TL Mafia LIV - Page 34

On May 06 2012 03:27 Blazinghand wrote:
Man this situation just makes me want to eat my own heart

On May 06 2012 06:46 Mementoss wrote:
Also 3rd KP could be mafia vig. At least we haven't lost any power roles yet.

On May 06 2012 06:49 Blazinghand wrote:


There are no mafia Vigis-- and a pyro wouldn't be able to kill someone until N2.

On May 06 2012 06:48 Blazinghand wrote:
Yeah, I shot Palmar. He looked like scum to me. I gave him the benefit of the doubt D1 but he didn't contribute and was silent, as scum Palmar tends to be.

Here's my crumb:



Type "eat heart of" into google search (but don't hit enter) and it'll suggest "eat heart of palm"

Palm -> Palmar, my target.

On May 03 2012 08:04 layabout wrote:
I just want to warn all of the "area 53" guys that policy lynching is no better an option in this game than it ever was before. I know that a few of you are currently feeling like we should place all lurkers and confusing posters into the fire. But the majority of those players will be town and lynching into them is likely to kill (admittedly useless) townies.
.

On May 05 2012 02:18 layabout wrote:

since we still have no real candidate
##vote Bill Murray
reasons:
anti-town when town
anti-town when scum
lurks a lot
when he is active he is disruptive

This is a policy lynch.

On May 05 2012 05:10 layabout wrote:
Katina has made posts indicative of intelligence.

I do not think we should lynch katina.

On May 06 2012 00:55 layabout wrote:
we should kill Palmar tomorrow

On May 05 2012 05:53 marvellosity wrote:


Sold, I don't have a solid scumread on anyone and BM is just useless and anti-town no matter his alignment.

On May 05 2012 02:43 marvellosity wrote:


I'm not sure you deserve an answer if you're not going to spell my name right.

At the moment Nova looks the scummiest for reasons already expanded upon by others. The fact that so little of anything has occurred today makes Nova's stance that he doesn't want to air his tentative reads all the worse.

On May 05 2012 05:04 marvellosity wrote:


Your analysis on Katina's 'lie' seems to be sound enough, the problem I have with it is that Katina generally has quite an odd posting style, so I'm not sure how much I should make of it, especially as the post in question was aimed at renowned finger-pointer BlazingHand.

On May 06 2012 07:25 marvellosity wrote:
Mementoss: cba to do a particularly long defence, but a) you've seen what I'm like before I get going in a game b) I didn't say Katina looked like scum, I said DYH's reasoning was sound but gave the reasons for my misgivings, c) I stated that Nova's scumminess lay in the fact he hadn't pushed his 'tentative' scumreads, + already explained how this did not put him into the scum category for me.

But carry on dear... you never really got over BH's tunnelling of me last game, did you?

P.S. Question for you and all of you

1) do you think layabout is a fairly intelligent reasoned player?
if yes, proceed to 2
2) do you think layabout scum would make the mistake of not advocating policy lynch and then making one on BM?

Personally my answer is no, which is why I am not comfortable on his case

On May 06 2012 07:34 Mementoss wrote:
EBWOP: This is the second time, I've had to ask/force somewhat of a scum read out of you Marvellosity. You'd think you'd want to contribute to the discussion, and actually provide them without being provoked?

On May 06 2012 07:33 Mementoss wrote:


Let me ask you a question back.

1) Do you think Marvellosity is good pro town player?
if yes, proceed to 2
2) Why did Marvellosity avoid pressuring players or committing to anything all of day 1?

Now go up and replace Marvellosity with Nova_Terra or Layabout. Added on to this, there is scummy contradictions within these cases that help add up to make me think any of the three of you could be scum. Added to the fact that Katina flipped scum, and the interactions you and Layabout had with him.

Also you are giving scum players too much credit. Did you think a scum player would last minute vote switch causing a tie and lynching the opposite person, when both players are townie?

These things happen to scum by mistake, or are just plain moves to fuck with you.

This being said, who is your biggest scum read and why?

On May 06 2012 07:41 marvellosity wrote:


There are moves to fuck with you (a la Risen) and then there is saying one thing and doing the other (as with layabout this case). Imo these two scenarios are not the same.

Re f5-ed the thread to see BH's comment - fuck you, sweetheart.

To your final question - I don't know. This is why I've prodded l10f not so long ago. Sinensis and Eiii are not far behind on who I'd like to hear a lot more from (sinensis for general quietness, Eiii because for his own reasons doesn't like talking at night, so I want him to talk more during the day).

while I'm here, Nova hasn't provided any further commentary on who he finds scummy. Personally I get where he's coming from in not wanting to push something when he hasn't got anything solid, but having stated he had reads it'd be pretty nice to hear them.

Summary: nope, no bigly strong scumread at the moment. wanna hear more from people i've not heard much from, because at the moment i only have anti-scum reads (layabout, grush)

On May 06 2012 08:32 Nova_Terra wrote:

Did you miss my thing on mementoss?