|
On April 14 2012 07:13 BroodKingEXE wrote:I thought that willz was more likely to be scum than Yomi. My thinking was that if I was wrong about either I don't want the Mafia (which could be Hiro or Trumpet to swing the vote). You couldn't really blame either of them as they have no posts so far. Swinging my vote to Yomi wasn't a bandwagon I talk about him here. I have reasons for voting for Yomi: Show nested quote +On April 12 2012 11:56 BroodKingEXE wrote:On April 12 2012 11:43 yomi wrote:
Hi I just got back from lifting.
I can't think of a more pointless discussion than the one we are having now. It is being led by Broodking, Kharadbanar, and Dittert. I have the most confidence in willz and to a slightly lesser extent arctic.
I'm not sure what we SHOULD be discussing since no investigation abilities have gone out yet, but I doubt this is it. Getting people to talk just for the sake of it is great but my fear is that this discussion will bleed into day 2 when we will have some actual information. This is your first post, yet you do nothing to contribute. Why should we stop the discussion, it seems like people are already forming opinions on people based on the "pointless" discussion. Instead of trying to stop the talk, why dont you look over what has already been said and start forming ideas about the tone of the responses. Show nested quote +On April 13 2012 11:59 BroodKingEXE wrote:
@willz at the moment I dont see anything particularly damning about your other posts, but why waste time engaging dittert? If you really think he is a newbie, then he is really no threat to you. We as a town haven't come to a consensus to vote for you. I think that yomi's baseless accusations are still more damning. This was before willz scummy post. Show nested quote +On April 14 2012 01:23 BroodKingEXE wrote:
@artic Yomi is another one of my suspects. He keeps trying to say he has contributed something, but he hasn't talked about who he accused yet. So far his only response is that he has already stated his evidence. A lot of people have been asking him for more evidence, but he hasn't been giving any. This is scummy behavior to me, but willz takes more precedence as he posted more (I want to hear a different response from him before I come to a surefire conclusion). I am not sure about the third member as I don't have any scum reads on the rest of the town, and HIro or Trumpet could very well be mafia. Show nested quote +On April 14 2012 05:29 BroodKingEXE wrote:
@Xatalos I think that Yomi is scummy, but we don't have enough to lynch him now. His latest case on dittert is shaky at best, but he hasn't spoken enough for me to draw a surefire conclusion. I think Willz and Yomi could both be scum, a Mafia could lightly defend his teammate to move suspicion off him. I agree that Willz pleading sounds pro-town, but I feel he still only has suspicions vs evidence on his suspected. I want him to build another case, because if he is a townie we need to know where to go after the night. The town might go after me, but if I flip town then four people would be dead with no leads on anyone.
The only reason I didn't immediately switch to Brood before I left to get pizza was to get some sort of response, since I gave the same chance to willz and yomi. 40 minutes is sufficient to throw something solid together. This is not solid. willz made a case against you which was really weak on the first readthrough (and it's still a lot of fluff), but it was enough for me to keep an eye on you.
I was going to push you to contribute more tomorrow after the yomi lynch. Now I don't have to wait.
##Unvote
##Vote: BroodKingEXE
Town or scum, that move was dumber than a five pound sack of stupid. It's the most obvious scum play we've seen so far.
Also -- this should show that nobody was REALLY convinced of our cases vs. yomi and willz, seeing how easily so many of us came off of them. This is how Day 1 is -- we do our best to put cases together that make sense based on our reads and analysis of what people have said. I still see yomi and willz acting scummy, and I still need to see a much better effort from them in the rest of the game (if yomi isn't just flat out vig shot tonight.)
|
On April 14 2012 07:23 HiroPro wrote:
Back from class. Going through filters for willz, yomi, and broodking. For people who are wondering why I am lurking, I sleep from 1-8 CDT and then I have classes until about 4-5 CDT, so obviously I can't post until after that. And being in different time zones doesn't help.
Your vote is pretty much irrelevant at this point, because no matter what you vote, BroodKing is set to be lynched. So don't dwell too much on your vote (it doesn't make you look either town or Mafia right now) and rather tell us what you think of the events after your last appearance. Who are your Mafia reads right now?
|
Vote SOMETHING at least to avoid the modkill...
|
Willz - I agree with his logic about trumpetarm/dittert having similar posting early on, silly to differentiate between them. Seemed very logical about the dispute between myself and vonKlaust. kind of defensive about dittert's vote on him (seems overly bothered that someone might tunnel him), (especially considering that no one else seems to agree with Dittert's general reads/ideas). I like the fact that he was against broodking's idea of concealing scum reads. When it looked like he was going to be lynched though instead of seeming defensive, he was much more helpful for town (posting his general reads and talking about targets after he flips green)
Overall, I have a null read on willz; I don't like how he was so defensive about Dittert's vote on him (and the general weird interaction with him saying I'm just trying to help Dittert out), but at the same time he does post his opinions on other people and he has a general town demeanor by focusing on making/responding to cases.
