• Log InLog In
• Register

Pick Your Power: Redux - Page 2

Post a Reply Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 17 2012 18:54 GMT #688 @The talk about mattchew: I can't see him being scum. Look at what involves mat being scum: They traded 2 roles + 1 player just to get CPR in an unknown position. No matter how you look at it it's a net loss for scum. Scum could have cpr shoot for a couple nights without doing any of this shenanigans and eventually decon would be lynched. Mattchew could dayvig anyone lurking/scummy at day 2 without much repercussion. Makes no sense for scum to invest in roles in such fashion.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 17 2012 18:55 GMT #690 @toad I didn't get mason. Someone took it above me.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 17 2012 21:59 GMT #745 @Toad What exactly is your reasoning for me being mafia? You keep saying I look weird and I'm scummy but you don't provide any reasoning. And because I didn't agree on the cpr thing being denied is not a good reason, but I'm not going to get into that, because I don't wanna flood the thread with obsolete discussion. So the facts we got so far are the following: Risk claims he didn't try for janitor. I know you said you wouldn't, but can you explain why, since you posted that you thought that role was worth denying? Marvelocity claims he didn't go for janitor nor cpr. Again, why is that? Sentinel claims he tryed janitor and didn't get it, thus vanilla. A role or bulletbill check could work in his case, narrowing it down to marv or risk, or finding out he is mafia.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 17 2012 22:33 GMT #749 @toad you are just not smart enough to realize what i posted previously is smart @palmar based on what? I see no reason to do so as of now, specially on day 1.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 17 2012 23:02 GMT #751 I actually think no lynching might be the best choice.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 10:15 GMT #804 @toad Your argument is retarded. You are spilling shit all over and not considering the game we are playing. You have been moved to my ignore list. Surely lynching sentinel would be the lesser evil in case we lynch town out of one of the 3, since he is either mafia or vanilla, but I think we can afford to have blues check into those guys (role cop checks marv / bulletbill checks sentinel) since it's day1 and we already have a dead scum. It also gives a chance for all the other blues to act. If we lynch right now it has 1/3 chance of it being great and 2/3 chance of sucking. I can't pin point who is mafia based on behavior amongst those 3 and have read nothing so far that tilts the balance onto one or the other, so I think no lynching is by far the best choice.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 10:19 GMT #805 Also if we want to deal with this today there is an easier way. Have marvel and risk role claim. We can analize the RC (if they opt to lie safely we will figure out absurd roles being picked at such high spot) and people can even CC if they get unlucky and claim something someone has.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 10:23 GMT #806 It's pretty retarded to assume sentinel would just say that for free, since he had the option of saying he didn't go for janitor in the first place. It's equally retarded that any of the others picked janitor and lied about it for no reason. So really nothing makes sense. There is sure mafia amongst those 3, but there is no way to tell which retardness is most likely imo.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 10:37 GMT #810 @palmar sounds solid. Any ideas on how to deal with the sentinel/risk/marv situation?

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 10:55 GMT #815 Okay I read the whole thing over to get the timing of the events and the less retarded explanation I can conjure is (drum roll) Marv is scum! If you look at how it happened and assume marv is mafia it makes *some* sense. Marv knew decon took cpr so he didn't have to confirm the role / waste a scum role on it. He also knew risk wasn't taking janitor and didn't expect people bellow him to try for it. So amongst the confusion of who gets the janitor role, it was the perfect opportunity to take it and get away with it. But then sentinel came in and busted him and it was too late. Marv did not expect sentinel to take it and got GG'ed.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 10:59 GMT #816 @risk It's not slim trust me. I'll gladly exchange 2 role claims for 1 more scum dead day 1.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 11:10 GMT #818 Yo palmar bro, look at my explanation and see how you like it. I'm liking it more and more by the minute.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 11:36 GMT #824 Earlier I was puzzled and nothing made any resemblance of sense, thus I thought it was better to have those checked. But now I thought about that explanation it finally makes sense, thus I'm fine with lynching marvelocity. I'd like people to comment on it.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 18:26 GMT #915 That was uber retardness picking mason at that spot, but oh well. There is another explanation I had not considered, which is sentinel is traitor. Kinda makes sense ensuring we would go in a wild chase after the other 2 players. I'd like risk to claim before I decide whom to vote.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 20:34 GMT #929 Sentinel being traitor is the best fit imo. I like the zelblade thing, he has to confirm he didn't try for dayvig/mason/janitor/cpr then we know risk is not janitor.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 18 2012 22:01 GMT #937 I gotta go out so I'm leaving my vote at sentinel.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 20 2012 13:55 GMT #1079 lol wat qatol so good

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 20 2012 21:17 GMT #1134 I'm going to post this here since the OP doesn't look like it's getting updated soon. Known info and deaths: deconduo mafia CPR Dead day 1 by dayvig mattchew risk.nuke Claimed Vigilante shot paqman marvellosity Claimed Mason -> partner is townie who tried for politician [UoN]Sentinel mafia JOAT Dead lynched day 1 Mattchew Dayvig shot deconduo zelblade Claimed VT tried for JOAT Bluelightz talismania Dead shot night1 Witch Misder PaqMan mafia vanilla shot by risk n1 (or lynched day2 =P) slOosh Toadesstern Claimed VT tried for mason Barundar Zephirdd hiro protagonist Palmar Claimed Pardoner Snarfs Qatol Jailer -> Jailed risk n1 modconfirmed sandroba VT tried for mason Probulous VT modkilled day1

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 22 2012 12:47 GMT #1246 I think barundar is the sk (he sugested the cpr mass murder thing, which seemed weird at the time, but I guess it makes sense as sk) and hiro is the mafia. @Palmar How come you are pushing me for not devoting much time to this game while you are yourself doing the same? Let me play diablo in peace.

sandroba Canada4998 Posts May 22 2012 12:58 GMT #1249 @barundar your first post saying that I was likely town and i should pick cpr.

Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All

Please log in or register to reply.