*cough*antispew*cough*
Given all that you posted itt you now want to lynch the guy who claimed seer while there hasnt been a counterclaim and his peek has been killed tonight?
It makes no sense.

There is no detective. That's why there's no counterclaim...

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:06 GMT

#494

On May 08 2012 06:06 Gummy wrote:

Show nested quote +

There is no detective. That's why there's no counterclaim...

That or the detective is one of the inactives.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:24 GMT

#496

Be more precise with your language. Are you talking about me or about tofu. Look at how the random generator works. I posted it on the previous page.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:26 GMT

#497

And why does dahdum even sign up for this thread. Presuming he's a townie he posts once a day without reading anything except the last few posts and then votes based on a reasoning, which is an incorrect recollection of the events that took place.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:42 GMT

#500

On May 08 2012 06:36 FirmTofu wrote:
Aces is the last mafia and Gummy is already dead by now.

Votes on Gummy(Need 4 to lynch):
paschl
FirmTofu
Ange777
dahdum

GG.

I didn't even read his counter-arguments because they are all Gummy flailing at town hoping to appeal to emotion.

For the record, Claw's fallacies were quite on target this game. It's a shame you all killed him instead of Gummy.

There was not a single appeal to emotion in any of my rebuttals. The only appeal to emotion was my poem for Paschl.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:43 GMT

#501

On May 08 2012 06:31 paschl wrote:

Show nested quote +

Is this another mafia claim?
I was talking about Tofu.

And how do you even know a generator like this was used? I could just aswell see him having 5-7 finished setups and rolling a dice instead of the method wikipedia uses.

How is this a mafia claim. Your proposed method also precludes double-medic.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:44 GMT

#502

On May 08 2012 03:14 AcesRequiem wrote:
All of you could be scum, seriously.

Paschl mainly because he voted for Claw when you switched your vote, Gummy. Even though you were strongly convinced Gummy was the enemy and Claw was innocent, you still voted for his lynch. I can understand this from one point, but it looks very scummy from another.

FirmTofu and Gummy you two are seriously both so confusing, however, you both bring up some fine arguments. Will look into this deeper in a moment. Gummy, why are you so sure Ange777 is maffia? Stop throwing around random accusations and please explain. I'm suspecting him aswell.

But why would we not go for a save lynch and lynch the lurker, being dahdum? We should've done this on day one for christ sake.

##Vote: dahdum

This is a waste of a vote at this point. Since the hammer doesn't come down until 8PM EDT tomorrow, I'll just try my best to refute nonsense. Even if you believe dahdum is Mafia, tofu is the surer bet.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:46 GMT

#503

As a sidebar, it seems like the only way to make this game sufficiently fun/hardcore for my tastes is to put some money on the line so people actually care enough to read and critically engage with posts. Given that the day is 48 hours, that should give plenty of time to anybody committed to this game to do a good job.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:52 GMT

#505

Wrap-up for a few hours:

@paschl: Do a filter of Tofu's previous posts all the way back to when he accuses me today. Does that sound like the play of a scum or a legitimate detective. Dismissing legitimate arguments as "emotional" is a very clever way to deflect without having to say a word in response. When it comes down to logic vs. sophistry, I know you're smart enough to vote in the right direction.

@dahdum: Get your ass back in this thread and read ffs. You gave a reason for your vote that was flatly incorrect. Go back to page 6 and see how that conversation played out.

@aces: Your vote for dahdum is a waste. If you don't put it on tofu, this game is over.

@Ange/Tofu: Continue to be impressed with your play, though I recommend actually rebutting logic with logic in any subsequent non-newbie games you play!

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 07 2012 21:55 GMT

#506

On May 08 2012 06:49 Mattchew wrote:

Show nested quote +

Gummy there will be no betting or money involved

Is there a TL Mafia leaderboard or something like that? Something to motivate people to actually care about the outcome of the game? One of the things I love about TL is that members are generally quite hardcore and play to win. At least 3/9 people in this particular game (I won't mention names, but you know who you are) have not played to win, either by way of inactivity/inattention or via intentionally suboptimal play.

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 09 2012 01:30 GMT

#535

Post-game. If a medic is in play and people know that a medic is in play but don't know his identity, games I've played before center around role claims, counter-claims and then the cleared player leading the town. Unfortunately, claw made a fake medic claim, which is the best thing that the Mafia can hope for. Thus, I attacked him since that play was just wrong.

Then I turned my attention to Tofu as a result of his willingness to reveal after a medic claimed.

It seemed like this game was mostly townies making stupid decisions regarding role claims and votes, and me yelling at everybody, and then everybody getting mad that I was yelling at everybody.

Fun game. I think my next game isn't going to be a newbie mini, though. Don't know if my heart can take this!

Gummy

United States2180 Posts

May 09 2012 02:02 GMT

#542

Looks legit. I definitely made the mistake that thinking bad play = scum.

I incorrectly thought, then, that hunting bad play was equivalent to hunting scum.