filter or theirs. very very easy claim and the fact you ignore my same question for past 2 day cycles.

I did not ignore it. I answered that question 3 times...

Manason

45 Posts

June 06 2012 14:43 GMT

#2563

On June 06 2012 23:39 Toadesstern wrote:
Actually screw everything I said about myself, about austin or about kita. We're NOT lynching kita today.

I have the most awesome plans of them all to combine all of our problems.
Kita claimed medic and mafia already lost their RB.
Here's the plan

Lynch someone who's nick is not kita (right now it looks like mana although I'd prefer maju)
I call out who I will mason at the very beginning of the night, OPENLY and I will choose to most townish looking guy around.
If kita is a town medic he will medic that dude no matter what.

Either way we're good.:

If the dude survives because they went for 2 other guys I'm not only confirmed but also mod-confirmed townie while kita remains the same as before. At the same time mafia went for 2 people who are looking not so townish which I am totally fine with.
If the dude gets hit by one shot and kita saved him Kita's good and and I am mod-confirmed although that's not going to happen because no way mafia is that stupid.
If the dude gets doublestacked Kita remains the same as before, will claim he mediced him no matter if he's town or mafia. I am still confirmed town just not mod-confirmed but we lost 1 townie instead of 2. I am very much liking that scenario as well.
If we see 2 people dead and one of them is the dude kita was suppossed to protect / I masoned he's a goner.

Can anyone see drawbacks to that plan? I like it very much atm because we're probably going to maka mafia shoot into people they don't want to shoot or make them doublestack when they don't want to.

Did you consider the situation where mafia holds back 1 kp and kita claims that he protected the guy?

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 06 2012 14:49 GMT

#2564

On June 06 2012 23:43 Manason wrote:

Show nested quote +

Did you consider the situation where mafia holds back 1 kp and kita claims that he protected the guy?

yeah I did. I like mafia holding KP back. Also both the protector and the protected get a confirmation PM.
If Kita claims protection on the dude and he says "nah, didn't happen" we have a mafia between those 2 100% sure. I like that as well.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 06 2012 14:51 GMT

#2565

You realise that if you didn't choose Probulous you'd be leaving our dt out to dry, right?

Meapak_Ziphh

United States6786 Posts

June 06 2012 14:52 GMT

#2566

people need to shut up about toad lol.

Seriously people, occam's razor. This is making a couple people look really bad right now.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 06 2012 14:53 GMT

#2567

Yeah I wanted to choose him. Or you in case something really weird like grabbing tornados happens. But in general yeah prob.

If they doublestack him, whatever we lost a DT but we only lost one guy.

Manason

45 Posts

June 06 2012 14:57 GMT

#2568

I like this plan I'm remove my vote on Kita

##Unvote: Kitaman27

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 06 2012 14:57 GMT

#2569

The only problem I see with the plan is that it's not telling us a thing about kita BUT it forces mafia to either shoot people they don't want (lika kita in case he's town) OR to doublestack OR to not use their full KP.

We can repeat that plan for all I care until their KP is down to 1 or we lost Kita because I only see benifits without drawbacks right now.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 06 2012 15:34 GMT

#2570

Who would be willing to Vote Maju instead of Manason and Kita?

On June 06 2012 09:07 MajuGarzett wrote:
##Vote: Manason

On June 06 2012 22:18 Hyaach wrote:
## unvote : kitaman27
##vote : Manason

On June 06 2012 22:19 papapanda wrote:
##Vote: Manason

I really don't like those guys :p
Yeah I still think all three of Kita, Maju and Mana will flip mafia but if we stick to my plan we want Kita alive and this vote pattern looks troublesome to say the least..

So we don't have much time. Can we get 8 peopleo on Maju? If it comes to it I'll happily vote for anyone between those 3 to ensure a lynch but I'd like to go with the best solution right now.

Oh and if someone sees a flaw in my plan please talk about it, I'm awesome but I'm not perfect and I could have missed something.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 06 2012 15:51 GMT

#2571

Ok I just heard tomorrow is a holiday and the only thing I got on fridays is a stupid analysis lecture I can watch online anyways.

SOOO I'm going to my parents place again, which means I won't be hear for the next 2 or 3 hours. Make a lynch happen, preferably a Maju lynch. Will be back in a couple of hour to see what's possible and what's not and adjust what I'm doing with my vote according to what I see :p

austinmcc

United States6737 Posts

June 06 2012 16:02 GMT

#2572

That plan also requires being very sure on the lynch target, because you're also passing up the kita or MZ lynch for a lynch on another player. For now, I'm sticking with my read on kita/MZ--we've had a lot of almost-kita lynches, and a lot of dead players being very suspicious of kita. The claim barely saves him, but doesn't confirm him like he wants it to. As to MZ, I can post some suspicions if needed, but frankly I'd rather others come to their own conclusion because I look a little tunneled in right now and would rather see if others find him suspicious.

Apart from that, I ... don't think I dislike the plan? I haven't found anything awful about it. So I'd be willing to hop over if kita or MZ aren't going to happen. The potential for -1 KP is nice, but it's not guaranteed. I don't like that it may not confirm kita/MZ and potentially you, but that's the price we'd have to pay.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

June 06 2012 16:16 GMT

#2573

lol austin. Save the tin foil hat for the aliens :p

As for a mafia Meapak, it seems very unlikely we have a serial killer due to the number of kp each night. The only scenario I can see is if scum double stacked someone and I stopped an assassin kp on meapak (unlikely) or I saved a traitor Meapak from a mafia kp (unfortunate, but not worth considering at this point).

Manason, I think a role claim might be appropriate. Also, could you explain why you chose to ignore my question earlier regarding your experience playing mafia? I think it is relavent considering your account was created only days before the game started.

I'm still thinking Wiggles might be the best way to go. A lot of push back for a player who has been practically afk.

Manason

45 Posts

June 06 2012 16:27 GMT

#2574

On June 07 2012 01:16 kitaman27 wrote:
lol austin. Save the tin foil hat for the aliens :p

As for a mafia Meapak, it seems very unlikely we have a serial killer due to the number of kp each night. The only scenario I can see is if scum double stacked someone and I stopped an assassin kp on meapak (unlikely) or I saved a traitor Meapak from a mafia kp (unfortunate, but not worth considering at this point).

Manason, I think a role claim might be appropriate. Also, could you explain why you chose to ignore my question earlier regarding your experience playing mafia? I think it is relavent considering your account was created only days before the game started.

I'm still thinking Wiggles might be the best way to go. A lot of push back for a player who has been practically afk.

I'm vanilla town. I read it at the time and forgot to respond however the answer would be I have real life experience but never online.

Manason

45 Posts

June 06 2012 16:29 GMT

#2575

Also I'm willing to vote for maju, I trust Toad and he's been making a lot of sense recently.

##Vote: MajuGarzett

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

June 06 2012 16:29 GMT

#2576

And who is your new lynch preference now that you have unvoted me and why?

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

June 06 2012 16:30 GMT

#2577

On June 07 2012 01:29 kitaman27 wrote:
And who is your new lynch preference now that you have unvoted me and why?

Opps ninja'd. What about Toad's opinion of Maju makes sense to you?

Hassybaby

United Kingdom10823 Posts

June 06 2012 16:32 GMT

#2578

Should have voted last night....

I like the plan Toad has in place. Ofc there's also the point where a vigi should probably not shoot tonight without claiming or that will mess up any reads into the night actions.