BroodKingEXE - Early on spent a lot of time discussing policy - not much to read into him from that portion of the day. Makes a vote on Dittert without much of a case (based on Dittert voting for lurkers, not really something that is overly scummy). Argument about hiding scum reads very anti-town in my opinion; without sharing those reads, town cannot make good votes. Don't really understand why he wanted to consolidate voting so early. Unvotes Dittert when Dittert starts posting again. Votes for willz saying that he is trying to shoot down other people's posts and is denying open discussion (very strange in my opinion because BroodKing himself posted something similar saying that people should not give out scum reads because mafia might kill them). Voting for yomi because he says he doesn't want mafia to switch and swing the vote (even though he says that he believes willz is more likely to be scum).
Scum read on BroodKing overall - I don't like the posts where he says not to share scum reads. The vote and case on willz is very strange, since a lot of the things he accusses willz of are similar to what BroodKing himself has been doing, and I don't really understand the vote switch onto yomi - to me it seems more like BroodKing was worried that willz was looking townie to other people and thus switched to a new target.
yomi - A lot of yomi's posting seems to be calling out various people as mafia without providing solid reasoning. I don't agree with vote on Dittert (Dittert seems much more like new town to me than mafia (RNG proposal is not really something to lynch over). Talking about ignoring various people in the thread because he doesn't like them is not town behavior at all. Yomi is scummy in my opinion.
##Vote: BroodKingEXE
|
Going to go through stuff that I missed and post my thought on those now (ignoring the stuff I just posted about willz, BroodKing, and yomi)
|
Voting has ended. Night post incoming
|
Goodbye to trumpetarn then. I'm pretty sure he is just a disinterested townie though. I agree with your points on BroodKing, HiroPro, and I also wonder why he gave up so easily and said "gg" as if he lost the game as Mafia.
|
Night 1![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/dM2z9.jpg)
Light slid into darkness as the group gathered round. It had been an exhausting day and they were all growing weary of each other's company. The knowledge that there was evil standing right before them had begun to wage psychological war within the minds of each of the contestants.
The speaker crackled to life right on queue.
GreYMisT, the host, in a powerful voice boomed out a simple question, "Who will it be?"
The contestants all quickly pointed their finger at a quiet boy standing near the back of the group, one who identified himself as BroodKingEXE.
"It is done."
Without warning arrows appeared from the dark woods and pierced the contestant's body.
Letting loose a gurgled moan, BroodKingEXE flopped forward, lifeless. As he lay there, the other participants gathered round and watched in horror as the green blood oozed from his lifeless body.
Again, the cannon sounded.
BroodKingEXE, the Vanilla Town, was lynched!
+ Show Spoiler [Role PM] +Welcome! You are a Vanilla town! You must band together with your friends to rid the town of these evil doers. You win with the town.
Day 1 Final Vote Count!
BroodKingEXE (7): yomi, KharadBanar, Xatalos, vonKlaust, imallinson, ArcticFox, HiroPro
yomi (2): willz22912, BroodKingEXE
willz22912 (2): Acrofales, Dittert
Not voting: trumpetarn
It is now Night 1! Please submit all night actions to both GreYMisT and Snarfs. The night will end in 24 hours, on Saturday, Apr 14 11:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00).
Players who did not meet the activity requirements will be dealt with by the mods.
|
|
|
|
|
The even more interesting question about that is: How?
How did BroodKingEXE think he would contribute to the town if he voted someone he thought to be less scummy?
How?
I don't even.
|
Sigh.. He brought this upon himself though by making such a Mafia move and then giving up without even really trying to defend himself.
|
United Kingdom3482 Posts
Wow
I was not expecting that
How do make such a big scumslip as town?
|
I'm getting pretty tired and am going to bed in a matter of moments. It seems that I have work last week(I'm an extra worker), so I won't be as active from monday and forward as i've been up until now. Just a heads up.
I'll get back tomorrow. Hopefully we can solve this mess.
G'night.
|
Damn you Brood. Damn you to hell. That was the dumbest thing I think I've ever seen.
The mafia is laughing at us right now.
Gah. I'm gonna get some air. This is ridiculous.
|
Does trumpetarn get modkilled or replaced?
|
EBOWOWBO:
I meant next week, not last week.
|
Trumpetarn will be replaced
|
United Kingdom3482 Posts
Well if that's the case whoever replaces trumpetarn needs to do some catching up he never posted enough for us to get a solid read.
|
Also with that, I think I'm going to part from the thread as well for the (EU) night.
Good night to all the people in europe, and good evening to the americans! I'm out.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
